Catalina’s Pizza & Subs

Catalina’s sits right next to Little Caeser’s in a strip mall. C’mon people, that’s not really a Monty Hall moment, you know which door to pick!
While Catalina’s does have one table for four inside, this is really a carry-​out place. The wife and I hit it up for a rare Monday night pizza and ordered our normal pep and shroom. Mondays and Tuesdays are quite the bargain at Catalina’s ($ 8.50 for a one topping large!)
The pizza is C’Bus style, square cut with toppings to the edge. The crust is slightly thicker than most. The peps had a good meaty flavor, but the shrooms appeared to be canned (a cardinal sin in my pizza world). The ratios were all good. The star of this pizza was definitely the sauce. The sauce was more tart than most.. . the first taste sensation was all tart, followed by «mmm, robust and herby» and closing again on a tart note. The side show of meatballs was again stolen by the sauce (the same sauce, I believe).
All in all, Catalina’s serves up an A-​OK pizza — nothing overly remarkable about it, but A-​OK.

We tried their pizza, salad and a sub. Not bad. Pizza had good flavor, salad was good and sub was good. Will it make me not order DONATOS or Classics not sure but not bad.
On the bad side we were told delivery would take 45 –60 minutes. It was an hour and twenty minutes. That must change!
Overall like I said before not bad.

Folks, this is seriously good pizza. Fortunately it is in no way related to the former Rofini’s at this location. I must say it is better than Massey’s and that’s saying something. Delicious sauce, good toppings (pepperoni pizza is A++) and excellent crisp crust. Prices are reasonable too. Subs are good… the ham & cheese is excellent. Highly recommend this place.

Went in and there was one person in the back banging around. After ten minutes of waiting for the sole worker to come out I left.

This is the pizza place that replaced Rofini’s pizza. They do delivery and carryout. We had a $ 5 off $ 25 total so we decided to give them a try. Their buffalo wings are large and pretty good, the sauce is not that hot and not really real saucy but the wings are large enough that they’re worth it. They are a bit fatty though my girlfriend noticed but not overly so. The Italian sub was pretty good as well, although not as good as Rofini’s but the amount of meat on the sub was decent and they really nailed the «traditional» italian sub taste. Their Italian sub was served hot and was delivered still warm enough that it didn’t require reheating. My girlfriend really liked her meatball sub. She did add onions to it. They put plenty of sauce on it.
The pizza itself is quite good. It’s an «Ohio» style pizza which is edge to edge toppings with it being cut square ala Donatos. They put plenty of toppings on their pizza. We ordered the deluxe which is pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green peppers and sausage. One thing to note, their vegetables are cut a little thick, especially their mushrooms so if you have someone who doesn’t like a particular vegetable, such as the mushroom you may want to only order on half of it. On the other hand, if you’re like me and absolutely love the thicker cut mushrooms (such as what Marcos has) then you’ll really love this pizza.
Oh and in regards to cheese, we got extra cheese and it was a decent amount of cheese but I think if we hadn’t we may have been unhappy with the amount of cheese. So if you want a decent amount of cheese, especially if you’re getting multiple toppings I’d highly suggest ordering extra cheese.
All in all Catalinas is pretty good, nothing extraordinary but a great value and well worth the money especially if you find a good coupon and much much better than a Donatos or chain pizza. We will definitely be ordering from them again at some point in the future.
P. S. They were pretty fast delivery too, we got our pizza in 30 minutes when they had told us it’d be 45 minutes on the phone.