It’s All Greek To Me

Horrible. Don’t even bother. Pizza is really not good. I would not go there again.

Best pizza slices south of 347 in port jeff. Nice service. Middle of everything downtown. Winner for cheap eats.

Walked in to this place, and was instantly greeted by a common Italian reassuring ornament with a broken (what I can only assume was part of a violin) instrument in his hands, and his cheerful smile under his cliché tinseled mustache. Past the blue painted walls behind a counter of pizzas of different sorts stood two gentlemen, of who both were just as reassuring as their only restaurant decoration. I ordered the buffalo chicken, and BBQ chicken with two garlic knots. Decently priced, and after an average wait time of six minutes I opened my box and there they were, exactly what I ordered. Baffled, I decided to indulge to my delight the buffalo, BBQ, and doubled knots. Will most certainly be back to try this chicken bacon ranch people have been raving about.

This place has turned around. Been here several times since my last update. Pizza is great and the staff is super friendly! Really tasty garlic knots too.

This place has the best pizza in downtown Port Jeff, hands down. It reminds me of the pizza I would get in Brooklyn on boozy weekends out. The prices are really great. Got 3 slices of pizza today and two sodas for under $ 11.00. The sauce is spectacular and their slices are big.
The owner is really nice and always takes the time to make you feel welcome. He makes the best baklava I have had in years. Being Greek, I get cravings for baklava and usually have to travel kind of far to get it. Now I can drive less than 5 minutes and get my baklava on.
The place is small and standing room only. On weekends it can get crowded, so I would recommend getting the pizza to go and enjoying your food down by the harbor. So for all you tourists coming to town that want to try real NY pizza… this is the place to go.

I used to swear Colosseo was the best Pizza around. i love Pizza and living in the village I decided to try Its all greek to Me. I got hooked on their Chicken bacon Ranch, I get it every time I stop in. (a lot) Also their Meatball Parm hero is great and so is the pepperoni Garlic knots. I still go to Colosseo but not nearly as often. No dis to Colosseo their Pizza is still great.

Nice try, was great when it was not absentee owner. Went there once a week when the owner was there. I dont go anymore. Food went downhill.

if there’s anything you should keep your heads up for it’s the philly cheese steaks that are soon to come, i’ve tried a philly made from mike at this place and it by far rivals any steak from tony luke’s or geno’s.
the fresh tomato and mozzarella make for a cheese steak that eats like juicy cheese steak but has that slight taste of a gourmet pizza.
I will definitely be back for sure, and can’t wait for the the next one!

This place has managed to not only be the best Greek food in Port Jefferson, but by far the best Pizza place as well.
This is a tiny little place that seats (stands) about 10 right next to Dunkin Donuts on Main Street. It has changed hands a few times over the past few years, but All Greek took over what I would think is about 6 months ago. Prices are reasonable and service is quick.
Most importantly, the food is terrific. Gyro, greek salads, etc are fresh and delicious. The pizza is outstanding. Regular slice has a great taste and thickness to it, reminds me a lot of Aegean in the Sun Vet mall which has had some of the best pizza around for decades. Specialty slices like Chicken Bacon Ranch and Buffalo Chicken are outstanding as well. Always some special roll, pinwheel, greek specialty available as well.
Service is super quick and very friendly. Same few guys and a girl or two are always there, always make conversation and make sure you are happy with your order. They run a few slice lunch specials and have Sunday football and other type of catering-​like specials as well. They’ll remember you by name after a few visits.
Maybe the best thing about the place for the PJ local is it’s open until the bars close on Friday and Saturday night. Prices don’t change, neither does the quality. Owner is there himself at 3am on many nights.
For the pizza or greek lover who doesn’t want to fight 112 to Colosseo or Zorba, you’ll be just as satisfied here.