Scotto’s Wine Cellar

Have patronized the store many times.
Normally great, but I recently bought a relatively older wine from them (listed via the website) that was not advertised as torn label (nothing suggested the condition was other than excellent), and indeed the label was significantly — very much — torn when they presented the bottle to me. No mention was even made of it as they handed it to me — no acknowledgement or apology that it was not as advertised.
To be honest, I probably should have refused to accept the bottle or insisted on a discount, as is customary when an older bottle is being sold in less than perfect condition, but I needed that bottle (it was a particular vintage) for a gift on short notice, so I took it. That’s my fault, but it doesn’t change the nature of the interaction. I’m highly disappointed that I was given a torn label bottle even though that is NOT what I had agreed to purchase.

Wonderful local wine and spirits store. They have a really good selection and are very helpful. I also really appreciate that if I give them a price range, they don’t try to upsell me to wines or liquors that are more than the price range that I’m looking for. They’ve always come through with good suggestions and very reasonably priced wines.

Scottos is the cream of the crop. If you know wine, you will know why. If not, they will help! Always a good experience. Thanks Scottos!!!

Unfamiliar with the neighborhood, I Unilocaled and found this great family shop! Went in for 2 bottles before a dinner party. Great staff and worked with my budget. Nice selection and pricing.

I love Scotto’s and here’s why — As the neighborhood has changed to accommodate all of us Gentrifiers, Scotto’s remains a little oasis of old school Carroll Gardens.
I moved here fifteen years ago, when Court Street had a few bakeries, deli’s, some sketchy bars, and Scotto’s. (Union Market was a Blockbuster!)
Whenever I bought a bottle of wine, they would take payment, look at my credit card and say, «Thank you Kimi.» They still do.
When I got married eight years ago, I bought my wine and Champagne there. They not only gave me the 15% per case discount, but also LEANT ME a few boxes wine glasses — of course at no charge. They simply asked that I bring them back washed.
Scotto’s has a great selection of wines and spirits from around the world– great California wines, but also a large selection of French, Italian and Austrian Gruner Veltliners– (What I’m drinking now).
I’m loyal to this friendly shop, which always offers help, and I enjoy the packed isles of stacked cases of wines on sale, with hand-​written descriptions.
If my bags are too big or I have too many, I leave them by the counter, and have no problem turning sideways to let another customer pass.

Scotto’s is a wonderful liquor store (not just wine, as the name implies!). They stock a lot of products from local wineries and distilleries. This includes (but is definitely not limited to): Brooklyn Oenology, Breuckelen Gin, and whoever makes that Court Street wine).
When we were there, one of the founders from Breuckelen Gin was in the back giving out samples of their gin, whiskey, and gin/​whiskey blends. All delicious and worth trying if you’re a fan of either type of liquor. he was super friendly, and it was a good environment for a tasting (though not a lot of room in the back).
Other than that, the shop has a great selection of wine and gin. Though, I will say that their whiskey selection could use some help. Maybe I just overlooked it, but they really didn’t have that much in the way of mid-​top shelf bourbon.
Worth going to if it’s on your way or if you live nearby!

My goto place for purchasing French wine. Great selections without breaking your wallet.

Great wine store on Court street. Wonderful selection of wines, knowledgeable yet friendly staff at the right price.

The gentlemen helped me pick out a nice wine for a friend’s birthday party dinner and I know nothing about wine. Just his simple descriptions and persuasions made me buy the Cabernet Savignon, and mostly everyone at the party liked it. Gracias!

While visiting family in Brooklyn and on our way to a local pizzeria that is BYOB, we were baffled as all of the liquor stores/​wine shops were closed and thought we’d have to go without. As we approached Scotto’s, we noticed that Jim, the owner, was closing up shop so asked if he knew of another place that was open. He knew that we would not have much luck and re-​opened his shop just for us! As if that weren’t enough, he helped us to select the best wine for our budget that accompanied our dinner. He went above and beyond. The wines were excellent. Jim really has a passion for what he does and it shows not only by knowing his wines, also by the way he caters to his customers. When we visit NYC/​Brooklyn again, we’ll be sure to pay Scotto’s a visit. Thanks again Jim!

Best selection of wines in Carroll Gardens. Knowledgeable and friendly staff. Ask them questions, there are a lot of wines in that store, and many options at all price levels. They will help you, I promise!
Great selection of Long Island and Italian wines.

The owner is very friendly and helpful.
We always pick up wine from here. They have a great selection.

Good selection of wines, although I must gripe about the ID checking process.
Went in with two friends (both over 21) and purchased a bottle of wine. When it came time to pay, clerk asked for my ID (totally acceptable) and then the ID of both my friends. She had to scan them, which took a while, all for a bottle of wine. in BROOKLYN. what is this the deep south or some middle-​of-​the-​buttcrack-​mid-​west? I can’t lol
Other than that mostly good store. Just a bit off this wine store did that when countless others in Brooklyn do not do this.

Amazing service — always helpful, and Liana is a gem in there (I’m on a budget, and she knows exactly what I need). As the rating states: «As good as it gets!»

There’s a terrific neighborhood atmosphere at Scotto’s were the staff are friendly and knowledgeable. They carry a good selection of local, regional, and imported wines and liquors. Their prices are very reasonable, and great discounts when you buy by the case.

Arrived at Lucali for some supposedly incredible pizza, only to find out that they are BYOB. Solution: find nearest wine shop.
That happened to be Scotto’s.
We rolled inside, asked the guy working for some red table wine. Following his recommendation, we grabbed a pair of Cali Shiraz, paid the man, and went to dinner.
The wines were awesome and at exactly the price we wanted to pay (10 per).
It saddens me that I won’t be in Gowanus more often. Because I would definitely go back. If you find yourself dry at Lucali, I suggest you do exactly what we did!

A fantastic family owned business! They are always friendly and offer great wine suggestions for wine dummies like me & the boy ;)

Cheap prices for name-​brand liquor. Very reasonable wine (unlike the other stores in the area). Extremely helpful staff. I love this place!
For instance, today we stopped by to look for a good white wine for mussels. I grabbed a $ 10 white based on the helpful label provided by the staff, then asked a staff member if it was appropriate for steamed mussels. He said, «Yes, absolutely — are you white wine drinkers?» When I told him no, not really, he said, «I can suggest a cheaper white if it’s just for cooking.»
So nice. It doesn’t just seem to be about the bottom line here, and I appreciate that. I’ll walk five or ten extra minutes to come here instead of the other neighborhood wine/​liquor stores.

A great liquor store in my new neighborhood. Prices and selection are good, and the folks who work there are knowledgeable and very friendly. And, they now stock Crème de Violette, which I’ve been dying to try. Sweet!

We LOVE this store and the people who work there.
They have a really nice selection of wine (with plenty of roses!) which is very accessible + they have a great skill with food and wine matching.
I often run in and tell them what we’re having for dinner and go home with a really lovely bottle that compliments it beautifully.
Scotto’s is one of the best things about living in this part of Brooklyn.
Thanks, Scottos!