NY Style Pizzeria & Grille

Something’s not right with this place. We had a flyer out on our door at the hotel, and we called both numbers. Turns out they seen to be cell phone numbers. I got a message from both numbers that the automated mailbox is full. The only time I have ever gotten this message was from calling a cell phone.

Fed eight people. Very good and attentive service.

Wasn’t sure we wanted to try it but glad we did. Waitress was full of personality and quickly made us comfortable. We ordered a spinach/​mozzarella pizza and it was delic! !!! Kids loved the fried pickles. If they made their own ranch it would have been perfect. Can’t do the fake ranch. Friendly and a little divey, perfect for the late night snack.

Disclaimer: we went to this place during the off season which may have played a part in our overall poor experience. To begin with, it was obvious that our server had not been a server for long or otherwise was very bored. She didn’t appear to know how to take an order and didn’t welcome us, etc. I ordered the manicotti but my friend ordered the pizza. The manicotti was ok but the noodles were hard and tasted as if they had been frozen. The garlic knots that came with it were burnt and dry. My friend was not too impressed with the pizza, it was so greasy she had to run a napkin over it just to eat it.
The main reason we went to this place was due to the fact that we had a 10% off coupon from parking in the parking lot across the street. When we went to pay (which our server declined to tell us was at the front rather than the table) we were told that the order was already rung up and we couldn’t include the 10% discount. As a final slap to the face, I was charged 50 cents for the small cup of water I asked for. Save yourself the trouble and find somewhere better to eat at.