The Randall Manor Tavern

Staten Island, United States

3.8

Closed now

13 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 347-855-2724
Website:
www.randallmanortavern.com
Address:
735 Castleton Ave, Staten Island, NY, 10310
Westerleigh
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
1.2 miBroadway/Richmond Ter parada donde bajamos del S54
1.3 mi1st Street at Avenue C
1.3 miRichmond Ter/Broadway parada donde tomar el S40
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Takes Reservations
No
Delivery
Yes
Take-out
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Parking
Street, Private Lot
Bike Parking
Yes
Good for Kids
Yes
Good for Groups
Yes
Attire
Casual
Ambience
Casual
Noise Level
Average
Music
Juke Box
Good For Dancing
No
Alcohol
Full Bar
Happy Hour
No
Best Nights
Sat
Coat Check
No
Smoking
Outdoor Area/ Patio Only
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Has TV
Yes
Waiter Service
Yes

Today

Today 11:30 am – 11:00 pm
Closed now
Local time (Staten Island) 00:07 Saturday, 14 June 2025

Business hours

Monday 11:30 am – 10:00 pm
Tuesday 11:30 am – 10:00 pm
Wednesday 11:30 am – 10:00 pm
Thursday 11:30 am – 10:00 pm
Friday 11:30 am – 11:00 pm
Saturday 11:30 am – 11:00 pm
Sunday 11:30 am – 10:00 pm

Related places

You might also consider:
640
ft
Coadys Emerald Pub
1371 Forest Avenue (Westerleigh)
1
mi
Randazzo’s Clam Bar
747 Forest Ave (West Brighton)
1
mi
O’Neills
1614 Forest Ave (Westerleigh)
1.4
mi
Nurnberger Bierhaus
817 Castleton Ave (West Brighton)
1.5
mi
West Cork Union Hall
502 Henderson Ave (West Brighton)
1.5
mi
Joe Broadway’s Billiards & Sports Pub
2178 Forest Ave (Graniteville)

Nearby

Near this location:
60
ft
DR Communications
1298 Forest Ave
60
ft
R R G L Enterprises
1298 Forest Avenue
70
ft
Aadobe Animal Hospital
1294 Forest Ave
120
ft
Port Richmond Glass
1288 Forest Avenue
120
ft
Boro Carpet & Upholstery Cleaners
71 Hamlin Pl
150
ft
G-Knows Cheesesteaks
1310 Forest Avenue

13 reviews of The Randall Manor Tavern

No registration required
Place rating: 5
Boca Raton, FL
Excellent place for American grill. Really cool atmosphere for drinks too, they have an awesome outdoor bar for the warmer months! The staff is friendly and its moderately priced. Definitely a great spot!!!
Place rating: 4
Staten Island, NY
Sometimes you just keep it simple stupid.
Randall Manor is a simple spot with good service, and good food. Staff is always courteous and do their best to be quick on busy nights. The bar has a great local feel, without the pretentiousness that all new bars seem to want.
Stop in on a random night and grab a beer and some good food. Leave the chain restaurants to the animals and kids!
Place rating: 5
Staten Island, NY
Roasted Pumpkin Ravioli with truffle oil simply amazing. Nice bartender, laid back atmosphere, higher level cuisine, mature clientele, interesting beer selection… good place to chill. Plenty of tvs playing sports as well.
Place rating: 4
Staten Island, NY
I thought the burgers here were great, then I had the pulled pork sandwich. Holy crap. Staff is friendly and attentive, the first time I was here I already felt like a regular. I love a good onion ring, and this place does em right.
Place rating: 3
Brooklyn, NY
This is just the run of the mill bar. Service was hit or miss and prices were average. I was honestly expecting something better than a $ 4 Bud Light on a Tuesday afternoon in the middle of Staten Island but it’s certainly not much to complain about. They do have a full menu but I didn’t have anything to eat this time around. I liked that they had a spacious back patio area complete with a full bar (not open when I was there). It wasn’t the most comfortable feeling back area as they just put a fence blocking off part of the gravel parking lot but still it was a nice and unexpected feature of the bar. I wasn’t blown away by the place and wouldn’t suggest going out of your way for a visit but if you live/​work nearby I wouldn’t avoid them entirely.
Place rating: 3
Graniteville, Staten Island, NY
Great menu full of all sorts of good food. I’ve had the burgers and I’ve Had most of their soups. I will be returning. The patrons were cool too. Made you feel welcome even made suggestions on what to order. Watched the game and enjoyed the experience.
Place rating: 4
Staten Island, NY
The Randall Manor is a Irish Bar.
Not your corporate run Disneyesque Celtic-​themed sports bar
with tartan & shamrocks all over, and
Not your dark & sometimes gloomy I.R.A. Irish Bar where they look at you sideways if you order a Bushmills.
The Randall Manor is a Irish Bar because
The Bartender is Irish
The Waitress is Irish
The Patrons are Irish
and IMHO that’s the best definition of a Irish Bar.
The Randall Manor has a pretty full menu, but we tried the burger
and we’re glad we did, the burgers were tasty and
the chef is a Badass for knowing how to cook one a true Medium Rare!
Mine came stacked with bacon & blue cheese
& Stef had swiss & mushroom
the french fries were fresh cut the way it should be.
Kelly our waitress was charming & helpful.
Next visit I’m going to try the Fish & Chips.
Place rating: 2
Staten Island, NY
Service is good, wait staff is very attentive and on top of getting drinks and other miscellaneous occurrences but the food just never «wows» me. I have tried there food numerous times and nothing makes me want to scream out or make sure I come back to have it again. I have had the steak, the Mac n cheese, the special ravioli, and the burger. All of them were okay, and the burger was cooked nicely but nothing that set it apart and made me want to go back
Also, I was charged for ice in my drink! How do you charge someone extra for ice??? They are all about extra charges here. Anything you ask is an extra charge on the bill. Be warned
Place rating: 4
Staten Island, NY
This place has great food. The chef/​owner is a CIA graduate and super creative. I have not had anything here that I haven’t loved. The burger is the best on the Staten Island… Hands down! Love the Irish nachos and the Jamaican jerk chicken wings are a nice change of pace. Also try the shrimp PO’ Boy and bacon wrapped meatloaf. The dinner specials are always fresh and creative. This place is sooo much more than a bar. A can’t miss for a great neighborhood meal and night out. Great food, great cocktails and great people. Highly recommend it.
Place rating: 4
Staten Island, NY
Great food great service was there twice– once for lunch once for dinner. Food was incredible both times. Lunch was loud but it is a bar. The dessert is delicious and huge.
Place rating: 4
Staten Island, NY
Good local place with great burgers and great desserts. The atmosphere is definitely for a «regular» crowd who stay at the bar for hours. We noticed when we were about to leave there is a back area with about 4 picnic tables and I plan on going back as it gets warmer.
Place rating: 4
Staten Island, NY
The food was really good, for a functioning we had here within the last year. The service was likewise, very friendly & helpful, we would come back for lunch or dinner.
Place rating: 4
Staten Island, NY
This place opened about a year ago. the bar is really nice, they have everything. and they have Magner’s cider (for me this is major cause im obsessed with ciders).the food is awesome. especially as far as bar food goes. the crab cakes, the burgers, gorgonzola salad, everything I’ve had there has been great. they’ve got a great chef which is unexpected for a bar/​tavern. the décor is really nice and what I look for in a bar which is dimly lit and dark wood. they have internet jukebox, outdoor space/​seating in the back, and quickdraw!.. this is my go to bar now that RH Tugs has closed