Brother’s Pizzeria

What can I say? It’s my favorite pizza in the area without all of the hype. When you look into their eyes, you will see the abyss, but they make a hell of a pizza.

Best sicilian pizza in the area! Staff is friendly and quick service!

If I could give this three and a half stars I would. The pizza was really delicious. It was kind of weird that I ordered bald black olives and half plain and I only received WHOLE olives on two and a half slices. While the whole olives were awkward to me since I’ve only ever seen sliced olives, I did enjoy the difference. The crust was good. The cheese was good and the sauce was really good. The pizza itself deserves 4 stars. What’s holding this back was is the soggy cheese less oily cheese fries I received. The mozzarella was almost completely melted down to the bottom and the entire bottom of the pan was greasy. They sealed the lid without venting it so the fried turned to all mush. I won’t be ordering fries again but I will definitely be ordering the pizza. This location only offers pick up which is fine with me because it’s not in a bad location. I will be ordering pizza from here again the next time I’m hungry for it.

They make the best Cheesesteak Pizza. Been going to this place for years.

We love Brother’s brooklyn pie, but when we ordered a bunch of cheesteaks and pies for a party, picked them up, the order was wrong. Asked for onions on the side, but discovered that every steak sandwich had onions on it when we got them home. When we called, we were told to bring them back if we wanted new cheese steaks. That seemed ridiculous to me. As if we were lying about the onions and they wanted proof they were on there only to toss them in the trash? Went back and got new sandwiches so they made it right but wasted a lot of our time away from our guests making two trips. Will give them another try maybe in the future, maybe not. There are many other pizza places with similar menus in Hamilton.

So, I am from New York originally and therefore a pizza snob… I have lived in the area for over 8 years and I don’t go anywhere else to get pizza. It is always fresh and consistant. Their sauce is amazing, perfect amount of cheese and toppings.
The staff is friendly and fast. It is busy as can be on Friday nights so call ahead to place your order and on game day prepare to wait a bit.
They don’t deliver but I live close enough to not care… I almost didn’t post this because I don’t want to it to get so busy that I can’t get my food! lol But I am in a sharing mood so you’re lucky!
Best pizza hands down in Hamilton even better than the other location on Route 33.

Best pizza place in the area. Not tomato pie, just regular pizza. Their specialty pies are very good. Sandwiches and salads are great. Love this spot been going there for years. Whenever I go out of town for a period of time, this is the first place i stop in to grab a slice. Brothers is the best!

I hate bad pizza… I’ve been to just about every pizza place in hamilton (there are a lot) but I have to say Brothers was a disappointment. We got a margarita pizza, which was very soggy and had no basil. Pretty tasteless overall. The chicken parm sandwich had barely any sauce and buffalo chicken fingers were bland with hardly any buffalo sauce. The plain pizza looked pretty good so maybe they are better with regular pizza than specialty pizzas but with so many other options in the area we won’t be going back.

This is the only Brothers Pizza in Hamilton that you should be going to. Great pie, and food. My favorite part is that they will make you just about anything you like. I happen to be a fan of chicken cheese steaks on garlic bread and they make it awesome here! I’m a big fan and I highly recommend this spot!

I returned today for my pizza fix after trying the Italian Hot Dog last week.
Here’s the breakdown:
1. The crust held firm on both slices, making for crisp points and easy first bites.
2. The underside was nicely singed with black spots, but not so much as to acquire a
burnt taste. Definitely, the strongest element of the pie. Very cracker-​like.
3. The surfaces of the slices were a bit oily, allowing for a steady drip onto the paper
plates on which they were served.
4. The sauce was on the salty side, perhaps from reheating, but not the mildly sweet
basil/​crushed hot pepper tone I prefer.
5. At $ 5. for two slices and a small drink, the price was certainly right. I have paid a
few bucks more for the same amount at places that don’t compare in quality or
taste.
Conclusion: Not the best pizza in town, but not the worst. Somewhere in the middle of the range for the multitude of pizza shops in Hamilton. When I think pizza, this is not the first place I will think of, but neither will it be the last. When convenience is a factor, it will come out ahead due to proximity to my office.

We order from this location at least once a month. They have quality pizza. You can’t go wrong with their plain slice.

Good authentic pizza, good cheese steaks sand, quick service, good prices, this place has been in business forever so that tells you this place has good food. No complaints really, only reason I didnt give it 5 stars is because its not «amazing tell everybody» kind of pizza, its just good local pizza.

I’ve been going to Brothers for close to thirty years as my childhood home is directly around the corner. We would order Brothers every Friday night from the time I was born til I left for school in the fall of 2002. I would return for summers until I left for Pittsburgh in the fall of 2006. Sometime between leaving for Pittsburgh in 2006, and returning home in 2009, I believe it changed.
Not only did they change the awful dining room but I swear they changed the quality of the cheese. It is much greasier than it used to be and it no longer sits well with me. Go with a whole pie for best results as it is especially obvious in the reheated pizza served by the slice.
It is still well loved in the area, but I know I am not alone in my opinion and I prefer Nino’s on Chambers Street in Trenton, Vitos on Route 33 in Hamilton, Corleone’s on Olden Avenue, or of course, Delorenzos.
Sorry to be a traitor, but it is what it is. It is no longer the best place in town. was it ever or was it a case of location bias? I have my answer. Go make up your own mind…

With the 300 other Brothers Pizza around this town and state THIS one is simply the best. They have the best pizza and I have tried them all. They also make a great calzone and cheese steak.

I like this place but check your food before you leave. I ordered a italian hoagie and when I got home I noticed I got a ham sandwich instead. Same thing with my pie I asked for mushrooms and peppers and got mushrooms, pepperoni and sausage but no peppers. Two meats on one pie is not my thing… I’m a a one meat type of guy ya know.

The one and only. Accept no substitutes. I have been getting Brother’s for over 40 years and it is still the same. Excellent! The best Sicilian pie, plain pie and cheesesteak pie around. Their cheesesteak sandwiches are packed. They don’t deliver because they don’t have to. Loyalty, baby!

The absolute BEST pizza in the entire world ! I remember when they first opened, and since, I’ve traveled the entire world, and have lived in Los Angeles and Seattle for the past few decades — and I have never found a pizza that even comes close. If I’m flying into NY on business, I will drive down to Hamilton for a Brothers Pizza. It’s a good today as it way 40+ years ago. I’m 3,000 miles away and craving Brothers Pizza.

Ok not to be confused with the 1 million other Brother’s Pizza places around. This is probably one of the best pizza places ever, and I’ve been going to this place for about 25 years now. Consistently the best pizza in town, especially when bought by the slice. Their cheesesteak pizza, sicilian, broccoli, and sausage are all great once you get sick of the plain (if that ever happens).
Also the prices are not bad at all when compared to other local pizza shops.
Did I mention the cheesesteaks and chicken cheesesteaks? Those are off the hook and affordable as welll. unnnhhhhhhhhhh! enjoy

You cannot go wrong here, food is good and the service is outstanding!

I’ve tried all the pizza places in town and the combination of crunchy crust, delicious sauce and quality cheese makes this shop the best. My son has dairy allergies and can’t have cheese so they make him a cheese-​less pizza with crust, sauce and olive oil. My son loves it and I eat it as well. My wife isn’t as big a pizza fan as I am and she loves the grilled chicken sub they make. Very fresh and tasty.
The people that work there are friendly and very accommodating. Although I never eat in, it seems like a great place to grab a quick bite. If you’re looking for quality food and freshness, I recommend Brothers on Whitehorse.