Mihm’s Charcoal Grill

Have been going here for years. The staff is super friendly and the food is always good. Only thing I would change would be a bigger place because it’s always packed! Will keep coming back!

Great little spot. Will definitely come back. I had a cheeseburger fry boat and strawberry malt. This place is the real deal! Delicious greasy burgers on a charcoal grill. The staff was super nice and you could tell they had a lot of fun working there.

Such bad service. The food was just okay. My husband had to get up and bring our glasses to the counter to get refilled after nobody came by to check on us and wehad empty glasses for our entire meal. I went to use the bathroom and it was locked, I stood and asked 3 different waitresses if I needed a key for the bathroom and got ignored. There was a young man and woman sitting at the bar and a waitress went to help them and he had to direct her to me.
I gave up on even trying to use the restroom and just wanted to pay and leave. Our bill came to $ 19.90. It’s cash only and you bring your ticket to the counter to pay. I gave the girl $ 25, and asked for change. She turned around and then before putting the $ 5 bill in the till asked me if I needed change for the $ 5…snapping the bill… She’s lucky I left any tip… Let alone $ 5.
Never ever going back to this place. Nothing here is worth the crappy service.

Went here once with my friends. There was so much butter on the burger that I couldn’t even finish it. After attempting to digest the burger I had to take a trip to the bathroom where I puked my guts out in the weird restroom. Not to mention when we left the restaurant my friends brothers car broke down in the sketchy parking lot outside. Ok experience overall

This is without a doubt one of the best burger experiences of my life. Fantastic charcoal flavor at a little dive diner in Menasha. Get the cheeseburger with added butter and raw onions and pickles. It is absolutely packed full of fat and grease the way I like it. This place is always packed for a reason.

It may not be healthy, but it sure tastes great! Service is solid every time. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a burger joint.

Most Delicious burgers i have ever had the pleasure to devour. They literally melt in your mouth.

Service is usually slow, place is small so sometimes it is hard to find a seat. Food is awesome. It makes up for what is lacking.

Tasty buttery charcoal burgers. Good malts. Calories don’t count here, right? Not very big and an authentically retro women’s bathroom (yellow fixtures and very 70s wallpaper) but well-​maintained. I can see why it’s a local favorite.

Restaurant nostalgia of old diners past. Redone and modern. Burgers are good. Pepper Jack Cheese balls, excellent. Wait staff was great. Will be back.

We took my dad there – he is a lover of real charcoal grill experiences, so I thought we’d try Mihm’s, which I’d heard so much about. On a rainy cool evening, the dining area was kept pretty chilly. The generously buttered burgers were served in a paper wrapper with no basket or paper tray. No tomatoes available. My bun was dry and hard on top, as though it were dried out – our waitress said that was the result of the toasting, and that perhaps next time I should request a cold bun. The chocolate malt was a treat that I enjoyed the most. The staff was very attentive and kind. My dad enjoyed the burger and the malt.

Interesting… looks like a regular dinner. Nothing fancy! Smells good! Burgers are yummy but will definitely give you a heart attack!

Loved my cheeseburger at Mihm’s! The grease absorbed so nicely into the bun. I asked them to put the hot sauce on the burger and they were just like, «oh, I can just bring that out to you.»
They just serve you the burger on the paper that they wrap it up in. They are serious business about making delicious, greasy burgers. That means no time to waste on dishes!
Definitely did not regret adding extra butter to my burger.
The menu is simple and straightforward. They serve FOOD. Enough said.
I liked the huge wraparound bar enclosing the grill and service area.

I have been told many times to try mihms burgers… The spot to go for charcoal grilled burgers! I was not disappointed, however the amount of butter on my burger did upset my stomach, so next time I go back I’ll just ask for lite on the butter! Everything was done quickly and perfectly! Just remember cash only!!!

For my 100^th Unilocal review, I have celebrated it with a trip to a restaurant of my dad’s childhood… Mihm’s Charcoal Grill in Menasha.
Now, it’s a little pricey, but the amount of food you get makes it worth it!
The cheeseburgers here are no joke. I highly reccomend adding butter to them, once that’s done, you have one of the most death-​feeling burgers you will ever eat. It’s so good, but so unhealthy at the same time. I also tried the pepper jack cheese curds. These have a little bit of a spicy kick to them. If you’re like me and want a spicy kick, get them!
Also, when you’re finished eating, go get you a vanilla or chocolate malt! This is the treat that really hits the spot. I can’t explain it any further.
Go fill yourself up at Mihm’s after a long run or walk. It’s a classic in the Fox Valley!

Excellent as always. Best steak sandwiches around. The butter drips right out of them

Awesome burger and fries for a great price! Service was fast and friendly, I definitely plan on going back.

Stopped in for a quick lunch while in the area and was wonderfully surprised. I must say if you are trying to watch your diet, you may consider otherwise. This was the best burger I have had in a long time. I love finding little hole in the wall places that haven’t change in 50 years and this is just the place. Burgers are grilled to perfection, buns are toasted on the grill, and anything you want to them and get a side of the cheese curds… You’re in WI! Add their famous malts to your order and you have a true American lunch! No need for dinner after! Enjoy!

Having heard from many people that Mihm’s was the place to go for a good burger, I decided to give it a try. While I would not say that the double burger I had was outstanding, as I have had much better burgers at other places, it was good. I would have liked to see more meat on the burger though. The patty was almost paper thin, combine the two patty’s on my double, and you maybe had a quarter pound burger… Maybe. One of my biggest pet peeves with restaurants these days are when you don’t get some kind of side with a burger or sandwich. At almost $ 7.00 for a double burger here, I would think that you would get a side, but you don’t. You also don’t get anything on the burger besides the meat, cheese and pickles, but you can pay extra for lettuce, mayo, and onions. All said and done, you are paying almost $ 11.00 for a burger here with side and condiments… The burger was simply not worth that price.
Want some good bang for you buck, go to JD’s Drive-​in in Appleton. The double burgers here are far better than the double I had at Mihm’s, and they only cost $ 1.75.

Outstanding! This is what a burger should taste like!!! Indoor charcoal grill, couldn’t be any better! Mihms is definitely a treasure that I haven’t seen replicated in any of my travels. The burgers come slathered in butter and standard condiments are pickles and onions. Order the steak burger instead of the hamburger and enjoy! Also, their chili and chicken dumpling soups are old recipes never changed and outstanding! Absolutely delicious!!! Everything else is mediocre including the shakes. 4 stars for the burgers and soups!!! A must revisit often kind of place.