The Top 20 Italian

Staten Island, NY, United States

Show map

Staten Island Neighborhoods

Annadale
Arrochar
Castleton Corners
Chelsea
Dongan Hills
Elm Park
Eltingville
Grant City
Grasmere
Great Kills
Heartland Village
Huguenot
Mariner
New Dorp
New Dorp Beach
Oakwood
Old Town
Princes Bay
Shore Acres
Silver Lake
Stapleton
Todt Hill
Tottenville
West Brighton
Westerleigh

94 places in Staten Island, ordered by rating:

Ariemma’s Italian Deli
4.6
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 718-979-2630
Address:
1791 Hylan Blvd
Delis / Italian
Giovannis Trattoria
4.2
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 718-227-3914
Address:
3800 Richmond Ave
Italian /
Michelangelo’s Pizza
4.3
3 reviews
Telephone:
+1 718-273-7541
Address:
860 Post Ave
Pizza / Italian
Da Noi
4.3
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 718-720-1650
Address:
138 Fingerboard Rd
Italian /
Aunt Butchies of Brooklyn
3.9
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 718-227-0002
Address:
4864 Arthur Kill Rd
Italian / Bakeries / Cocktail Bars
Michael’s Meatballs & Martinis
4.1
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 347-695-8160
Address:
1816 Hylan Blvd
Italian /
Trattoria Romana
4.0
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 718-980-3113
Address:
1476 Hylan Blvd
Italian /
La Strada Restaurant
4.0
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 718-667-4040
Address:
139 New Dorp Ln
Italian /
Zio Toto
3.0
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 718-317-0373
Address:
86 Page Ave
Italian /
Mr Pizza’s Pasta House
3.3
15 reviews
Telephone:
+1 718-370-0102
Address:
2317 Richmond Ave
Pizza / Italian
Benvenuti Pizzeria e Trattoria
3.3
12 reviews
Telephone:
+1 718-967-6560
Address:
15 Giffords Ln
Italian / Pizza
Pasticceria Bruno
3.9
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 718-987-5859
Address:
1650 Hylan Blvd
Bakeries / Italian / Breakfast & Brunch
Nunzio’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
3.5
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 718-667-9647
Address:
2155 Hylan Blvd
Italian / Pizza
Romeo’s Pizzeria and Restaurant
3.3
7 reviews
Telephone:
+1 718-356-3300
Address:
34 Jefferson Blvd
Italian / Pizza
La Pinela
3.5
2 reviews
Telephone:
+1 718-447-2706
Address:
163 Dongan St
Italian / American (Traditional)
Goodfella’s
1.6
11 reviews
Telephone:
+1 718-815-8500
Address:
1817 Victory Blvd
Pizza / Italian
Tiki Island
2.5
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 718-948-1903
Address:
Port Atlantic Yacht Club 225 Ellis St
Lounges / Italian / American (New)
Bario’s Restaurant
1.8
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 718-370-0100
Address:
446 Nome Ave
Pizza / Italian / Food Delivery Services
That’s Italian
···
Telephone:
+1 718-370-1061
Address:
2655 Richmond Ave Ste 2505
Italian /
LJ’s Buona Pasta
···
Telephone:
+1 718-967-9385
Address:
3935 Amboy Rd
Italian /

Italian in nearby cities:

Jackson Heights
Rego Park
Fair Lawn