Treasure In the Sand Pizzeria

Okay pizza if you’re looking for quick and easy. I’d rate the pizza a 2.5 for the taste and content and the owner a 5. She was very friendly and accommodating.

This little pizza shop is located in the straw market and it never disappoints. The ingredients are fresh and my order always comes out correct. The owner is so friendly and the staff makes everyone feel welcome.

My boyfriend and I had to wait for a while when there was no one else in the place. We finally got our food and it was not very good. Probably wouldn’t suggest this place.

terrible customer service /​food as well as in the ice cream parlor attached. to have the service be extremely slow I expect the customer service to be above par & have some decent food if not great.

Great local pizza place. Friendly service by the owner and delicious thin-​crust pizza. They serve ice cream and smoothies as well.

Kind of expensive for a little pizzeria/​sub shop. But I got a chicken sub and wings which were good tasting. And the night before I got ice cream from there. Could use some friendlier service

I chose this place based on all of reviews that I read. I must be missing something!!! I would say the pizza was okay at best. The crust was very thin and tasteless. The sauce was to sweet. Lastly way over priced. For two xl pizzas and a order of garlic bread it was almost $ 50 which I wouldn’t complain about if the pizza was good. I really wanted to like this place as I like local places.

We were lazy. She delivered 2 xl pizzas for 40 bucks. Good pizza. Was at the room in about 15 minutes. Super friendly and pizza was worth the money. Give her the business. Well, not the business, but your business.

We had wings, the turkey sub and fried Oreos. There is nothing about this place that is bad. The food and the service is outstanding! We’ve stayed in the area 2 years in a row and will now make this our permanent family vacation location, thanks to the outstanding locals and great customer service!

After a day of playing tourist we were heading back to our resort. My daughter suggested ice cream! Sounded like a good way to end the vacation day… but where could we get good ice cream at about 10:00? She looked on Unilocal and found Treasure in the Sand Pizzeria… which is attached to an ice cream store! It said they were open so we turned on the GPS and made our way over.
I’m so glad we did! Cute little area we hadn’t found yet! It’s in an area with some other local shops.
We were trying to decide between a pizza and the philly cheese steak that people recommended. The owner said she could do the pizza by the slice! Sounded perfect to me! We decided to go with ½ a pepperoni pizza and the cheese steak sandwich. The also offered the full range of Coke and Pepsi products which made me happy! We sat down to wait and before long we had our late night dinner! We were both really pleased with our selections and enjoyed talking to the owner and finding out more about the business and the area.
The bread was fresh! Great sandwich with a good amount of everything on it! My daughter enjoyed her pizza a let me try it as well! Great sauce, perfect amount of cheese and pepperoni, nice light crust… and unlike so many other businesses down here they get bonus points for spelling «pizzeria» right!
When we were done we got ice cream (and 10% off! with our dinner purchase). The worst part of the evening was having to decide which flavor of ice cream to get! I didn’t think the salted caramel and the black cherry would do well together so I went with the black cherry. Maybe we can go back later so I can try another flavor!
They don’t have public restrooms but they do take credit cards!
I’d recommend it to my friends (and I already have!) and I’d definitely come back!

This place was the worst! I guarantee the crust was pre made and frozen definitely not fresh dough. The sauce was so sugary and sweet I thought I got diabetes after one slice ! The wings so bad I could only eat one. So disgusting the sauce was more like ketchup then wing sauce putrid! I don’t know about you but when I order nachos I expect to get nachos but what I got was a pile of still tortilla chips and a plastic container Velveeta cheese. Like seriously where was the salsa, jalapeños, beans, sour cream or the guacamole. Because last time I checked all those ingredients are in nachos.

Nice small restaurant close to our condo. We didn’t care for the sauce on the pizza but heard the subs were good. Might go back and try those since we are so close! Staff was friendly and the place was clean!

After a day of walking on the beach, my girlfriend and I were both famished. After visiting Flip Flops a few times, I had noticed that there was a pizzeria/​sub shop behind it which happened to be Treasure in the Sand and thought that subs would be perfect for an early dinner. I ended up getting a chicken/​bacon/​ranch sub and my girlfriend had a buffalo chicken sub. Both were great! The shop owner makes her own hot sauce and it was amazing. I also really enjoyed the fact that the buns are toasted in the pizza oven, adding a little crunch to the inside, but not overly toasted like at a Subway. Didn’t get a chance to try the pizza, but maybe before we leave for home we will get to that!

Friendly family owned business right by the beach that was a pleasure to stop in for a quick bite. We ordered pizza but was told to try the cheesesteaks next time around. Thanks Ron!