Orange Leaf Frozen Yogurt

This Orange Leaf has all the typical components you would expect. I believe its a fairly new location. However, I will say that this one has been a little messier than other locations I have visited when I have come on the later side of the evening. Also, they usually have less fruit topping choices available than some other area locations as well.

Pretty good fro-​yo. This Orange Leaf looks fairly new as does the development it’s housed in. I stopped here after dinner at Cerulean because the person I was with has a sweet tooth yet paradoxically declined dessert at the restaurant.
First off, the cups come in two sizes — «big» and «soup tureen». Seriously, who fills up the larger size? That wiould be like a quart of fro-​yo. I guess if you added some of all 16 flavors you could fill it up but then you’d have a stomachache. Or maybe you wouldn’t because of all the good bacteria in the fro-​yo?
Anyway — I had some caramel apple flavor and it was good, not great. A little too soft/​runny for me. He had a mix of coffee and peanut butter — why I don’t know because that sounds pretty vile. There are lots of toppings and sauces to pick from if you want to dress up your treat. Pricing was really reasonable — for both of us it was $ 5 total.
Also, I have no idea why, but there outdoor Muzak blaring on this block. Like really bad rom-​com Taylor Swift music. Weird.

Not being a big fan of ice cream or anything similar… i found myself wanting more of my half-​filled bowl of first time froyo. Yes, you heard me. First timer. The little squishy things that burst flavor into your mouth (bobas?) — riveting. The downside? It’s 2 mins from my work. This could be dangerous, very dangerous.

So the family went the Orange Leaf on Mundy Drive right off SR37 tonight. I can’t recommend it. I found a hair in my vanilla soft serve. When I took it to the counter, the cashier lady didn’t know what to do. She summoned the manager whose first response was «You can get another one» in a tone that made me feel like it was my fault. I decided not to take into her yet. So I sat down, told my wife and she agreed I should ask for my money back. I walked up and asked what we were going to do about it. The cashier called the another manager back in and he had no idea. The first mgr returned and now she told the woman to give me a five dollar gift card. My wife said no that I wanted my money back and I promptly snapped. I made it clear that there was A HAIR IN MY FOOD and that I didn’t want another one or to come here again. The mgr finally whipped out a five and handed it to me, again like I had done her wrong.
So I know that it’s just something that happens and I shouldn’t snap at times like that. But, really, the mgr wasn’t even sorry that someone had nasty food on her watch.
Orange Leaf is good stuff, I’d just recommend NOT EVER going to the one on Mundy Drive.

We walked by a couple of times walking to and from the Alexander Hotel. One evening after a long walk being very thirsty I stopped to get an Orange Julius beverage. We politely listened to their explanation of how their store had several flavors of frozen yogurt and multiple toppings that you serve yourself and is priced by weight. But I was thirsty so we left. Later that evening we returned for desert and were happy we had. My wife and I each had a modest serving our bowls were not completely full and the total was between $ 10 & $ 11. The staff is extra friendly.

I have visited twice this week– don’t judge. The staff is abnormally friendly and energetic. You don’t often find this great of staff in the downtown area.
They change the flavors frequently. The only downside is that they do not keep birthday cake (vanilla) on tap at all times and it is my husband’s favorite. I have tried the brownie batter and peanut butter– yum.
The topping selections are awesome and they have a unique variety. The prices seem lower than the other area downtown frozen yogurt places.
Did I mention they have a rewards program where you can quickly earn free yogurt or $ off of your purchase without any annoying online set-​up? Enjoy– I’m sure you will see me in there.

Wow! Staff couldn’t be more friendly! They offered samples, coupons, picked up our trash, and probably would have given me a hug if I would have asked! Other than that, this is your typical Orange Leaf experience. They did have a few toppings that my normal spot doesn’t have like some weird gelatinous yellow balls and graham cracker crumbs. I would almost make special trips from Noblesville to get froyo here because of how friendly the staff is!

Wow– 16 flavors to choose from and I was told that some change every couple of weeks. I was impressed with the variety of flavors – some more tart ones (peach, passion fruit, pineapple), usually staples (chocolate, peanut butter, vanilla) and sugar addicts’ delights (cheesecake, birthday cake, cotton candy). The coffee flavor tasted very true to coffee. Was told these are made fresh daily on site, which is impressive. The space is clean, bright and pretty. Lots of orange. I’d guess it’ll be popular with the City Way folks or summertime bikers. Heard a Mass Ave and one other branch is supposed to launch too, which is surprising.