Romeo’s Pizzeria and Restaurant

5 Stars because there food is absolutely excellent.
Fast friendly service, great prices and killer zeppoles.
We have tried all the restaurants in the area and they are a pretty good but Romeos is the best.

Weird people, they keep staring at customers instead of serving them. i went there with my girlfriend to order pizza to go and the delivery kid was staring at my girlfriend’s breast all the time !. i will never go there again

Honestly one of the best pizzerias on the island they have great wraps and their pizza is pretty good. The staff is always friendly and the Prices are really good. Whenever I order for delivery its always really fast for me. Definitely come here instead of monalisa across the street

This place was not very good. We ordered two heros and baked clams (delivery). The bread on the heroes was stale and the clams had no taste. Not impressed. Won’t order from here again.

I have to give this place 5 stars because in every catagory they really do shine at least those catagories which matter to me.
They staff is friendly and attentive and never once messed up my order or said the word no to a special request I had. Their delivery is fast and the drivers are polite and best of all they keep their place very clean.
You can taste and instantly understand the ingredients are fresh in everything you order and they use those ingredients to deliver exceptional flavors in their dishes.
They have excellent vodka sauce which is a first for me on Staten Island so that is a huge deal for me and they don’t skimp on the sauce when putting it on their vodka slices either.
Their pizza crust is thin, crunchy and had a little chew and is honestly perfect.
Best of they have very competitive prices.
The one gripe I had was with their mozzarella cheese on their regular slices. It had a strong taste which dwarfed the flavor of the sauce and crust. It’s pretty strong stuff. I personally prefer a cheese that is closer to the taste of milk then that of a strong oily mozzarella but that’s just me. Could have been that the cheese was just at its final aging days too or it was sitting out in dry air loosing its moisture, who knows.
Every other slice I had was excellent. Haven’t tried their grandma pie yet but will update when I do.
All in all if your in the area or sitting at home I highly recommend you try them one day.

I order from Romeo’s at least twice a week and can’t get enough of it! The food is out of this world and the pizza is amazing!

I gave this place second chance. I ordered a fried calzone with ham. I was given a calzone that was sitting there all day, cut open and ham was added. I expected freshly made calzone. The garlic knots are bland. The pizza was ehh. The food is mediocre at best. I will not be ordering from here again.