All Star Cafe & Pizzeria

Staten Island, United States

3.6

Closed now

10 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 718-227-2000
Website:
www.allstarcafenyc.com
Address:
694 Arthur Kill Rd, Staten Island, NY, 10308
Great Kills
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
0.9 miGreat Kills
1 miEltingville
1.1 miArthur Kill Rd/United HEB Cem
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Takes Reservations
No
Delivery
Yes
Take-out
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Bike Parking
No
Good for Kids
Yes
Good for Groups
No
Attire
Casual
Alcohol
No
Outdoor Seating
No
Wi-Fi
No
Has TV
No
Waiter Service
Yes
Caters
Yes

Today

Today 10:00 am – 12:00 am
Closed now
Local time (Staten Island) 08:09 Saturday, 31 May 2025

Business hours

Monday 10:00 am – 11:00 am
Tuesday 10:00 am – 11:00 am
Wednesday 10:00 am – 11:00 am
Thursday 10:00 am – 11:00 am
Friday 10:00 am – 12:00 am
Saturday 10:00 am – 12:00 am
Sunday 10:00 am – 10:00 pm

Description

Specialties

Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant

Sit Down, Fast Delivery, Wine & Beer, Catering for your Special Events

We serve the best Italian Cuisine and the best pizza with super fast delivery. We proudly deliver to 10 308, 10 314, 10 309 and 10 312.

Just call us and we will be deliver right to your door

History

Established in 1986.

All Star Café Pizzeria & Restaurant opened in the spring of 1986, with a vision of creating Staten Island’s finest Italian Cuisine dining experience. We infuse every dish created with a passion for perfection. With our tasty signature dishes and mouth watering Italian Pizza, we have quite an eclectic menu. Never losing sight of what it takes to create fine Italian dining, we know that in order to create the dishes we want to share with Staten Islander’s we must only use the freshest ingredients available. Delivery, take out or dine in.

Meet the Business Owner

Mortybella M.

Business Owner

Located in the center of Staten Island’s historic Atrium Shopping Complex, All Star Café Pizzeria & Restaurant serves up Staten Island’s finest Italian fare with exciting dishes and taste tempting pizza.

At All Star Café Pizzeria & Restaurant, every dish is created using only the freshest, finest ingredients.

We serve only the finest meats and seafood, freshest vegetables, and breads that are baked fresh daily. Our award winning menu and attention to detail create a truly enjoyable dine in experience.

We serve the best Italian Cuisine and the best pizza with super fast delivery. We proudly deliver to 10 308, 10 314, 10 309 and 10 312. Just call us and we will be deliver right to your door.

Related places

You might also consider:
1
mi
Nonna’s Pizzeria
27 Brower Ct (Great Kills)
1
mi
Benvenuti Pizzeria e Trattoria
15 Giffords Ln (Great Kills)
1
mi
Pronto Pizza
3297 Richmond Ave
1
mi
Kingdom Cafe
4350 Amboy Rd (Great Kills)
1
mi
Village Pizzaria
3995 Amboy Rd (Great Kills)
1
mi
The Original Giuseppe’s Pizza
4300 Amboy Road (Great Kills)

Nearby

Browse nearby places:
70
ft
Preferred Discount Auto Parts
686 Arthur Kill Rd
160
ft
Dunkin’ Donuts
680 Arthur Kill Rd
220
ft
Atrium Furniture
680 Arthur Kill Rd
310
ft
Planet Wings
698 Arthur Kill Rd
360
ft
Atrium Cinemas
680 Arthur Kill Rd
380
ft
Walgreens
758 Arthur Kill Rd

10 reviews of All Star Cafe & Pizzeria

No registration required
Place rating: 5
Staten Island, NY
The best pizza you can have in Staten Island
Place is very clean, price is good, taste is great & the owner is friendly A+
Place rating: 5
Midland Beach, Staten Island, NY
True New York pizza. Savory sauce, just the right amount of cheese, enough oil to let drip on the plate but not so much that it’s running down your hand and a thin but not wafer thin and crispy crust. Best pizza on the island.
Place rating: 5
Great Kills, Staten Island, NY
Not sure why this location is getting such bad reviews. I happen to love this place! The plain pies are ok but the speciality pies are great! Try the buffalo chicken or loaded veggie pies. Also — they make a great rice ball supreme with ricotta, mozz and sauce. Never had a problem with delivery.
Place rating: 3
Brooklyn, NY
Foods not bad. Delivery is pretty bad tho. They always somehow screw up the order. Last time I ordered for pick up, I asked the guy for extra dressing for the salad I ordered and he gave me an attitude because I didn’t know which dressing the salad came with. Isn’t that something the person working there should know? He demanded that I go out to the car and check which one he gave me. Whe I said why don’t you just look at them menu to see he rolled his eyes. Another time I asked for lettuce on a wrap and they cooked the lettuce.
Place rating: 3
West Hempstead, NY
Went here for the first time and ordered a. Meatball parmesian sandwich. It was served up hot and fresh but overall I would say it was average. All star has a good variety of other sandwiches to choose from most of which are italian, e.g. Chicken parm, shrimp parm, meatball park, etc. you can also get deli sandwiches on a kaiser roll if you choose. Additionally as the name states it is a pizzeria with a good variety of pies and slices. Cashier/​waiter was very friendly and brought the food to the table and wished me well. I would definitely come back and try their other fare as an alternative to the subway, Chinese and other places nearby. God place to sit and have lunch before or after a movie at the atrium theater.
Place rating: 3
Arden Heights, Staten Island, NY
Average slices. I’ve never been to this pizzeria prior to this and it’s really close to home. I had a slice because I was starving wasn’t that bad. It was great either. Today’s weather isn’t the hottest, but at 93 degrees why don’t you have the air on in this establishment?
Place rating: 4
Staten Island, NY
This place has good pizza, good salads and good wraps. I’m a fan of their chicken ceasar salad or wrap. I recently had the fried eggplant wrap, which hit the spot. Their vodka pie is good and so is their regular. They have a large menu to choose from, so you have a variety of options. They do deliver & they’re pretty quick. It’s near the movie theatre, so you can always grab something before going in or coming out. I look forward to trying other options in the near future.
Place rating: 2
Staten Island, NY
Pizza is average at best.
Place rating: 4
Staten Island, NY
You can call me a regular at this pizza place. Only a few blocks away from my house, its the best pizza I have ever had! Try the Fresh Mootz Pie with Maranara sauce. It is a little pricy for pizza so not a place to order from every week if cash is a problem but if you like pizza, its worth every penny! Could not be happier. Just wish it was a tad bit cheaper. Its also a very nice place to sit down and eat. They have a TV that usually shows NY1 and a radio on, (TV Has closed captions on).
Highly recommend!
–John
BTW For you Jersey Shore Fan’s, Vinny’s family owns the place! You can see his step dad almost everytime you walk in!
Place rating: 2
Staten Island, NY
Use to be good, now pizza is absolutely horrible, and call it burnt as well. One thing I recommend you would try which was the only thing I like in this restaurant is the calzone. 2 stars for having one bad dish and one good dish.