Taylor Street Pizza

Ordered from here a few days ago. The worker at the font said it was under new management. I was skeptical, but the pizza made up for it. It was so good. Perfectly cooked to my specifications. Didn’t skimp on the cheese and the crust was perfect. I didn’t have a coupon and he even offered to look one up for me! Such a nice guy! We also ordered one of the combos they have and the burger was DELICIOUS. definitely going to order from here all the time!!!

Great service, great pizza, and quick delivery. Can’t ask for anything more from a pizza place. I recommend this gem all the time to friends and family.

Not the same it used to be. Noticeable change In the quality and quantity of food. Very nice people and good service.

We had a couple slices from this place the other day and they were GOOD. Very pleasantly surprised. Fluffy crust, good sausage and pepperoni, lots of cheese. Just good pizza. Check it out.

As I said I have stopped in for slices a couple of times. I have noticed that This place has stepped up their service big time. The lady at the counter was delightful in helping me make my lunch selection. She said they remodeled and I have to say the store looks pretty good then what it did before. They now have led tvs instead of a chalkboard for the menu board. I walked in for lunch and see that they have lunch specials everyday. I got the #4 cheesy beef. Special came with fries and a pop for 8 $ bucks. Price is average. While I waited I heard a music speaker in the background of Tony Bennett’s rags to riches song haha I thought I was sitting in on a scene from Goodfellas. Nice touch Taylor street, nice touch.

This place used to be our go to for the perfect thin crust pizza. Have lived in Naperville for 10 years and have been going here since day 1. The last two times we got it, everything changed. The cheese, sauce, the crust was thicker, literally a completely different pizza. Pretty sure they changed owners so this could be why? They also stopped doing the coupons on the box that you collect to get a discount. One time we even placed our delivery order and then almost 30 minutes later they called to cancel our order saying it was «out of delivery area» even though they delivered to our place countless times in the past! Sadly, yesterday’s dry, overcooked, cardboard tasting pizza will be the last we ever get from Taylor Street. What a shame.

I’m kinda upset I didn’t receive the correct Philly I ordered. It was delicious, that’s why they got 4 stars, missed out on 5 stars b/​c was missing lettuce and tomatoes. I’m sure I got charge more for the extras too. Check your order. But OMG, delicious!

I ordered 3 individual slices of pizza for take out. Delivery was fast, granted we live down the street. When I first saw the pizza, the slices were pretty big. One slice was definitely sufficient enough for a meal. However the pizza was bland. It definitely needed some flavor. There was a lot of crust and it was very doughy. It was a tad much in my opinion.
If you need something for on the go, this is a great place to get something to eat.

I used to order from here all the time when I first moved to the area, but I discovered other places with better pizza and better delivery
Their pizza isn’t bad, but there’s nothing special about it either. I have also had their sandwiches and wings and their chicken wrap, which actually is pretty good. The sandwiches and wings are average at best. As far as their pizza goes, I prefer their double dough over their thin crust and they also sell slices all day.
My biggest knocks are their delivery service and that they close fairly early on Friday and Saturday nights.

Pizza is one of the easiest foods to make so it’s irritating when a pizza shows up at your doorstep tasting like cardboard and government cheese. No worries about that happening at this place! I’ve had just about everything that they offer — thin, pan, double dough, even their wings — not a bad pizza on the menu.
If you can’t find a pizza you like on their menu it’s because your tongue is broken and need to see a doctor.

I placed an order for delivery, it took around 40 minutes to get here, so that’s pretty normal. The delivery guy was wearing sweats. and looked dirty. He set the pizza carrier on the floor, which is kinda gross. and when I handed the receipt back to him he looked at the tip I gave him ($ 4.00) and shook his head like he was mad. The pizza was really good though.

A little pricey for pizza, but it is really good! If you want to splurge on a really good pizza, this is the place.
The slices to-​go aren’t nearly as good as the full pizzas you order. Not only are they sitting out for a little bit, but the dough is overwhelming in my opinion.
I’ve always had speedy service whenever I’ve stopped in. I usually only order when I stumble across a coupon.

When I lived down the street, this was our go-​to pizza joint. We always ordered the same thing, and received exactly what we ordered. That is, until about six weeks ago.
The other half threw out the ol’ «I buy, you fly» bit (in this case, I’d make the phone call for delivery). So I proceed to call and place our order: a large, thin crust with pepperoni and black olive, with a coupon to upsize our order for free. (Like I said, our usual).
For starters, the kid on the phone answers «Thanks for calling Taylor Street Pizza HOLD» in one breath before I could say «Okay.» A few minutes later he came back on the line and asked what I wanted. I gave him my order, paid over the phone including a generous tip on my other half’s credit card. I asked him to repeat the order back (considering he seemed unsure when he typed it in the computer), which he did, so I hung up. They usually quote us an hour for delivery but the longest we ever had to wait was 30 minutes.
About twenty minutes later, our pizza arrived. We open the box to discover a pizza with black olives and pineapple. My other half quickly flagged down the driver and said that there was a mistake; we wanted pepperoni, not pineapple. The driver apologized and took the pizza back.
So, I get on the phone and call TSP back. The kid answers. I proceed to ask him how we received a pizza with incorrect toppings, when I had him verify my order after placing it, and not only that, it even stated «pepperoni» on the receipt. The kid mumbled something about hitting an incorrect button or something along those lines. I then asked what he planned on doing to rectify the situation. He said «I could make a new pizza?» Well, gee– that’d be great. But how about a free 2 liter of pop or something? I don’t know. He said they were making a new pizza and it would be delivered shortly. No apologies for the inconvenience, and no other «peace» offering. Before I could ask for the manager, he hung up.
Sure, I could have just called back and asked for the manager. But at that point, the damage was already done, and I really didn’t care anymore. Our correct pizza arrived, albeit partially burnt, and you could clearly tell it was made in a hurry (cheese and toppings just «thrown on» and then tossed in the oven).
Seeing as we’ve moved, I’m certainly not sad to lose this place as our go-​to pizza joint.

Best pizza in town! Taylor Street is our go to place for amazing pizza. Double Dough with extra cheese is our favorite. Haven’t gone to the location, but their delivery is always fast and fresh.

Live near Taylor Street Pizza but had never checked them out before… until last night that is.
I was so excited to find out that they have Pizza by the Slice all day long and think that I might gain a few pounds with this new knowledge. I had a piece of the sausage pizza, it wasn’t as hot as a fresh pizza would be but 20sec in the microwave and the cheese was malty and delicious again. Very good pizza, not too much sauce, the sausage is mild and they add enough cheese that I didn’t want to add more at home.
I also tried a Panzerotti for the first time ever… basically, it’s a fried calzone which sounds amazing but wasn’t as good as I thought it could be. I think the issue is that I really like calzones and enjoy most breads and crusts; I’m a bit of a carbaholic actually. When the dough is fried however, it makes it tough to cut and to eat. The Panzerotti is a vessel for delicious gooey melty cheese and meat, but the outside is a bit too crisp and greasy; Not my favorite. I’m glad I tried it but think I will stick with a calzone next time.
I called my order in but got carryout. The service was good and the guy that I phoned my order into was the same one who checked me out at the register.
Very positive experience overall and I can’t wait to try something else on my next visit!

I don’t know why this place only has ³¹⁄₂ stars. My husband and I just moved to Naperville and we notice Taylor street pizza and wanted something quick so we decided to give it a try. My husband loves deep dish so we got pepperoni, sausage, and mushroom. The staff was real friendly and answered all our questions. It was so tasty and we love the way they caramelize the cheese on the top. I think they could use more cheese but never the less this is our new go to pizza place.

After winning a gift card for a fund raiser, I went for an XL pepperoni thin crust. I was told upon arrival I had to use it all or loose it, on one trip.
Lady at the counter wasn’t in too good of a mood or very helpful. Their slices are too doughy for me… but I got one anyway. She tried to get me to add a two liter. Should have got a salad instead.
As the picture shows, a $ 20 pie should be covered in cheese. If you like your pie with as much cheese as a frozen one, than this is your place. I like to have cheese in every bit.
Half hour round trip, so I won’t be going back but it was nice of the owner to offer the raffle prize, so I’ll throw in an extra star.

In spite of memories I have of eating this pizza with my ex-​in-​laws, I still come back here when I’m in this part of town. This thin crust is the real deal– it’s a nice crispy crust with just the right amount of sauce and toppings. My personal favorite here is the extra sausage well done. Their sausage is perfect here– it’s super mild tasting and is pretty good quality, there’s no fennel noticeable in it. They bake the pizza perfectly when it’s well done, it has a nice caramelized cheese on top that is amazing.
The salads are lousy, and the slices for sale are nothing like the whole pies.
This is definitely a carryout place. There’s a picnic table and a few flimsy chairs inside. I’ve always been happy with the staff (on the phone and in person), so no knocks there. The thin crust pizza here is the real deal. Definitely in my top 10 all time favorites.

The woman taking my order on the phone was a mess and put me on hold several times for long periods. After about 10 minutes, I had to hand the phone to my husband so I could attend to my toddler son. I thought delivery pizza was supposed to be the easy choice for dinner! Finally we were able to get our order in after about 15 minutes of being on hold, being told the computer was down, being asked our address several times, etc. The price was really expensive but we figured we would roll with it since it took so long to order. Pizza arrived and was disappointing. Overall flavor was good — good cheese and sauce — but the crust was not good. It was very crispy. That being said, we are not native Chicagoans and prefer our pizza East Coast style, so take this review with a grain of salt. We will not re-​order from here and our quest for good delivery pizza continues!

I love Taylor Street Pizza. It’s right across the street from me which leads to danger and often kills my diet. But I don’t care, I’ll die a pizza infused early death. Their pizza isn’t fancy, but it’s just consistent and down right good pizza. I’ve never ordered a bad pizza from the place. Try the thin crust and you can’t go wrong.
The sandwiches are also top-​notch. I often order the combo with marinara sauce on it. It is one of most delicious things in nature. I could eat that every night as well. I also like the staff as well. Everyone is pretty cool and they really appreciate your business. It’s so great to find a pizza place like this in the area.