Cigar-Cigar Etc

Aloha fellow Hawaii cigar smokers. I first read some reviews about this shop. Some good some not so good. I drove in and waited for him to arrive, since it was around lunch time. He pulls in
and I ask him «Hey can I park here and walk to Walmart? «Hell No!» he exclaims .
«I’m kidding» I said, I’m here to buy cigars from you. It was a good ice breaker.
After I told him, I was new to cigar smoking and wanted his help to find some good choices.
Cool guy! Knows his stuff. Sold me some nice smokes and ask me to come back and smoke with him in his lounge. I will take him up on that and hope to learn more from a true
cigar aficionado. Oh and he filled my butane lighter. As for the bad reviews I read, it seems to me that some people should get over themselves and not be so sensitive. Now reading all these reviews good and bad you must go see for yourself and make sure to buy some great cigars. Robert.

I’ve been going to Cigar Cigar for nearly 12 years now. I’ve read every single review on Joe and his shop and all but one is correct and that would be the review about his cigars being poor quality. When I first got into cigars, I did some research and acted like I knew what the hell I was talking about. First time I met Joe, he was rude and called me out on my ignorance. I took some offense to him and thought this was no way to treat a customer. A couple weeks later, went back and he remembered me. Joe is passionate about cigars and unapologetic for his abrasive and what can be perceived as condescending behavior. But he knows what he loves and ONLY buys cigars that he likes, exception being the ACID line, I think.
I’ve received a many pearls of wisdom and a lot of knowledge on cigars from Joe. Can he be an ass? You bet, but that comes from a man who refuses to move at the speed of the rest of the world. Joe is OLD school. He’ll tell you how he sees it and if you’re offended he doesn’t care if you don’t come back. But if you do, he’s quite interesting and a throw back from a bygone era. You go to Joe and don’t act like you know everything, you should be fine. Reminds me of the old school kanakas drinking, smoking and jamming kanikapila style.
Bottom line, quality cigars, loads of insight and wisdom, from a eccentric old guy. Thick skinned recommended.

Great Cigar Lounge in Honolulu to sit, relax, de-​stress and enjoy that excellent cigar. Joe knows his stuff and will head you to a great cigar from his humidor. I definitely recommend Cigar~Cigar Lounge. Thank you Joe. See ya next time.

I just stopped by looking for a specific cigar which he did not carry BUT Joe recommended the AF magnum R. I cut and lit it right there and fell in love. Delicious cigar. Joe knows his stuff and it’s comforting to know there are aficionados out there that can back their recommendations. I definitely recommend cigar cigar if you are serious about cigars and expect quality products. Great job Joe!

I hate to be a be a hater on one of the few dedicated cigar shops on the island, however Cigar Cigar is one of my least favorite places to buy cigars. There are several reasons for this. One is that they’re no prices listed on the cigars meaning that you have to ask each and every time. SO #!@&)$ ANNOYING! Also, you can’t shop in peace here. The owner will stand in the little humidifier with you and blab you’re ear off as though you don’t know shiznit about cigars. Granted the guy is knowledgable, but I know what I want and don’t need your advice buddy. The prices are also steep, however this is kinda the norm here on the island.

Don’t know whether person who helped me was owner or not, but he was condescending, rude, and not helpful. It was the first time I’ve ever walked out of a shop.

Over the years, Joe has become a friend. His warmth, integrity, and expertise make Cigar-​Cigar a great place. I recommend it without any hesitation. Enjoy!

This cigar lounge has been around Oahu for quite a while. That said, I went there yesterday to enjoy a cigar. The selection wasn’t that extensive … a very safe variety with nothing esoteric or out of the ordinary. Prices are a smidgeon higher than other cigar shops I’ve visited (and I’ve been to several around the world).
The owner, Joe, was also the cashier. He seemed more nonplussed than anything when I bought my cigar. I went to the seating area (not big) and took a seat. While Joe was helping another customer, he made it a point to tell me loudly that «The chair you’re sitting in is for the king.»
«The king?» I asked. «Who’s that?»
«Me,» he snapped.
So I moved to the couch. When he finished with his customer, he ambled over to where I was and announced, «Here in my shop, I have a couple of rules:
«1) Nobody sits in my chair but me.
«2) I don’t allow anyone to use their phones in here. You can use it for answering calls or emails, but you can’t use it for anything else!»
Oooo…kayyyy. I live & work in Silicon Valley, where checking up on your Facebook profile (among other things) is about as common as breathing. It’s a sea change in the way we all socialize, so this blip in Luddite condemnations is a little short-​sighted, to say the least.
Besides, there are other cigar shops in Hawaii which are far more welcoming, have broader selections, and have fast WiFi.
If you abide by the rules at Cigar-​Cigar, you’ll have no problem. If you prefer not being over-​scrutinized, I suggest looking at other options.

The owner, Joe, is a pretty great guy. He is always happy to chat, makes good recommendations, has a different, but comparable selection to Tobaccos of Hawaii, and keeps his stock in good shape (no dried out cigars here).
Parking is a little rough, but the location is on my way home, which makes it hard to pass up some times hehe.

My son and I own a cigar store in Tuscaloosa, AL. We enjoy seeing cigar stores whenever we travel. I was delighted to find Cigar Cigar on a recent visit to Honolulu. Joe is a brave cigar retailer in a state as antagonistic to cigars as Hawaii. After all, where can you smoke the fine cigars that he offers. If his prices are higher, you should consider that to be the fault of the state of Hawaii and its excessive taxes. When you ship your internet purchased cigars to Hawaii, you are actually evading taxes (illegally I might add with the risk of redundancy). Joe had some really excellent cigars, including the nearly impossible to find Avo LE 2010, which may be one of the world’s finest. I buy them when I can find them, but, I can’t bring myself to destroy them. Call it conservation of a precious resource. Anyway, I hope to return and enjoy a great smoke with Joe the owner. Tourists and Residents should make a point to support this fine retailer. I know that I will. Thanks Joe!

Very disappointed went into cigar cigar looking for a humidor and some cigars with my wife. Was treated with nothing but disrespect. Was called a newbie and asked to define the term newbie as if i didnt know how to spell. Further told to google my questions. As a business owner myself I would never treat a prospective customer like this. He just lost a customer for life and I’d advise all of you who read this to steer clear.

earlier in the month i called to ask if this place had any small humidors. the person was extremely rude over the phone and said they sold none and hung up. Because of this i ended up buying one online. Today i walked into this shop to buy more cigar and supplies, giving this place a second chance. BUT AGAIN!!! The guy, i guess owner, was MORE rude in person than over the phone. He was being a jackass saying i should have bought my humidor from him and other crap. i explained that he told me over the phone that he sold none and was still being a prick. he treated me like a child and as if i had dropped out of kindergarten with all of his stupid common sense vocabulary shit. my opinion, don’t give this guy business because he is so full of himself. i would like to give this place 0 stars, but since 1 is the required to get this thing posted, i have to settle with that.

Ok, The humidor is a closet. Joe is very helpful and he will pull out the good stuff for you if you show some intrest. The store is small and disorganized but overall I have never bought a bad cigar from Cigar, Cigar. They always smoke well but of course they are overpriced… you are in Hawaii!

Throughout my travels across this country I come across many businesses, restaurants, hotels, etc. I am always seeking out a local humidor to create a new experience. Needless to say, I have visited many cigar stores over the past 10 years.
I now work for a company based in Hawaii and travel there often. It is always nice to feel welcomed when traveling alone. Someone who takes in interest in what you have to offer in terms of conversation and experiences. Joe is that person!
Though the cigar store isn’t fancily decorated, it feels like home when I walk through the door because of Joe. He is well versed on cigars and is attentive and interested in your tastes and needs. Despite the first glance chaos, Joe’s humidor is well stocked with some quality gems; all you need to do is engage Joe in conversation.
I can attest to the quality of Cigar Cigar cigars. His selection is quality, not quantity. I have spent plenty of time hefin’ with Joe while discussing our favorite Westerns.
The price? It is elevated. But, isn’t most retail in Hawaii? I would rather pay a little more and receive great customer service than be ignored while sifting through run of the mill and generic selections.
If you have the opportunity and the time, go! At the very least, you’ve made a new friend.

As a very experienced cigar smoker, I would disagree with the glowing reviews. The first thing that struck me when I walked in was the poor quality humidifier used. It indicated to me a lack of quality and distinction.
The cigars I purchased were on the dry side and incredibly overpriced. The cigars I purchased were quoted at 19.95 yet the MSRP is 7.00.
I am always willing to pay a premium for top handling but this wasn’t the case.
I hope there are better stores available as I wouldn’t frequent this one again.
One thing I do agree on, Joe the owner is a very likable person.

I’m pretty much a bona fide cigar aficionado. I also manufacture my own cigar humidors and have smoked hundreds of different cigars but much like the previous review, I don’t fit your typical cigar smoker profile… but should there be one? We’re not all fat, middle aged, balding men in tacky golf clothes. You’d be surprised at the diverse array of people that are into cigars and if you are one of them, or want to try a premium cigar this is definitely the best place on the island.
Upon my first visit, I was greeted by the owner, Joe. He was very friendly and it was quite refreshing to speak with someone who is as passionate about cigars as I am. I read about how he ages his cigars on the reviews here so I wanted to check with him about it. He does indeed take every new box he orders and stores them away for at least a couple of years. This is very convenient as a shopper because I don’t have to buy extras and store them in my humidor before smoking them.
Regardless of what type of cigar I’m in the mood for, Joe has one to satisfy every palette. While there were a few brands I wished Joe would carry, his humidor provides everything to satisfy seasoned aficionados as well as beginners looking for something more mild. Whatever you decide on, you can be sure it is going to taste better than if you just picked it up online or at another store because of the aging process.
As for the rest of the shop, there are a wide array of accessories (cutters, lighers, humi’s) as well as a couch, tv, coffee table and a refrigerated selection of non-​alcoholic beverages for sale. (come to think of it, it might be BYOB, but I didn’t ask) I haven’t stopped in and enjoyed a smoke in the store lounge, but definitely would like to when I find the time. Joe knows his cigars and it would be a great atmosphere to sit there, chilax, enjoy a smoke and «talk shop».
Mmmmm, all this writing is got me craving a cigar now. Nothing like stopping by Cigar Cigar, sliding the humidor door open and smelling all the wonderful aroma of Joe’s aging cigars. I highly recommend this place for anyone looking for a good cigar!

Wow! I’ve been collecting Cigars for over 30 yrs and been looking for a High Quality Cigar Shop on the Island.
Cigar– Cigar is the place!
Joe the owner is very personable and knows his stuff. He has a wide range of AGED Quality Cigars and is very helpful.
I definitely recommend this place and thanks to Marc W. for bringing it to my attention. Prices are reasonable for the Quality and Handling.

I actually enjoy cigars on a regular basis, so I can review this shop from a shopper’s perspective. If you love cigars, this is the place. You’ll pay a dollar or two more here for a cigar. With good reason.
First, you get the owner, Joe Hilton’s experience. He’s been here over ten years. Second you get his ability to age to perfection. Joe isn’t buying stock for today. Shipments come in, then disappear for a year or two. Yes, Cigar-​Cigar ages their cigars to perfection. And that makes all the difference.
When you buy a cigar from Joe, you know it’s going to be good. If you are going for your regular smoke, it will be better than when you buy it anywhere else. It’s been aged that way. And if you are going in for a recommendation — like a good sommelier, after a few questions you’ll be pointed in the right direction.
It’s pretty much a one man show (except Sundays, when there is someone else in the shop). If you are serious about cigars, this is the place.

I rarely smoke, but some occasions do call for a premium cigar in order to celebrate. Oddly, I only went to Cigar Cigar to look for a simple humidor for my dad’s collection of cigars, and was unaware that I would end up writing a review on it.
The store is small, and very casual. You’ll be greeted with a couch and TV, along with cigar boxes stacked up to your waist all around the perimeter. The owner, Joe Hilton, is very nice and eager to share why his cigars are the best. I was reluctant at first to ask why «his» cigars are the best because they are the same as other cigar stores, but I asked anyway to avoid that awkward silence.
Surprisingly, he informed me that he ages his cigars anywhere between 1 – 3 years! Now that’s impressive. I did not know that the aging of cigars is suppose to enhances the experience of it, much like wine.
Before I left, I took a brief tour of the cigar room. Cigar Cigar offers a good range of average to premium cigars. Since I never smoked any of the store’s cigars, I will start it off with 3 stars.
To be continued…