Antimo’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

This place is a hidden gem. Some unique specialty slices (favorite so far is the vodka one). Great cheesesteaks, mozz sticks, zucchini sticks, and chicken parm entrée. Great service and reasonable prices. My new go to local pizza ahead of Pizza Palace and Mamma Caterina!

I recently ordered two orders of 8 piece chicken tenders or at least I thought I did. When I came home I noticed that they gave us only 6 pieces in each order and still charged us the same price as an 8 piece. When I called to inquire the lady over the phone said that they recently got an order of chicken tenders that were bigger than normal and that’s why they gave only 6 instead of 8 pieces. REALLY? When I took a closer look at the pieces they may have been marginally bigger but not enough to do what they did. Way to screw your customers Antimo’s. Good Job!

Great family business in our little neighbor. Love it there! Always a stop for us after sports and when I don’t have time to cook! Our favorite is the meatball and onion pizza. Yummy

Tried this place out the other week for a take out pie, having been disappointed with options in my hometown. Pie was delicious, only complaint is that I would have enjoyed more sausage on the pie. Sauce was good, well seasoned, and the crust was just as I like, thin, but not too thin. Good that Antimo’s stays open a little later (until 10), than other places, which mostly close at 9. The staff were very friendly.

Antimo’s is the perfect place to grab a slice, enjoy a good conversation and eat some awesome food. They care about Pizza and it comes through with every pie. We love the fact they grill and cook the veggies a bit before throwing them on the awesome dough. We like our Pizza «Well Done» and this is our new favorite place.
On top of the great Pizza, and Pasta, the staff and owners are friendly and caring. Always greet you with a smile and seem happy to be a part of the community. With three young boys Pizza is a staple and we never go wrong with Antimo’s.

I have eaten at Antimo’s many times and every meal has been excellent. The staff is friendly and welcoming. They always say hello when you walk in the door. I have not been a fan of pizza in the past but I tried the pizza here, I was blown away. I would recommend the Grandma Vodka Pie. Its original and very tasty. I would also recommend the Sausage with Vodka Sauce and their cheesesteaks. The cheesesteaks are amazing. Better then Pats and Gino’s in Phily.

I never review most «in town» pizza joints because they are mostly not memorable. There was a time before pizza franchises, deep dish pizza and California pizza when great NY Style pizza reigned supreme in NJ. In the last 10 years, mostly due to the pizza wars, almost all local pizza places have been forced to cut prices and quality to survive.
One day last week while at my favorite local golf driving range I see a grand opening sign for Antimo’s. I decide to grab a slice after golf expecting the usual local pizza joint experience and what I got was completely different. Antimo’s is «old school» Brooklyn pizza — light and crunchy crust with bright flavored (not thick sweet) uncooked tomato sauce and the right amount of cheese — the perfect NY style slice. Went back a few days later for another slice and a chicken parm sandwich and loved both again. Went back again and tried the Sicilian slice which may be the best Sicilian slice in Morris County.
If you are a fan of real NY Style pizza check out Antimo’s — its the pizza place that looks like a house, near the Mt Freedom driving range and across the street from another pizza place!