Pizza Paradiso

If you’re looking for a casual, easy/​relatively quick dinner (as opposed to a sit-​down restaurant with wait service) in this area of Maui, Pizza Paradiso is worth a try. I enjoyed the Chicken Shawarma and would recommend that — not the best I’ve ever had but not bad at all. They actually have a pretty big menu, which is nice.

The falafel was very delicious and the waiters were really nice and friendly. We even went back a second time and got the godfather pizza which was pretty good think crust pizza. It is a great easy good place.

Came here on a Friday afternoon and ordered a couple slices of pizza. The pizza itself was quite good, however the staff was very disorganized. It took about 20 minutes to get five slices of pizza that were already premade heated up and served.

So glad we found a place on the westside that has gyros and they have a yummy tobuleh green salad with it.

I love this place! Everything on the menu is absolutely delicious. I have always ordered the pasta dishes and my husband the subs. But… We order a pizza the other day and it was seriously the best pizza that I have ever had. It was thin, crispy, cheese was stringy and delicious. I cannot say enough good things about this place. Yummmm

Pizza Paradiso has THE BEST gluten free pizza I’ve ever had! The crust is thicker than what you normally find for gluten free & taste just like a regular pizza crust. I had the Maui Wowy. My husband had the regular pizza & pesto bread & thought it was delicious. Also, don’t skip the gelato! The coconut gelato was incredible. We ate here twice while on vacation for a week.

Very busy place, I love the margarita pizza, Godfather pizza and spaghetti is so good!

This little joint almost lost out on free money today. They serve gyros and pizzas as separate dishes. So I figured I could get them to put the shaved meat on a pizza. They’ve got all the ingredients right? But that’s a no go, supposedly a pricing issue. I specifically said I would gladly pay extra. Just laziness, really. So I asked to speak with a manager, and 15 minutes later he came out and said no problem. I did pay quite a bit extra, but idgaf. It was a damn good pizza. And they gave me some complimentary tzatziki sauce, A++

I recommend the gyro with lamb and beef. Super good! I also ordered the chicken shawarma. Both meals had fresh salad with garbanzo beans which was much needed after a hot day at the beach. It was refreshing and healthy! Keep in mind these plates were pretty pricey ($ 11-​$ 12). I would come here again.

Shawarma is made on pita but you can’t ask for a topping not given on it. I really don’t like how struck they are about a made to order item. Food is ok. I would rather go to any of the other places that don’t mind leaving off a topping I don’t like, but alway down to try a new place.

Excellent pizza and a very friendly place. It is Christmas time and they are very busy. Still they managed to put out a great thin crust pizza.

½ way through our vacation, my husband decided to break a few bones in his body. Thus, we were cooped up in our condo for the rest of the vacation.
Because we only had one car for the whole family, and normally it was being used by the adventurers of the group, I was cast with the duty to find food. While walking across the street I ran in to Pizza Paradiso. Thin crust goodness. I bought 3 large pizzas that lasted maybe 10 minutes in the condo with all the hungry mouths. The pizza was SO GOOD, and fresh that after we left the family went back again two more times for pizza before they left the island.
I am happy that to say that the staff was very friendly, helpful and they had a few specials going on! SO GLAD that I found a great PIzza joint within walking distance.

LOVE, Pizza Paradiso!
Best pizza around.
Super fresh ingredients, great service, great prices.
What more can I say?
Oh, there’s something for everyone.

Might be referred to as a fast food Pizza, Mediterranean restaurant
Surprisingly good pizza and other displayed food appeared to be fresh. A busy store but quick on food delivery! Store staff were friendly and helpful

Beef Kabob Combo and 2 slices pepperoni pizza with a Pepsi was $ 28.44. Value for this entire meal was… maybe $ 2.00 for the pepsi.
Beef Kabob was marketed as a tenderloin of beef. It came with 5 pieces of fat that wasn’t even close to being edible, 8 ounces of rice, one 1oz cup of hummus and a 1oz cup of dressing and a few pieces of bread. The pizza was dry and had been sitting out for a long time before I ordered it.
The seats, tables and floors were filthy. I can’t believe I spent $ 28 on inedible food.
Do not waste your time here!!! This should be a zero stars!

Pizza Paradiso is back on the list of places to go. We gave it another shot because we used to like it so much and this time we had a good experience. Food was good. Also learned they have a $ 6 lunch special (see pic) which is nice with everything being so expensive in Maui. Only negative was the gelato. I think their freezers are too cold or something; gelato shouldn’t be shaved out of the containers and be in frozen chunks. Skip that; otherwise we were pleased with our dinners.

Thought we would order a pizza to go. Called ahead for a pick up order and requested a large Maui Wowie (pineapple and ham) so we would have left overs. The employee was very nice and said he would discount it since we were ordering before 5pm, which I guess is standard as I saw that deal advertised too (came to $ 21 after the discount). We were told it would be ready in 15 minutes. We arrived on time and stood around waiting for someone to acknowledge us. After about 5 minutes a male came to the front counter and we paid for our pizza and a Cesar salad. There was some seating available but it wasn’t very inviting so I was glad we got it to go. I noticed other people were waiting for to go orders also.
The pizza was medium/​thin crust and DELICIOUS! Just how we like them… not a lot of sauce and just the right amount of cheese. Was very similar to Papa Murphy’s take and bake if you know that chain, but has an even better yeast/​sweet crust flavor!!! Not greasy or bland, but perfect! The Cesar salad was very good also. My husband and I split the salad, as they were prepackaged for $ 6.95 and was the perfect size for two side salads.
I’m embarrassed to say there were no left overs :(
We will gladly be back!

Decent tasting spaghetti, terrible portions for the dinner price ($ 13.49 w/​tax) The lunch portion is exactly the same size WITH garlic bread and half the price ($ 6.99). Definitely won’t eat here for dinner again.

This place is pretty pricey for pizzas as a Medium veggie pizza (12″) was $ 22 something. I tried one of their chicken pizza slices and it was good. Also got the Falafel sandwich wrap which was good. The falafel patties looked like they were baked instead of fried and still tasted good.

Friends from the Mainland took me to Pizza Paradiso for dinner. The food was very good. The pizza was a medium-​thin crust, and there were several selections available. There were also a few varieties of pasta, pita sandwiches, and sides (such as hummus and dolmades). The soda variety was Pepsi. There were some seats available inside the restaurant, but it looked like most people probably did take out to their home or hotel. All in all, it was very good, and I’ll keep it in mind when I’m on the West side.