Pie Pie Pizza

I’ve only gotten delivery, but this seriously is some of the best pizza in the area. The perfect Olga for pizza. The crust is light & doughy. The toppings are evenly distributed. It’s totally flavorful. So happy I finally found good, NY pizza that delivers.

Definitely not the best pizza in New York, but their prices are reasonable, and there usually is a nice selection of special slices. My friend and I got two slices each with toppings, and the total was still under $ 10. One negative is that the service was a bit slow since I think there was only one person working at the time. Also, you should note that there is a $ 10 credit card minimum so it’s better to come here with cash.
I’ll probably be back again since I live in the area. They have some nice weeknight deals that I hope to take advantage of!

This is solid pizza joint on the Upper West Side, right on Columbus/​106 St. I usually just go for the plain cheese, but sometimes they have the grandma slice and that’s excellent, too. Affordable and delicious, this is a bang for your buck pizza place. Tip: Ask for extra crispy.

Pizza is very good for the value. Sometimes it can be a little bit slow, but overall I definitely recommend the place.

Reasonable pizza with good quality. The fact that their pizza is not greasy, always soft and never burnt, adds to why I always go back. I recommend their pepperoni pizza since it’s the perfect balance between sauce, cheese, and meat. I’ve lived in this area for two years and it’s much better then other competitors. Plus, better management and staff!

This is why you can’t always go off Unilocal reviews… Sometimes people don’t know what they are talking about. So far the best and cheapest pizza I’ve found on the UWS. Nice thin and tasty crust. I recommend the spinach with ricotta. Also cheap compared to the spots on Broadway in the area. Definitely my go to pizza spot for now.

It’s official: Good pizza is extinct, at least in this neighborhood.
So great was my desire for a decent pizza after having already given up, that I fell, hook-​line-​and-​sinker, for their marketing: I imagined that «no sugar in the sauce» and «Wisconsin and local cheeses» was just the beginning of a potentially authentic delight. Instead, it was the tail end of an ancient rat’s tail.
Aside from the sugar-​free sauce and supposedly Wisconsin cheese, everything else is commercially canned and boxed gross. If you’re drunk or accustomed to Domino’s or less, then you might not be waisting your time.
If you’re a NYer with educated taste buds, fuggedaboutit.
As for me, I give up, short of making my own or going back to Italy.
The owner has asked me to update my review, because he says my opinion is slanderous. Okay. I’ll add some facts: Despite living less than three blocks from the restaurant, and despite an email flyer encouraging me to order online, I was unable to order online because the website said I did not live within their delivery area. So, I called. The guy was nice on the phone, and when I asked about getting a crispy crust, he was quite positive that it would be no problem for me to receive a crispy crust. Somehow, my fresh-​made, crispy-​crust pizza was at my door within about ten minutes (I told you I lived close.) The crust was the opposite of crispy. In fact, it was SO floppy, I turned on the oven and baked it for another ten minutes, to no avail. Whatever is in that crust, it does not bake to a crisp. Well, I could have tried to burn it. But I digress. I attempted to eat the pizza, anyway, with a good attitude in mind, because I had been so long without. However, it just didn’t taste good. My stomach became unwell, and for the first time in my life, I threw pizza in the garbage can. None of this is opinion based on educated tastebuds. It is simply my report of what took place the night I gave up on pizza in my neighborhood, for good. Personally, I think what I wrote the first time was just as honest, but much more fun to read.

$ 1.50 for a slice cheese pizza, and it’s good. The staff is nice and the place is clean. The seating area fits about 10 – 12 people. It’s a nice neighborhood joint.

I love this place, and much needed in this neighborhood. Pizza is delish, and their brisket meatball subs are too. Totally reasonable prices as well.

Cheap, decent and fast pizza in the area. Better alternative to Domino’s.