The Ice Cream Shoppe

The ice cream is great. I like this place because you can’s go inside and sit down and eat. A lot of amazing flavors. And they make ice cream cakes

The ice cream here is delicious! Stopped by this past weekend with a few friends at the end of a camping trip and was blown away by the flavorful ice cream. A medium is 3 large scoops and there are a ton of homemade flavors (20+). I had the coffee ice cream with oreo cookies and it was one of the best tasting ice creams I’ve ever had! The waffle cone was excellent as well, tasted super fresh.
I’m surprised by the generally unemphatic reviews so I am stopping by to voice my overwhelmingly positive experience. I’m from CT but will make sure to stop by if ever in the area again.

I’ve been intrigued by this place for years, but have always gone out to Sundaes or to Beach Plum (more recently, once I discovered it) and never wanted to get ice cream twice in one day. (Wait, why not??)
I decided to stop in on Sunday, on my way to Bradley Beach. The variety of flavors was good, though there was nothing really wild. I asked how many scoops were in a small, and I was told 2 (Yes!!! I hate decision making when it comes to ice cream). I got a scoop of banana fudge and vanilla pb, and this small cone was no joke (apparently a large has 4 scoops??). Definitely an ample amount of ice cream for $ 3.60-something.
Though I normally prefer crazy flavors with fun combos of cookies and candies mixed in, the ones I got were very creamy and flavorful, and they did not skimp on the ingredients. Lots of chocolate in the banana fudge and big globs of pb in the vanilla pb… not some crappy little faint streaks you might find elsewhere. Also, no ice crystals like I have had sometimes at Beach Plum (which I do still love for their variety). I know I already mentioned it, but very creamy. The kind of ice cream that will drip off, not flake off.
Delicious ice cream and a great value. Loved the nostalgic feel of the building, too!

If you like homemade creamy ice cream packed with flavor, this is the place to get it. Awesome coconut ice cream with them coconut flakes.

we used to go here all the time. but could a soft cone get any smaller… every year they get smaller and smaller makes you think what else are they cutting down on. back to the beach plum…

I can’t believe I had to add this business on here. With so many seasonal ice cream shops all over the place, I was also surprised, but thankful, this place was even open on a Winter evening. There was no one parked in the lot, but all the lights were on. Okay, let’s give it a go.
I wandered in and looked over the hard ice cream flavors, eventually deciding on a Chocolate Peanut Butter waffle cone. It is virtually impossible to give any spot that craves my sweet tooth a bad rating, so it was certainly A-​OK for my first visit.