Patsy’s Pizzeria Nanuet

BEST. WOOD-​BURNING. PIZZA. PLACE. AROUND.
The classic margherita pizza, is so delicious. The sauce is slightly sweet, the crust is tasty, and the basil and the mozz is fresh. It’s so simply, and so perfectly delicious. I’m a petite person (only 5 feet tall) and I could literally eat an entire pizza myself (it’s a thin crust pizza but it’s also just THAT good.)
I’m Italian, I could live off of bread and sauce… Maybe that’s why this place is so great!
It is a little pricey (if you order more than one pie) but it’s 100% worth it.

I keep coming back for more! I love the food, location and atmosphere. It’s great that I get to go shopping and then relax at my favorite pizzeria with some good company. My waitress Teetee always greats us with a friendly smile and she always keeps us laughing. Great food, great service! P. S you need to try their tiramisu!

Great restaurant with a nice selection of pizza, pasta dishes, salads, and panini. The pizza is top-​notch, nice thin crispy crust with fresh toppings. I also highly recommend the cannoli. Excellent and friendly service too!

Patsy’s of Nanuet is amazing reminds me of the patsys I used to go to under the Brooklyn Bridge, my server was amazing she had everything I needed when I needed it, the food came out on time, was hot,

Today was our first time eating Patsy’s (Nanuet Mall) and it definitely won’t be our last! The caprese salad with burratta was amazing and the Quattro Formaggi pizza made me feel like I was back in Italy. Best of all, Agnes (our server) is the epitome of a great server. if I were still in the restaurant business, I would try to steal her! Alan, great job!
Tanti auguri a tutti! Ci vediamo la prossima volta!
Jo Ann & Jim

Stopped by this afternoon with my husband and ordered Patsy’s alla vodka, and I must say, this pie was phenomenal! Thin crust and lightly baked to perfection. The restaurant it’s self was a great experience! Good environment, great service (Forgot my waitresses’s name BUT she was a great server and super animated!) and the modern music! Great place for a quick bite!

Come here for the pizza it’s good and thin .
Don’t come here for shrimp or seafood, huge mistake .
We ordered to eat family style.
A pizza which was delicious .
A panini Also delicious .
Shrimp scampi which was rubbery and pasta that was bitter .it sucked .
Frutta del mare which had shellfish and pasta, it sucked… it was whack .
Stick to the pizza in this pizza shop.

Great pizza ! Excellent services I had fried calamari and margarita pizza while I sear at bar 5 stars Patsy’s !

This place is awesome! I was here with my family a few times (including tonight) and will definitely keep coming back! The food is always fresh and my kids love the pizza here which is thin crust and hot with a sauce that’s can’t be beat! We ordered a few apps like baked clams that taste perfectly spiced and delicious and the garlic bread basket is crispy and tasty the eggplant rollatini is rolled to perfection with just the right amount of cheese. Our waitress was very nice and made sure we had everything we needed. One of the owners Alend is always there to run things smoothly and make sure there’s always happy customers like us!
This place is very clean and food is great and can’t wait to go again! Thanks Patsy’s of Nanuet will see you soon!

Not only does Patsy’s have great pizza but the service was stellar as well! Teresa was our waitress and she was the absolute best, so friendly and accommodating. I can’t say enough great things about this awesome Nanuet gem.

3 stars for the dynamic staff and ambiance! Sadly, not a single dish tickled our fancy. We ordered eggplant parm, chicken parm, kid’s spaghetti and broccoli side. Each dish lacked flavor and salt. And, the broccoli was drenched with oil, far too many cloves of garlic… #takeyourgrandparentshere

If you know the name Patsy’s, then you probably remember what it meant — usually a trip to Harlem.
This place in the new Nanuet mall is absolutely, positively not Patsy’s. It might say Patsy’s on the awning, but the pizza here has zero resemblance to the original. That’s not to say it’s completely *BAD*, it’s not. In fact, I’ll give them points for not overdoing the sauce — it’s actually pretty good. But if you’re going here to experience a NYC institution in the pascack valley, you are going to be VERY disappointed.
My advice is for you to skip this place and go up Middletown Ave over to Martio’s. That place is fantastic, and cheaper to boot.
But if you absolutely HAVE to have the thin-​crust HOT oven experience for your pizza, I suggest you try Brooklyn’s in Hackensack — just don’t forget to bring cash as plastic is a no-​go there. It’s a bit of a hike, but is very much worth the trip if you want the whole Grimaldi’s/Patsy’s-type experience.

I am big fan of Patsy’s Pizza going way back to the original shop. I would drive from Westchester to Harlem for years just to get a few pies of that delicious pizza. A few days ago I decided to finally try the Nanuet Patsy’s — I waited because I thought that the original shop was the only way to go but I was surprisingly wrong!
The crust and sauce on this pizza are divine… My wife and kids loved it also!
Thin crispy yet brittle and soft crust, Sauce with strong zesty tomato umami and a gorgeous backdrop of herbs and spices on the finish. The cheese is quality you can only get on Arthur Avenue or Little Italy in Manhattan, chewy yet easy and authentic flavor on the chew.
I’ve been back a few times and each time confirms the deliciousness I had the first time there. Enjoy!

Patsys Pizzeria at Nanuet
Excellent! They have an excellent pizza not only… I never had better stake in my life ! bistecca with Potato Croquets and broccoli was out of this world! People always friendly and very helpful, I would definitely recommend this place for the best breakfast, Lunch and dinner. 5 stars from me Becouse I love the best stuff!

Came here with my lovely bf and he absolutely loved their Margherita pizza and told me he’d rate it 4 stars. However, I’m more into thicker crispy crusts, but I enjoyed it as well. A personal pizza (6 slices) was good enough to fill the both of us up. Being a carnivore, I don’t consider a meal, a meal unless there is some form of meat. That bring said, I ended up ordering a sausage and peppers hero as well. It was pretty good, but they skimp on the sausage (3 small slices in my half… I counted hehe). Based on the food I would give this place 3 stars.
Service: great! Our server Brittany, was very attentive and friendly! Hence the extra star…
Atmosphere: I really liked the set up of the restaurant. Very modern and the music was nice

Patsy’s is amazing! The atmosphere is great! As soon as you walk in your hit with the smell of pizza. They have a beautiful bar open to the fresh air. We sat outside– they were playing some great Italian music and it smelt like fresh basil.
We ordered the Margerita pizza and it was amazing! It came out in less than 10 minutes! The sauce, the cheese, the crust, and basil were all incredible!!! The flavor was outstanding!
Definitely recommend!

Went into Patsy’s with my girlfriend for a few drinks one time and the passive aggressive (and seemingly drunk) hostesses wouldn’t let us near the bar because we «looked too young» even though we had valid IDs. Eventually we get to the bar and the bartender looks at my license, hands it back and goes «nice try, I have kids you know. Can’t fool me». I had the new version of NYS drivers licence and she had zero idea what it looked like. It is her job to know these things as a bartender (I would assume).
After this, I ask for the manager who comes over and seems not to really care about the whole situation. He says that I look like I’m «fifteen» but the ID checks out. He has a «chat» with the bartender and says we could come over and have a drink as if he was doing us a favor.
Needless to say we declined his offer. Never felt more insulted by dining/​bar service in my life. We haven’t even went back to try the pizza after this experience.

I posted a picture some weeks ago. .. . which was well after my visit. .. . and I took a long time to write this because I was so completely & totally annoyed at the «dining experience»
Took quite awhile for the pizza to arrive, and suffice it to say that it came out totally wrong. .. the waiter didn’t bother to look at it or he would have noticed. When we were able to get him back to tell him that it was screwed up, he took great care to tell us that he was blameless because he entered it properly & the kitchen messed up. Then when the replacement pie also came out wrong, we asked to see the manager, who didn’t bother to come by. .. but the waiter promised a discount on behalf of the manager.
So we got the bill = and the discount was not applied! then we had to wait again to find the waiter to eventually get this corrected…
Look this is a pizza place for god’s sake! no rocket science involved. .. . and EXTREMELY over priced. $ 30 for a loaded pie? Product was good, but not at that price & aggravation level. Some places don’t deserve to be in business. .. .

It’s a great place for a quick meal. The parking is plentiful, they have outside seating and the décor is top notch! The food is good. The staff was attentive and quick to seat us. The waiter knew his stuff and was quick about everything. Their speciality pizzas are really good. They have good combinations and you can make your own. I see everyone stating that the staff was inattentive or slow or didn’t know… it’s ok they opened two weeks ago! Let the staff get some time to acclimate to everything. Let the management give their newly hired staff some time to gel.
Personally I thought the waiter did a great job and was knowledgable regarding the food and options. He was also really attentive to us during a high traffic time. Considering they are technically known for their pizza… order their pizzas and make your call or write your review from there.

The restaurant was maybe 40% full and yet the wait for a table was just long enough to get us annoyed and almost walk out.
We should have trusted our instincts.
The food here is unremarkable. The service was lousy.
We started by trying to order some fried calamari. Our waiter let us know that the restaurant was all out of fried calamari and fried zucchini. This was a Sunday afternoon at around 1pm.
So, we ordered a Caesar salad and an order of the melanzane di rollatine. The salad was okay despite the lack of any anchovies. The eggplant was the best thing we ate but certainly not incredible.
We shared the Margherita pie. I was not a fan of the crust. It was dry and stiff.
We passed on dessert and waited an unacceptably long amount of time to get a check.
No free refills on fountain drinks. In our case it was just soda water.
No reason to return.