Stick&Pop

I work in the neighborhood and stumbled upon this great little shop when they were first opening up. Not only are all the pops DELICIOUS, but they also have such a great variety. The girls who run the shop are some of the nicest people I know, and they will be sorely missed if they ever leave. They helped me with a last minute Thanksgiving order, and even gave me a little treat when I was having a bad day after a trip got canceled last minute. Make sure you stop in and try the Johnny Cakes or the O’Hara. Two of my favs. From the bon-​bons, to the minis, and the full sized pops, everything tastes great. So much heart is put into their creations and you can totally feel the love in the cakes. Plus, they love Bravo TV, so feel free to bond over Real Housewives love when you stop in. :)

Tragically, storefront is closed! I showed up and there was a «For Rent» sign in the window. I then called the number and they said they are shutting down the business in the next few months (including online).
Order these glorious cake pops online while you still cannnn!

Abysmal customer service. I ordered several hundred dollars worth of product and they didn’t arrive on time for the event. When I contacted the store, they were rude and snapped at me and insisted I hadn’t placed the order. I told them I had a confirmation email so they said they’d call back. When they called back, they blamed it on UPS and said there’s nothing they can do. For a small business, they’re awfully cavalier with their customers. I’ve ordered from them before and know their product is good, which is the ONLY reason I gave even one star. Beware before spending any significant amount of money with them and CERTAINLY don’t trust them with timeliness for your special event. Cake pops are available at many other fine bakeries and retailers… don’t waste your time with people who treat you as a dollar figure and not a valued customer.

Super cute shop. Very nice proprietor. Get the peanut butter pop!

I was looking for a place to find cake pops for a client gift. Low and behold there was Stick&Pop! The venue is tiny but holds a variety of delicious cake pops and I found EXACTLY what I wanted. Thank you SO much for being super nice and helpful while I tried to figure out what I was in fact getting. I’ll be back!

The people that work here are very nice and it was immaculate!
I think each cake pop was $ 3.50 and considering I can get a great cupcake for $ 2.50-$ 4.00 I thought it was over priced.
The ration of cake to frosting was off for me, I would have preferred more cake.
If I had to choose between a cake pop or a billy’s cupcake I’d go for the cupcake… more for your money!

Really can’t say enough good things about Stick and Pop’s cake pops. I ordered 14 dozen of them for an event and they were the most beautiful, delicious things — a sight to behold and taste! I was sorry I didn’t have more left over because I can’t wait to have them again. Plus, dealing with Jackie on the order was seamless. Thinking of swinging by this weekend to get some to bring to a Super Bowl party even though its completely out of the way — Stick and Pop is totally worth the trip!

Stick & Pop, you’ve turned me into a Nutty Bunny and I’m nutty over your cake pops!
I popped my Stick & Pop cherry today while I was walking from my apartment over to Marshall’s to do a little bit of Christmas shopping with the hordes.
I dropped in and picked up a Nutty Bunny (carrot cake with peanut topping) and a Darling (chocolate/​cookie dough type cake with sugar sprinkles).
I ate the Nutty Bunny on my walk. I got about one block (about three bites) into the pop and with only one bite left I about did a 360 to go right back for another one.
The cake inside these pops is absolutely the moistest, most delicious cake I’ve had in ages. I have my fair share of delicious cupcakes from Magnolia, Crumbs, Empire, etc but none of their cupcakes come close to the cake in these cake pops.
People, do yourself a favor and get over to Chelsea for the goods before this bunny goes back to do a cake raid.

ok, I don’t know about those other people saying that it takes them 2 – 4 bites to finish one of these cake pops, and how big their mouths really are, but these cake pops are big enough for at least 8 bites: p. Compared to starbucks cake pops, stick&pop pops are probably about a pop and a half, maybe even two in size. Quality wise, they are very good, fresh and have a cookie dough texture. The pops are just the right amount of sweet (not too sweet to have you grabbing for some water –_​-​) and come in an interesting combination of flavors (unlike the typical chocolate and vanilla flavors). My only grievance is the price…$ 3.21 a pop, hence a –star, although I understand all the work it takes just to produce one pop, and it doesn’t hurt to splurge a little once in a while. So would I try another cake pop from this cute, small and clean establishment? Yep!

This place is marvelous.
I would simply leave my review stating just that, but that would not do this adorable little establishment justice!
Whenever I have come here (which at this point has only been 2 tiems) I am always greeted warmly and with many comments on the current creations that I am staring at. The decorations are light and minimal, with a touch of whimsy added.
The product itself might seem cliché and annoying because it’s something you can do at home, but so are cupcakes and everyone likes those. These cake pops are ABSOLUTELY delicious. I’ve tasted the Darling, the Moonpop, the Griswald, and I’ve had their «cups» (which look like little reese’s cups but with the same flavors as their pops come in) in the Johnny cakes. All of these flavors were moist, decadent, and made me sad that it was gone in about 4 bites.
They are a tad pricey, but it’s worth every penny once you eat that first bite :)

And here I thought I’d have to consign myself to hitting up Starbucks every time I was craving a cake pop. We came upon Stick&Pop completely by accident … while walking to Pinkberry so Brian could get his dessert fix. I actually tripped and nearly killed myself in oncoming traffic when I locked eyes with the sign and began absentmindedly crossing the street — a shop that ONLY SELLS CAKE POPS!!! Incredible.
The two ladies behind the counter were in the midst of trying out a new recipe that would include Pop Rocks (I know, why didn’t I think of that?) but were really nice and helpful. I ended up getting four pops, partially because I knew Brian would end up eating some of all of them, but mostly because there were too many options to commit myself to just one.
Griswald — Marshmallow and vanilla cake with chocolate pieces, dipped in dark chocolate and covered in crushed graham crackers. Two things ran through my mind as I ate it: What a brilliant way to re-​imagine a S’more (one of my all-​time favorite snacks) — and — Why do they call it a Griswald?
Johnny Cakes — Peanut butter cake dipped in dark chocolate and covered in crushed pretzels. This was a no-​brainer for Brian since he’s obsessed with all things chocolate-​peanut butter.
The Lunchbox — Peanut butter cake with raspberry reduction. I felt like I was back in elementary school eating a PB&J sandwich (would have been great with a glass of iced cold milk)
Moonpop — Vanilla cheesecake dipped in dark chocolate, topped in Oreo crunches. Very rich and decadent.
Good to know: They also cater, and do deliveries on large orders.

The three month old and I went to Moms work today, and stopped by Stick&Pop for a couple dozen cake pops for all the ladies at her design office in the fashion district.
I knew I wanted the Johnny Cakes, so I got 8 of them and let the lady pick out the rest. We dropped them off at the office and let the little girl get passed around and get pinched and smile. We left, and my wife returned home with a couple leftovers, and I finally got my Johnny Cake and it was great. I am NOT a dessert person, no sweet tooth here, but these were good. It was like cake cookie dough covered in chocholate and nuts.
I would highly recomend this place for a snack or a little get together. The owner of my wifes company took the card to order them in the future. The cake pops were a hit.

This place is exceptionally amazing! Since the first day I tried their delicious pops I was hooked. I was lucky enough to visit this place the first week they opened. I bought six of their flavors and the next day I had to go back for the other five pops. I was very impressed with the quality and flavors that they offer. You can definitely tell that Stick&Pop does an amazing job manufacturing and developing their outstanding product.
The atmosphere in the store is bright and pleasant. Both owners are always happy and welcoming. There is not one day that you go into the store and you are not received warmly with a smile by the staff. Clearly, you can sense that they enjoy what they do and that they are confident in their product.
Their prices are very reasonable for the quality that is offered, the fine ingredients and the artistry that it takes to create their scrumptious pops.
Looking for a different dessert adventure beyond the ubiquitous cupcake, Stick&Pop is a must-​do.

I got a bunch of the mini cake pops to give out as favors for a party. The were sooooo cute and delicious the guests started hoarding them! I wish I bought more.
Also, the ladies who own Stick&Pop are extremely warm and welcoming. They provide excellent customer service along with their amazing pops!

I’m really just not a fan… It’s WAY too overpriced. I’m no stickler, I’ll shell out 5+ bucks for a gourmet cupcake… but these cake pops are waaay too small for the whopping price of $ 3+
I maaaybe got 3 small bites out of it.
We got:
–Griswald (way better than the latter)
–Johnny Cakes
We were recommended by a friend to try the lunch box, but of coure, they were all out when we got there :(But here’s the thing, I wouldn’t even go back to try that flavor… just not worth it.

A delicious option for a fun customized gift. The cake pops were fresh and with a great balance of flavors. I was fortunate to be served by the owner who showed a great deal passion for making her customers happy. I recommend you stop by for a pop! Also great for a gift to bring to a party.

I visited the neighborhood only for their cake pop since I spotted it from a magazine. It is like a lil factory for catering which means no seat and not much choice on display. I was attracted by the pix from their website. In the reality, they only have under 10 choices. I got a white one, I dont remember the name. The inner cake is too moisturized, like mash bean texture. I would like to have it a lil bit solid or soft but not like over crushing.
I would come here for party catering, which means I can customize which outfit I want it to be. If you are just walking by, not a matter to make a stop and get a pop cake though.
2 star for the price, since I cant get more delicious one from starbucks.
2.5 for the environment, it’s an office (lil one) or I would say factory (lil lil backery)
3 for the cake, I just gonna say two, but I expecting too much, actually it’s not that bad
A– OK Place

I just stumbled upon this little gem yesterday in Chelsea. The super friendly ladies behind the counter said they had been open for about 8 days! I hadn’t heard of this company before but after a boozy brunch around the corner these cake pops looked like the perfect sweet treat — actually the couple walking out of the store convinced my friend and I to go in (one of them had cake in her teeth so I took that as a good sign).
We both got the Johnny Cakes pop which is peanut butter dipped in dark chocolate rolled in pretzel bits & salt — we enjoyed them immediately. I also got a nutty bunny which is carrot cake dipped in white chocolate and rolled in nuts it was INSANE and is my fav by far. I can’t wait to go back!!! Oh and it is on 19^th St between 8^th and 9^th Ave — I just wish they were on the east side too!

Have not tried their pops yet, but just look at them! They’re gorgeous.
I’ve also contacted the owners, Christy & Jacki, about a few things including a bridal shower that I’m throwing. They’ve been nothing but professional and accommodating. And they’re so sweet! (Just like their pops, I’m sure!)

My office just passed one out to everybody after a company-​wide meeting. I grabbed a Griswald flavour pop. It’s a marshmallow and vanilla cake, dipped in dark chocolate and rolled in graham. The pop was basically made to look like a giant lollipop.
And holy shit, that mofo was delicious. It gave me a gastronomical boner. I can’t wait for Stick&Pop to open a physical location.