Benny’s Cafe

Good food at reasonable prices. Staff are always nice and attentive. Not bad for a casual Sunday breakfast or brunch with the family.

Decided to try some place I’ve never been to and thought I would take a shot at here. Reminds me of a Greek Resturant. I sat at the bar and ordered the Benny’s Breakfast. 3 eggs, choice of potatoes. choice of meat and toast. Good came quick and was good. I liked being able to watch the local news on the tv in the bar area. I will definitely come back.

Delicious cheesy, meat lovers omelet. Attentive waitstaff, trying to refill my coffee every so often. Nice!!!

I ended up here after my first choice fell through because they didn’t have a cook on the premises. I was seated right away and given a menu.
The interior was your typical greek diner with lots of wood and fake scenes painted on the walls. Chairs with wheels in front of the tables, booths along the walls.
The menu was not one of the huge ones and had all the standard breakfast items. I opted for the Benny’s special which was eggs, protein, hash browns and toast with Coffey. I never order Coffey from diner style places because it’s never great. Coffey came with my meal and it was nothing to talk about. The food came quick and hot.
My 3 eggs were perfect sunny side up. The hash browns plentiful. The toast was the generic three. The sausage links were tasty and a little above average. I will post pictures.
Over all the service was good and the breakfast was your average diner/​café fare. It’s your solid you know what to expect style breakfast place.

I was very disappointed in the overall sanitation of this place. The floors were grungy & sticky. The cup my water came in was a thick, old looking plastic that was cloudy, scratched & chipped from too much wear.
I feel the prices are too high for the low quality food that is served. I had a steak & eggs combo that came with friut & hashbrowns. Everything on my plate was drenched in old tasting grease & the fruit looked shrived & still had rine & stems attached!
I will not be back to this place. Thumbs down for me.

Caramel apple French toast was amazing! I’ve never had gyro meat in an omelette before, but it was great.

This is the best Albanian restaurant in the Milwaukee metropolitan area, and the second best Albanian restaurant I’ve ever eaten at. Full disclosure: I’ve eaten at two Albanian restaurants, La Mama’s Pizza in Chicago (the pizza isn’t very special but the byrek is delicious), is better, but the difference isn’t great enough to be worth the drive. The rest of the food here is typical American diner food (the waitress called me «honey»), the only reason to come here is to try one of the Albanian dishes, or one of the Albanian versions of what we think of as Greek food (like spinach pie).

Excellent for breakfast. lunch, or dinner. Prices may be slightly higher than some other family restaurants but the quality is considerably higher and dinners include a free glass of wine or beer and dessert. The menu is huge including many breakfast plates served all day, excellent sandwiches, the usual American dinner entrees, stir fry, Italian meals, and even a few ethnic Albanian dishes. The Friday fish fry is excellent. We have been to this fine establishment many times without a miss. From home made soup to dessert, everything is delicious. For value and flavor, Benny’s can’t be beat.

Really fast, friendly service, good food, HUGE portions and reasonable prices. This was really a nice discovery for us!

The menu is pretty average but they do have some Albanian cuisine. I took them up on their 11.99 Spinach Pie and Qebab plate and hoped for the best. The world must be my oyster because you get a free tap beer with a meal. sign. sealed. and delivered.
keywords: value, awesome, free beer?, spinach pies are super flaky and tasty.

A family restaurant with many choices for breakfast, lunch and dinner. Picture a paper placemat and coffee mug as a standard to every place setting. Very friendly service. The prices are a bit higher compared to other family restaurants, but the food is great. No complaints! The omelettes are excellent!