Peaches N Cream

The best ice cream I’ve ever had. Finally chose the raspberry ice cream. Even though I got a «normal» size it was huge! I live in New York City and came to Painted Post visiting a family member and she insisted we come here. I’ve been to countless «specialty» ice cream places in Manhattan but none of them even compare to here. Now I can’t wait to go back!

Hard ice cream in a ton of flavors, soft serve, frozen yogurt, and sundays too! People were super friendly, described several of the unique flavors for us. Prices are low, serving sizes are huge. «Baby» size was big enough for me. Kids got the «kids» size and couldn’t finish!
Outdoor seating available in the SHADE and a little farmers market right next door!

The ice cream here is absolutely phenomenal. It’s so delicious!!! The portions are absolutely huge. What a special upstate treat. The ice cream is so fresh and it truly is a wonderful spot. I try to go as much as possible

As a child, I lived in Painted Post, went to Erwin Valley Elementary School, and got ice cream at Peaches N Cream. As an adult, I recent visited Painted Post had to make a stop at Peaches N Cream. It was exactly as awesome as i remembered it. Huge selection and massive portions of seriously delicious ice cream, it was like stepping back into my childhood. Don’t ever change, love you!

BE WARNED: Portions are HUGE.
Don’t let the name «baby» and «child» fool you on the size because it is ridiculous how large the cones can be. The first time I visited here I ordered a mixed «child» cone with rainbow sprinkles [yeah I’m an adult] and it was the size or a normal small, possibly medium. I was shocked, the picture they draw with how big the sizes are don’t do it justice because it’s way bigger. I saw someone order the medium and I think my head exploded with how big it as, massive; no way I could ever eat that much from a medium. So be cautious when ordering. The second time I just ordered a baby in a cup with sprinkles and it was still a very good sized portion.
It’s a great place to get soft serve (and even hard) ice cream. I didn’t get the hard ice cream but I am sure it is just as delicious. I highly recommend trying it if you are in the area. There is a ton to choose from, I haven’t been during the evening/​night-​dessert hours but I hear the lines are long but I think it would be worth it. Lots of tables and there is a market attached to buy fruits if you’re feeling up to it!

The absolute BEST ice cream place. Unbelievably affordable and generous on sizes (a small is 3 full scoops). Service is great. They are almost always busy so it does take some time to get through the line during peak times but they do great at getting through all the costumers as quickly as possible. I’ve never had any complaints despite numerous visits.

Enjoyed a nice Waffle cone full of Perry’s Ice Cream. Generous portions and a broad selection of flavors of Hard Ice-​cream. Nice seating around their shop. We stopped on our way back to Rochester from a visit in PA. Thank you.

Incredible quantity and quality of ice cream and outstanding service. A small is three huge scoops. Like an old fashioned ice cream stand used to be in the 60’s.

We love visiting Grandma, because it’s also a chance to visit Peaches ‘n’ Cream! They have terrific ice cream, both hard and soft serve. Servings are generous — from «baby» up to «large,» one to five scoops. You can definitely get as stuffed as you want, and it tastes like good quality ingredients. I love little independent ice cream places like this!
There’s also a nice little farmers market /​plant store attached, with plenty of fresh fruits and vegetables if you feel like being a little healthier :-)