New York Pizza & Plus

I still like their pizza. I’m disappointed that their lasagna is still on the menu but not available any longer. Still, it’s good pizza.

The pizza was just okay. A little doughy, not crispy. The mozzarella sticks did not test like mozzarella. The salad was pretty decent. But they deliver!

My office is down the street and I frequently order a mass amount of pizza from here for the staff. There are always tons of coupons available and very budget friendly if you are trying to feed 40 plus people. My favorite so far is the CA garlic chicken. Greasy and delicious!

We had ordered pizza from here for the last 5 years on a pretty regular basis. In the beginning when I would work late I could call in the order pay over the phone and send my boys to pick it up since we only lived across the street. Was great! And very convenient. Never ever had a problem.
Eventually, recently, they stopped allowing me to do this. No explanation just «they don’t do that» (hmm ok I only been doing it all this time) Ok wutev. nonetheless a few weeks back I was hosting a party and ordered a few pizzas. I was running behind and sent my son with my atm to pay. At the restaurant they wouldn’t accept it. So my son paid cash. Ok, all good.
Last weekend we tried to order pizza when I learned my account was flagged. The cashier couldn’t really explain why just that apparently I didn’t have my id when we tried to buy pizza last time. (Hm ok but we paid cash) Soo I was finally able to place the order and this time have it delivered. But what got me was when the delivery came I wanted to use another card and he wouldn’t take it. Had my id. But said he needed the card I told him on the phone. He proceeded to become irritated and said that this was the reason my account was flagged and that they were told not to take my orders. WTF?! I then Gave him the card and ID I ordered with. I couldn’t believe it! After all these years… No problems what so ever… I told him that we have plenty of other options around here and we will not be ordering from them again. last weekend was our absolute last time. They lost a loyal customer.

The pizza is pretty here, just alittle on the greasy side. They have a lunch special: small personal pizza with a soda for $ 5. It’s a great lunch deal.

Super disorganized & food will take forever if you ordered there and wait. Related to pizza; there’s nothing New York about it. People taking your order should give the right expectation; it took close to 30 mins to get ours.

Love this place! The BEST, non greasy pizza I have ever had! Lots of toppings too! They definitely do not skimp! Service is outstanding and you get a FREE 2 liter of soda when you pickup. Can’t beat that! Pizza is ALWAYS fresh and hot! It’s super clean inside, they work pretty fast to get the pizza done by the time you get there. Give them a try. You won’t be disappointed! And the price is right!

I had the New York style pepperoni and mushrooms and some garlic bread. It was amazing!

I absolutely love this place. I believe they were having a special going on so it was $ 5 for a small pizza + a drink and I was a little skeptical because a deal so great wouldn’t have tasted as great. I was wrong because food tasted great! The staff was completely friendly and professional.
Also as a tip, I called ahead of time and ordered my pizza before I actually got there just to save myself some time.

My reviews all start with 5 stars and one star is taken off for every negative. So overall this place is pretty good. This was our first time there even though I have driven by it a hundred times. Finally got tired of saying that we need to try this place and did. First impression was it was one of those hole in the wall places that turn out to be hidden treasures. It wasn’t quite a treasure but was worth it. We got a pizza, wings and potato skins and took it home. Everything was pretty good. They deliver so next time I think we will stay at home and have them bring the food to us.
The negatives were two minor ones worth half a star each. First half a star for the very small dinning room. The few tables that are there are so cramped that it makes eating there uncomfortable and awkward. Second the ice machine was broken so even had we eaten there there was no ice for drinks. Beyond that, it is a good pizza joint and we will go back.

I’ve been to this place twice, I live across the street so it’s super convenient when I want some pizza. Unfortunately, both times have been weird, weird and disappointing. The 2^nd experience; I ordered something pretty simple, small pizza and mozzarella, easy right? I order for delivery, they say «45−1hr.» Nope, two hours later and two phone calls later, still waiting. did I mention I live across the street? Sure I could have ordered for pick up, but hey, this is my day off… Lol.
Sadly, I am no longer interested in their food due to lack of professionalism and poor customer service and the pizza isn’t rewarding enough to deal with their short comings… sucks, it’s so close..

Incredibly disappointed!!!
I stopped here for a sandwich for lunch. I ordered a beef and chicken sandwich. The beef was completely raw as you can see by the picture I uploaded. I told the guy at the counter and he didn’t seem concerned. The sandwich was hot in some places, cold in others. I only ate a few bites of it. I ordered mozzarella sticks as well which came out luke warm and the sauce came straight from the fridge. I’m only writing this review in hopes that the owner sees it and can take action before someone gets sick.

When I moved into the area in June of 2012, this pizza was absolutely fantastic. Ordered it all the time. But something changed like 1 or 2 years ago. Now it’s really pretty mediocre. They are VERY skimpy on the sauce! Just lacking in flavor all the way around. I’m not sure if it changed owners or what. Also, I think the employees really need to work on their professionalism and phone skills. They will treat you like a nuisance when they answer the phone and put you on hold for eons. Used to put up with it for the pizza but unfortunately that is no longer what it used to be. Bummer, because I live pretty close to this place.

********Beware When Consuming *********
Normally, this place is good cheap pizza, but I dont care what you pay or if it’s free, you should never have to bite into a screw and then a bug! Even worse when they try to tell you your lying really you think we wanted to drive 20mins back and not eat 3 pizzas and a gyro, especially knowing we are repeat customers same order every weekend. At least acknowledge that its disgusting not to mention dangerous, thank goodness our 2 yr didnt choke on the screw. Then to say the bug was a mushroom, you decide for yourself I posted picsof both, but it crunched and had legs, but the girl swears its a mushroom, I dare her to take a bite… I think it’s also an insult when you then offer a refund for 1 pizza, NO, i want all my money here is your food back and i will be reporting it to the health inspectors, GROSS, if you don’t acknowledge it and try to make sure it doesn’t happen again what else are you not acknowledging, Rats, Roaches, Flies, Maggots. …Yuck!!!

In town for a soccer tournament and I needed a «semi quick» dinner for my daughter, since it was so late, and this place was only two minutes away from our hotel. I went for a thin crust pepperoni & olive medium pizza with a greek salad. The salad was «decent», but was a healthier alternative at such a late hour.
The pizza was a perfect size for us both, & we even had some leftover. The crust wasn’t NY style thin crust, which was disappointing, but the cheese and loads of pepperoni/​olive, sauce and flavor made up for it. I suggest ordering before you head over. They also offer other appetizers to choose from.
BONUS~~~ I got a free two litre soda with my purchase! Woohoo!

Was craving pizza the other day so decided to give this place a try as its across the street from work. A coworker and I ordered it in around 1130am for pick up at 12pm and they let us know they would put it in the oven at about 11:45 as it only took 15 minutes to cook.
At 11:40 or so, we got a call back and apparently they were out of jalapenos and wanted to see what else we would rather have on the pizza. Such great service, rather than waiting until we got there! The flavors were good, reminded me a little of Round Table but a lot cheaper. A little greasy but then again it’s pizza and can’t beat the lunch special: $ 5 flat for a personal 3 topping and a soda. Definitely a great treat when I’m craving pizza for lunch.

Each time I come here I am impressed. Cooked to perfection and always quick!
I love the options for the specials and being able to customize my pizza for a low cost!
Thanks guys!

I had ordered XL combo on white sauce for pick up. They made it on red sauce, then tried convincing me to take the one with red sauce like it was not a big deal. Finally, they made the one on white sauce that lacked ingredients and did not give me a 2ltr soda that comes with pick up orders. Customer service is 0 stars, no hi or bye, didn’t ask if I needed any plates, silverware, napkins, ranch, etc…
If you want to pay $ 21 for a pizza dough with some sauce on it, save yourself some money and just head to the nearest grocery store. BEWARE.

Uum Heck no would I ever return here!
I was originally walking in to enjoy a nice warm slice of pizza. (Apparently, they sell pizza by the slice until 1pm) So, here I am 1:15 pm and they were sold out. Wah! I should have left then! However, the lady a tthe counter tells me they have a lunch special which consisted of 1 small pizza for $ 5 and a fountain drink. I figured eeh what the heck because I was totally craving pizza.
So I take a seat in their little dinning room area (which is pretty cute by the way) and I begin reading. About ten minutes later I hear two of the employees bickering at each other about their job tasks. «That ain’t ma job!» and «I’mma leave»… ooookay… So out comes my pizza and it looks alright. so chomp chomp. I started eating
Well, for starters the crust was bland and burnt around the edges so obviously i just ate the good stuff (The middle). However, when I was all done I was pretty sad because I was full but not satisfied. I just felt like blah. The pizza didn’t really have any flavor and it was sloppy because the cheese would just drip down. I can’t put my finger on it but it just wasn’t as tasty as I wish I could have been.
Anyhow, i jump in my car and midway home my stomach growls. I think oh no I hope that place didn’t make me sick. I park my car walk into my house and start feeling sick. Sure enough an hour later and lordy lord! I got super sick!!! I’m not sure if I grossed myself out or what but I thought of the pizza place and it kinda smelled like it may have been a dog kennel (it smelled like wet dog). Sure enough this thought create a gag reflex that in turn made me vomit and vomit and vomit. So at this point, just the thought of pizza grosses me out.
thank you but No thank you

As someone who has lived in New York, calling this place New York Pizza is an insult. First of all, my dough wasn’t cooked through and was gummy in the middle — ew. Second, I’m pretty sure the fresh tomato I got was actually canned diced tomato.
Third, their menu makes no sense. They don’t just list everything you can order with a price. I thought maybe their website just sucked, but even the to-​go menu you can grab in the store is a flyer without everything listed. Like, they list a sampler that has mozzarella sticks and wings, but no where does it say you can just buy wings with a price and how many wings are included. You are basically rolling the dice on the price and the portion size. Stupid.
There are better places to get pizza. I recommend going to either Hot Italian or Chicago’s Pizza.