Whittemore Ice Cream

Seymour, United States

3.9

Closed now

13 reviews

Does not accept credit cards

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 203-888-5459
Address:
114 S Main St, Seymour, CT, 06483
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
0.6 miSeymour
2.9 miAnsonia
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Accepts Credit Cards
No
Parking
Private Lot
Bike Parking
Yes
Wi-Fi
No

Today

Today 3:00 pm – 9:30 pm
Closed now
Local time (Seymour) 10:59 Wednesday, 23 April 2025

Business hours

Monday 3:00 pm – 9:30 pm
Tuesday 3:00 pm – 9:30 pm
Wednesday 3:00 pm – 9:30 pm
Thursday 3:00 pm – 9:30 pm
Friday 3:00 pm – 9:30 pm
Saturday 1:00 pm – 9:30 pm
Sunday 1:00 pm – 9:30 pm

Related places

You might also like:
1
mi
Yogurt Island
172 North St
1.4
mi
Ice Cream Emergency
2-48 Mountain Road
1.6
mi
Peachwave
71 Oxford Rd
3.9
mi
Nonnie’s
121 Amity Rd
4.3
mi
Sundaes by the River
418 Roosevelt Dr
5
mi
Baskin Robbins
198 Leavenworth Rd

Nearby

Near this location:
10
ft
Roll’os Food Truck
114 South Main St
140
ft
Petzold’s Appliance Parts Center
100 S Main St
800
ft
Lunch Box 23
1000 Every St
1
mi
Soncca
29 Maple St
1
mi
Team Inc Child Care Serv
29 Maple St
1
mi
John’s Deli
45 Maple St

13 reviews of Whittemore Ice Cream

No registration required
Place rating: 4
Seymour, CT
Nothing beats freshly made waffle cone with ice cream that’s as equally as good! Ice cream is smooth and creamy, not sure if it’s made there but their signature flavor is Irish cream. It gets pricey with additional toppings but if you keep it simple, then 1 – 2 scoops of just the ice cream is all one needs to satisfy a sweet tooth. However if you want to splurge then get the waffle cone! Whitmore’s also makes floats, shakes and has soft serve as well. Plenty of toppings and flavors to choose from.
Whitmore’s is off route 115; with outdoor seating. Inside is full of Great Depression memorabilia and worthy of checking out, beautiful woodwork with exposed beams. I absolutely love the toasted almond on a waffle cone!
Place rating: 5
Seymour, CT
This place sells delicious ice cream. Some flavors I haven’t seen anywhere else. The décor is pleasent, mostly benches and some tables.
Place rating: 2
Oxford, CT
Thos was a fantastic Ice Cream Shop at one time before the new owners took over. My favorite is Irish Cream… did not have it they were out… tried pistacio… they were out… finially ordered chocolate moose… they had it along with the bonus ice crystals formed on the ice cream… very disappointing ice cream trip.
Place rating: 4
Ansonia, CT
This is my favorite ice cream shop. Their chocolate fudge brownie ice cream is my favorite. They have a large variety of ice cream and sugar-​free versions, as well as frozen yogurt. There is a good variety of toppings. Lots of parking space. Indoor and outdoor seating. The only things I don’t like about this place is the floorboards are creaky and easy to trip over, and they don’t accept credit or debit cards, which is inconvenient.
Place rating: 5
Los Angeles, CA
They made the waffle cone in the moment, custom for my Cashew Carmel Waffle Cone! Yumm
Place rating: 3
Seymour, CT
I’ve been a Seymoron since 1999, and I’ve been to Whittemore’s a few times. It’s in a nifty historical building, which is nice, and the service is pretty good as well. I will say though, that I’m picky about ice cream and this will influence my review quite a bit. I hate most hard ice cream. You know how most kids are about eating liver, broccoli, and lima beans? That’s how I am about hard ice cream, mainly because I’ve been spoiled by Talenti gelato and Rita’s frozen custard, not to mention all the places that offer 24 flavors of soft serve. My family still insists on going here every now and then, so I oblige. I will say that if nothing else, their flavor and topping assortment is decent. I heartily agree with the others saying that Rich Farms in Oxford is a better bet because I can at least remember the taste of the ice cream from there.
Place rating: 5
Seymour, CT
The best spot for ice cream in the Valley. Great flavors — even some tasty sugar free options — and very friendly staff. I recommend the cherry chocolate chip but the butter pecan is great too. Love their waffle cones!
Place rating: 5
South Windsor, CT
So I Was visiting my grandparents and they wanted to go here for ice cream little did I know the building was historical (and I LOVE historical places) the ice cream was also great and the service was even better. If your A local or on the way to the beach this place is great!
Place rating: 4
Seymour, CT
Love coming here for those hot summer nights. Fresh and tasty ice cream, good service, and just a great place to sit and hang with friends while having a nice cool treat.
Place rating: 4
Manassas, VA
A great ice cream place here in little Seymour, CT and its got a lot of history so that’s really neat great variety decent prices if you’re in town stop by and check em out
Place rating: 3
Denver, CO
Cute place with plenty of seating and a huge parking lot. They were opened late which was nice because our other option was the grocery store. I got the mint chip which was creamy, minty and not green. I topped it with chocolate syrup and it hit the spot. The only issue I had was the large amount of freezer burn on the inside of the cases– definitely in need of a defrost.
Place rating: 4
Southport, CT
This old building (apparently build in the 1800s) is charming & quite New England adding to its nostalgic charm– not a bad thing when it comes to an old fashioned ice cream parlor.
The proprietor & his family own & run this spot. They are Turkish & also own the local Captain’s Pizza chain.
I happen to love all things coconut. So I really liked their Mounds ice cream. They were out of a few key flavors when I went so I can not attest to other flavors. But it is creamy (they should not keep it sooo cold as its a bit too hard), sweet but the cream shines through the additional ingredients, nice ratio of ice cream to add ins. The hot fudge was dark, thick & not too sweet– nice balance. They offer all the traditional ice cream flavor options & some imaginative ones too.
Large private parking. Inside/​out door seating. Clean bathrooms.
Place rating: 3
Manassas, VA
Whittemore’s has been in Seymour for a few years now. It faces some pretty stiff competition from competitors in Oxford, but it holds its own pretty well. The ice cream is quite fresh and tasty, and they offer a pretty wide variety of flavors. Yet, Whittemore’s ice cream just isn’t as decadent as others. I can’t put my finger on what’s missing, but something is. On the plus side, they do stay open fairly late (10pm) for when you need a late-​night fix. On the negative side, they’re a cash-​only establishment which can be a bit inconvenient. All in all, they’re good when you need to satisfy a craving, but you’re better off going a town over for the really good stuff.