Jersey Boardwalk Pizza

Lecker Pizza wenn man auf dem Weg nach Key West Hunger hat :)

Great pizza and great service. Our order was delayed because of a mix up and they were very apologetic and even offered us free dessert. That’s how you run a business! Highly recommended.

We go down to the keys almost every weekend and always stop here on the way up. Good food. Good price. Great times.

Boardwalk Pizza is no more. We just had a waitress come to our table that was high as a kite. She was also bleeding from her finger quite a bit, but was trying to conceal it. When she came back with waters, blood was all over the cups and straws. We went to leave and then tell the other girl working there why, but bleeder intercepted me and put an order in my face and kept saying that she was trying to get it right and she was so, so sorry. She was so strung out that she didn’t even realize I wasn’t the table (only one of three) with the order. Also saw blood dripping off of her finger which was now uncovered as she walked back to the kitchen and was talking to the cook over the prep area… while it was still bleeding!
Called later to see if they canned her or at least sent her home and they said everything was A-​OK and she now had on a band-​aid and no blood got anywhere. HELLO! IT WAS ALL OVER OUR F**KING DRINKS and definitely in the food prep area!
I’m not being overly cautious in saying that anyone eating there on the night of 11÷2÷15 around 5:25 — 7:00 should definitely get tested.
Been there quite a few times. Never again.

Pizza was delicious, and so was the garlic bread. I appreciate that they could deliver to the gated community where we were staying!

I’m from Jersey… and it felt soo good to find this place. After 8 days of Disney/​Miami/​Key West, I was getting homesick. The food here is ahhhmazing. Delicious. I still think Jersey shore Boardwalk pizza in NJ is 2x as big… but still, it was good here!

Great place with great service nice classic Jersey feel to it this place is a most eat.

We really enjoyed the pizza here! The BBQ wigs were also delicious. Our server was awesome, very prompt and helpful. Couldn’t have asked for a better pizza spot! This place is so much better than most places in Miami. I’ve missed NJ pizza and Boardwalk satisfied my cravings tonight.
Love it!!! Would highly recommend.
Side note: bring mosquito repellent.

Dined here on Sunday night and it was a pleasant experience. Service was great and food was delicious. Only reason I did not give it 5 stars is because the garlic bread with cheese that we ordered was not that good but it’s okay because the pizza was excellent. Two

They make a nice pie– thin crust, crispy bottom, yet a good chewy texture. Very friendly service. It was too hot to eat lunch outside on the deck. Inside AC was comfortable, but interior could be fixed up a bit. But hey, it’s a pizza shop.

Best meal we’ve had ever south of Miami! If you want authentic NJ style pizza and meatball subs then don’t miss this place!

First time eating here and loved it. Cheese pizza was delish! Our waitress Rachel was very attentive. Will definitely come back

Serving up good pizza and a cool old fashioned atmosphere. We had the meat lovers and the veggie, both were excellent, crust was crispy and being from New York we love our pizza, I give them

Great pizza for that day late in the week when you say «I’m tired of eating fish at nice restaurants. What else good is there around here?»
Nice people… Good pizza… You can eat outdoors too!

For pizza in the Islamorada area this is likely the best.
We live in Islamorada and have pizza here at least once a month. I’m only giving this 3 stars since I really felt cheated tonite… we arrive before 6 pm and ordered the $ 14.95 med pizza with a pitcher of beer with 2 additional toppings on the pizza. The pitcher of beer only poured 4 glasses since it had an inch and a half of foam in the not so full pitcher and then when the bill came they charged us the additional topping cost for a large pizza. It was a small amount of overcharge but when brought to the attention of the waitress she said that’s what they do on the «specials» and that she told us about this earlier (she had not). Not quite so special is that?
Don’t shy away from this pizza place because the pizza is good. Just beware that their «specials» may not be as advertised.

Stopped in this joint recently and figured out why it’s been a few years since I’ve been back. Terrible service. Waited for over 20 minutes to be served and no one ever showed up. Sat down inside at the only available table and waited. Several other customers finished, got up and left. Bus person came over and cleaned tables and a new couple sat down. They were immediately served as myself and my friend had continued to wait patiently to be served. We got up and left. But not after we helped ourselves to the soda fountain on the way out. There is a reason locals don’t go here. I live in the Keys and I will not be back.

When I’m in the keys, there is only one place I go to for Pizza, this is it! Love that the Dough comes right from my hometown… It makes me feel like I’m home every time I visit. If you are searching for the best pizza in the keys this is for you.

Pizza was good but the calzone was amazing. Highly recommend the sausage calzone. Regular size was enough for 2 of us, cost a little over $ 10. Happy hour specials were decent

Let me just start by saying I’m from NY so I’m used to really good pizza.
I thought the pizza here was «OK»
I mean we are down in the keys so if you keep that in mind then it’s good pizza.

I decided to stop here to grab a quick bite. As soon as I walked in I noticed this establishment had a NJ theme. I was hoping they would bring some of the pizza making skills back from NJ. So I started looking for slices but they didn’t have any. Had to order a medium pie. Plenty of staff on board to help us out with our order. You can tell it was Friday night and they were expecting the unexpected. Service was great and the young lady who helped us was very attentive.
Pizza was ok, it wasn’t the best I’ve had. Cheese and Crust were good. I was disappointed in the basil topping. Have to leave the basil whole can’t dice and crush it up. It’s not the same!
Overall, Not bad. I would only stop here if I was really hungry.

Coming back from the Florida Keys, my boyfriend and I decided to stop here for a quick bite to eat. We only noticed that it was Jersey style pizza when we entered and saw the NJ memorabilia on the walls. Jersey pizza, you say? New Jersey has some of the best pizza I’ve ever tasted. I know all about NJ pizza, I’ve been eating great Jersey pizza my whole life. But this really didn’t come to close to Jersey pizza.
First thing we noticed is they don’t sell pizza by the slice. Really? Because that last time I checked, every Jersey pizzeria sells pizza by the slice! Fine, we can’t have a slice, we’ll order a pie then. We ended up ordering a medium pie, half cheese and half basil. Now, medium pizzas in NJ are huge, colossal is more like it. Even the small pizzas in Jersey wouldn’t be considered small.
So when the medium pie came out we were actually surprised at the size of the pie. The medium pizza seemed like a small pizza in Jersey. Definitely smaller than expected. For those who don’t know about the size of pizza slices in Jersey, we have huge slices. Yes, one pizza slice in NJ can be pretty filling depending on the toppings. The size of the slice was half the size of a true Jersey slice.
As for the pizza itself, it was good. It wasn’t the best pizza I’ve ever had, but it wasn’t bad. I wish they had put fresh basil instead of dried basil as the topping.
Overall, the service was fast and pleasant and the pizza was good. However, it definitely isn’t Jersey pizza.