Tasty Grill

Easily a five star dining experience. The waitress, I get every time, is as sweet as ever. Their gyros are out out of this world. I am in awe with how amazing their food is. It is at a fair price for delicious Greek cuisine. The wraps, salads, sides, French fries, and feta cheese (which I had all ate) are amazing. It is so fresh and I HIGHLY RECOMMEND this restaurant. The staff and owner are extremely friendly. As soon as you walk into their restaurant they are greeting you with a huge warm smile. Not only can you sit down and eat directly there, you could also have it delivered or walk right it and walk right out. Food is great and service is wonderful.

Falafel Friday at our school each week! We love tasty grill! Chicken souvlaki platter is so good! There lemon potatoes are out of this world! A must try if in the Whitstone area!

Love the food. Lemon potatoes are great. You have 3 different types of gyro to pick from.

Great place! I loved the chicken gyro sandwiches and French fries! Neatly wrapped, crisp, the chicken was tender and the fries were perfectly cooked and thin my favorite. On top of that the price was affordable. Totally recommend it!

I was honestly never the hugest fan of tasty grill in past visits. I vaguely recall a couple years back going to pick up food and seeing a disorganized mess behind the counter. A waitress was calling out a cook for not giving her what she needed – he yelled back at her and she stormed away; not very professional. I recall that day waiting for a good 25 minutes for our food while several people piled into their small entrance way.
This time when we ordered take-​out while my sister was over, they were just incredibly frustrating.
I ordered through Grubhub so was more than ready to wait about an hour for our food as per the usual when ordering through the online service. We were pleasantly surprised when the food came after just half an hour. We quickly unpacked our food to find that we were missing half our order. We ordered 2 Gyro platters and one salad. The platters should have come with pita, tatziki and salads. All of these sides were missing as well as the dressing and pita for the salad. I immediately called and told the girl who picked up that it seemed the driver may have just forgotten to take a bag out of his car so she could call him and it could be corrected. She apologized and said it would be sent to us ASAP. About 20 minutes went by without hearing from them again or a delivery and I don’t know about you… but I wasn’t about to eat my gyro without my pita and tatziki! Also, we live about 2 minutes from Tasty Grill. So, if anything, it would have taken 15 minutes tops if they were busy (it was all pre-​made items!) So, I called again, this time a little bit hangry and told them the rest of my food was getting cold. This time she stated that the delivery guy was heading out now and it would be there shortly. Another 10 minutes went by without a delivery so I called back again growing impatient and asked if he went for other deliveries first and she said he did! I was so angry at this because I felt that an incomplete order should have been completed before new orders were taken out for delivery. At that point it had taken longer for some breads, sauces and salads to be delivered than our actual meals. I think it was a major lack of communication that caused this but it unfortunately caused me to lose my interest in this specific place. There’s many other places in the area with similar food who take the quality of their service much more seriously that I would much rather give my business to.

Great friendly staff and the gyro is amazing, it’s not oily like other places, and good variety menu~

We just ate lunch ! my deluxe cheeseburger ! It was out of this world ! Guys keep up the good work ! And by the way ! successful ! NEW YEAR !!!

Superb Greek eatery! My fav is the pork gyro… everything here is super tasty, hence the name… A lil pricey but worth the great meal! Will def go again and recommend!

A must go! Amazing food quality, prices are very fair, staff is very welcoming and friendly. My girlfriend and I ordered the beef/​grilled chicken gyro platter with sweet potato fries, the food came out very quickly and tasted very fresh and easily feeds two… For an appetizer we had the hummus and it tasted homemade. The environment is very clean and spacious. Looking forward to coming back when I am in the area! Officially a favorite.

Absolutely love this place! Whenever I come up to see my friend, this is where we dine or do takeout. This restaurant always serves fresh food and great drinks.
Highly recommend the chicken souvlaki platter. They have a outside eating area. Parking isn’t that hard to find.

Tasty is a nice local spot with very friendly service. Sometimes though the grillman/​souvlaki monger will ignore your preference and replace it with his. For example, slice the pork gyro thin was translated into slice the pork gyro extra thick. To their credit the offered to redo the order but we were in a rush. Taste wise the food was good although the pork souvlaki stick tasted as though it was hanging out a while and then re-​grilled to heat. The gyro was the big hit.
I ordered a plate of the pork gyro which came with a very fresh greek salad. Surprisingly the feta in the salad tasted as though it was imported and not of the domestic flavorless variety used by similar other shops. They also used decent olive oil in the dressing. There was an option to select sweet potato fries with the «plate» size order and I took full advantage of it.
Decent ambiance and an outdoor patio will most certainly entice me to return.

The staff is very friendly– however the food is just not worth it. Just about everything made here is frozen, then fried. It’s essentially a McDonald’s that specializes in poor Greek cuisine for triple the cost. If the food is going to be greasy and consist of cheap meats and ingredients, the prices should be the same. You are not fooling anyone who has been to Fontana’s, let alone Greece.

Ate lunch here again today, maybe my 5^th time. Kept it simple and had naked wings and a side of veggies. Those veggies, if you’re into that heavily seasoned flavor, are really good! I’ve never had veggies prepared quite this way, anywhere. The wings were good too, and had a vinegar flavor, which I like and thought appropriate. Service was good and friendly as usual. My Sunday server there is very sweet, and she’s a real fan of food. I think a server is a salesperson, and you can’t sell something well if you don’t really believe in it. Clearly, she does.

This review is for their takeout delivery. They are too inconsistent with their food. I’m always in for a surprise when I receive my delivery. Either they forget sauce or something is spilled. I get that the weather is crappy right now with Hurricane Joaquin right around the corner, but this is unacceptable! I’m never prepaying the tip (through GrubHub) again because when I opened the bag the sauce container exploded and was everywhere! And the portions were way smaller than the last time where I ordered the same thing. Their food tastes good, but it’s not worth it.

I loved the casual outdoor seating — I felt like I was in someone’s backyard.
The food wasn’t anything special though. We started with the tzatziki spread with pita bread. The bread was hard and looked more like waffles than actual pita bread (see picture) and the tzatziki was lacking that nice tangy kick I love. It tasted like regular yogurt with an oniony aftertaste.
We then shared a gyro platter. I’m pretty sure most Greek places can make an awesome gyro platter… but this place fell short. We got the 3 meat combination with salad and lemon potatoes for $ 15.99. You definitely get a lot of food for what you’re paying, but it just didn’t cut it for me. The chicken was incredibly dry and hard and the pork was too fatty. Beef was the best part. Lemon potatoes weren’t lemony.
I was looking for those thin slices of delicious gyro goodness when I walked in and sadly that’s not what was served. The food wasn’t terrible, but nothing stood out that would make me want to come back. Sorry Tasty Grill, you weren’t so tasty after all.

Great food, well priced. I always appreciate the option for outdoor seating. (They have a nice little patio out back with umbrellas, plants, and lights).
The food is delicious. We had a Tasty wrap, Mediterranean wrap, Swiss burger and fries which were all so tasty and well portioned. It was just unfortunate that there was only one woman serving — she initially got the order wrong, but she was pleasant.
My favorite: the frappé!
I would definitely go back.

Excellent food, casual outdoor seating. A nice neighborhood find. Prices are good, $ 20 bottles of wine, how can you go wrong? The Beef gyro is TERRIFIC, the pork gyro– not a big fan. The sweet chili calamari and the coconut shrimp were both very good.
The service is terrific. Friendly– reminiscent of the tavernas in Greece.

A clean, casual, and enjoyable place serving Greek/​American style food.
Service was great, waitresses were attentive and friendly. Main things they specialize in are wraps, gyros, souvlaki (pieces of meat grilled on a skewer). They also have American items like burgers that also looked good.
Tried the chicken souvlaki dish ($ 11.99). Chicken was a little dry. The Shrimp skewer dish which was on the more expensive end ($ 15.99) was more enjoyable. All the dishes come with choice of a side (fries, onion rings, rice etc…), salad, and pita bread in a basket. It was filling.
There’s a pretty nice little outdoor area in the back of the restaurant where you have the option to eat outside. Covered in greenery, It’s a pretty sweet space and a great for long chats over a meal.
Seems like the 1 – 2 stars reviews are mostly regarding take-​out service. Not sure about that, but dining in was definitely a positive experience. I would come back!
Street parking, and they accept card.

Okay. Weve had this before in this place. Its delicious. They prepare it well. The thing is the portion when we were there was much more than what u see in the pic. I get that seafood prices vary but I also know when its way unfair to charge like this.
It is outrageous how my wife was treated by the manager of this place because she complained about a dish. The picture is right here. They want to charge 16 dollars for this. Never again tasty grill. You have def lost a good customer who was willing to pay but not for this kind of service or disrespect. Specially from the manager. Never again…

Great food and great service! definitely filling and in a homely enviroment. The waiters are extremely nice and helpful. Ive been here a couple of times and one of my favorite things is the tzatziki sauce! Each time i’ve been here i’ve gotten the Tasty Spreads which consists of toasted pita slices served with three different spreads. The tzatziki is one of the best i’ve had in New York. My friend who has been to Greece said it was just as comparable. The spicy feta is another one of my favorites. The hummus spread seemed a little dull but the other two definitely make up for it.
I’ve also tried the chicken gyro sandwich and beef gyro sandwich. In my opinion i like the beef better because it is more savory while the chicken is more on the dry side but its personal preference. Either way i drench each bite in the tzatziki sauce we got from the spreads. Great place for lunch and not expensive at all!