Cottage Inn Pizza

I’m pretty easy when it comes to pizza, but this was disgusting and so over priced. The toppings didn’t taste fresh. It is definitely cheap and definitely will not be going back.

I’m pretty fascinated by the mix of reviews about this place.
The pizza is a pretty straightforward four-​stars-​for-​chain-​pizza for me. The deep dish is especially tasty (and way less greasy than Pizza Hut); the price is way better than nearby Granddad’s, and tbh, I thought it tasted better than Granddad’s, too. (Granddad’s tiny pizzas + high prices. .. I dunno. I mean, they’re not Bono or Harvest.) Maybe Cottage Inn has upped their game in the past couple of years, but I have ordered from them twice now and saw no reason to give it less than four stars.
We’ve ordered delivery twice and twice it has come to us expediently, even earlier than expected. The pizza was hot, fresh, and good. Their cheese bread is also tasty (I’m a sucker for cheese bread, full stop.)
Before moving out to the Hilliard-​ish area, I was stuck with only Pizza Hut and Donatos if I wanted to get delivery. Cottage Inn is better than both, and they will have my delivery business from now on.

Had their Deluxe pizza for the first time tonight and we really liked it! Thought they were very generous with the toppings and it was tasty and filling!

The pizza is cheap and it shows. Thin crust is very thin and cardboard like, very skimpy on sauce, cheese, and toppings. Not impressed and won’t have it again. There are way too many great pizza places in Hilliard to bother with this one.

This place serves a tasty cheese pizza at an affordable price. I wouldn’t call it gourmet but it is better then the other pizza joints in the Hilliard area. As for the atmosphere, the place was a bit dated but clean and the employees were friendly. My daughter and I will be making this our go to place for a basic pie.

This place is seriously as cheap as it gets for the Hilliard area, but «cheap» isn’t the word if you’re looking cost wise.
While dine in is available at this location. I don’t think it was much of an option for us. The place was really dated, slightly dirty, and it looked as if someone (guessing a worker there) had sprawled their junk all over one of the tables, for their relaxation time later on.
The quality of pizza is on par with Little Caesars pizza. It’s just unfortunate they’re charging $ 3 more in price.
Even the subs were dismal, tasteless, and forgettable.
The pizza is edible, but lets face it. there’s other places to hit up in Hilliard instead.

Accidentally stumbled upon this place and couldn’t be happier! We have had great food, delivered quickly and have tried many things on the menu. The Mediterranean was our favorite– the pesto sauce made it! Garlic Bread, Innstix and the wings are all also on our favorites list.

I’m a little embarrassed that this is my first review, but not too cool to admit that Cottage Inn Pizza is quite tasty! What makes the pizza? Without a doubt the crust. The deep dish crust is slightly crispy on the outside but soft when you bite into it — plus if you’re a glutton for sauces (and I am), you’ll love the free crust options that Cottage Inn offers: garlic butter, Parmesan garlic, and even Cajun butter!
The service was also impeccable. Our pizza order is usually complicated, specific toppings, no cheese, etc. Cottage Inn nailed it and delivered to us approximately 20 minutes faster than promised. The pizza was hot and the veggie toppings appeared and tasted fresh.
If you’re a sucker for a thick crusted pizza and like tons of menu options, Cottage Inn is a great fast and easy pizza experience.

«Gourmet pizza»?? Are you kidding me? This is almost the worst pizza in Hilliard. All the ingredients diced up, mixed together, and spread on top of the tasteless sauce. I rather eat Domino’s, yuck.

My girlfriend and I just finished the chicken cordon bleu pizza, and it was excellent. Very tasty, and, since it is on special this week, quite a good deal as well.
We had it delivered, and it came (still pretty hot) in about 30 minutes.
In the past, we’ve had the chicken alfredo pizza, which was just okay, and the wings, which are good, but you have to toss them in the sauce yourself (not a big fan of that).
Overall, this seems like an affordable place to have quality pizza.

I preface this review by saying that my better half is a NUT about cottage inn. We’re originally from michigan so we’re used to having a ton around and they’re his absolute favorite.
With that said, not a big fan of this location. We’ve made a special trip out from Dublin recently so he can have his fav. After this last visit, we’ve really opted to heading to the polaris location.
The last order we placed just wasn’t quite what we ordered. We asked for extra cheese, extra sauce, and well done, none of which was actually on my pizza. I’m usually pretty discerning when it comes to pizza places. I know some days can be better than others, people are not perfect, but this was also not the first time this has happened for this location.
In general for the store, I did notice that they allowed one of their employees to work in flip flops. I noticed that he had come in from delivering a pizza and went right to work making someone’s pizza. Pretty sure this is a health code violation.
The customer service was decent, not good or great by any means. The pizza was edible, so I’m giving two stars for that. I wouldn’t really recommend this location to a friend, and I doubt I’ll be returning. That whole cooking in flip flops deal has me a little «ewwww”-ed out.

They claim its «Gourmet» pizza, I dont see it. Flat pie with no taste. Veggies are diced up small, and sprinkled on the pie. The sauce is bland and tasteless. Crust is like stiff cardboard. Id call this below average pie… I wont be going back.

Good Pizza! Good people!
The Cottage Inn Pizza is very very good and a must try. The owner hand delivered our company a pizza and we loved it. We will be ording company lunches from there on the Reg.

I just ordered from this place, and it was pretty good. The crust was pretty good, I like how you can flavor it. Very greasy though. Its definitely different but in a good way.

Flip this pizza over and you’ll get a tasty little surprise: sesame seeds! The bottoms of these pies are loaded with the nutty flavored kernels.
The parlor provides a sweet pizza sauce and is always loaded with cheese. The cheese gets a little greasy, but sometimes that’s what I’m in the mood for.
Plain old cheese pizza is my favorite when it comes to Cottage Inn.
Accompanying the pizzas on the menu are subs, sides, Italian favorites, and salads.
Cottage Inn also has a good website for a local business with clean graphics and fonts and fun little widgets.

Okay I know I have said that Rotolo’s was my favorite and the best in Columbus, but does Hilliard count as ‘Columbus’? I think Cottage Inn, while still rather obscure, is rapidly approaching the #1 mark in the HCA Book of Perfect Pizza. Seriously. Anyone who has said that ‘a pizza is a pizza is a pizza’ has never had Cottage Inn. I am a crust girl and this stuff is really off the charts with goodness. Rotolo’s doesn’t give me my crust fix but they do everything else right. So it’s really a toss-​up. You might have difficulty getting a delivery to you and it is located in Hilliard (Worthington location as well) but if you can stand it, go pick it up and try it. It is always worth the gas money to me!