Attilio’s Restaurant & Pizza

We come here regularly about once a month, and we always get a great meal, service and price.

Friendly service. Food was marginal. Had chicken parm. Chicken was over cooked, difficult to cut. Also had zucchini stick which were burned. Friend had sausage hero which was ok
Had pasta on previous visit which was good. Not my favorite probably won’t go there again.

OMG… they nickel and dime you on top of serving SUB PAR FOOD. Really guys, you charge $ 1.75 extra for angel hair pasta? It doesn’t cost any more than spaghetti, linguini or ziti. Give me a break!
Why my mother insists on going to this place is beyond me other than the fact that there’s always a $ 5 coupon to be used. Screw the coupon.
Want pizza, go there. Want good or just decent food, go elsewhere. Really, this place is awful. REALLY AWFUL!!! True Jersey shore gross restaurant.
Mom, you get to go by yourself next time — sorry. Leave me home. I’d rather starve.

Kind people, good service, friendly atmosphere and yummy food! :)
also, a cute waiter ;)

Really good pizza made from real italians. a good local family business, I have been going here for years. my favorite has always been a well done pepperoni pie, with mozzarella sticks! but you can definitely enjoy a cheese steak or maybe even meat stuffed raviol. it is a byob so feel free to bring a bottle of wine or your favorite beer! nice ambiance with a beautiful wall mural, it is always a fun little date spot.

Pizza is very good, well above average trust me. You’re ok here on that front. However, service is unpredictable and presents you with some head-​scratchers. Consider that the entertainment that comes with meal at no cost. They’ll be there all week.

I can’t believe they only have three stars. I think they have the best pizza on the shore. When I belonged to promenade beach club, we used to order from here all the time in the summer. My kids love their pizza too, and they are very particular.

Last night (yes I ordered pizza on VDay) was the 3^rd and last time I’ll order from Attilios.
First time, I only ordered a pizza and picked it up. The pizza was ok, no complaints.
Second time, my husband and I both ordered sandwiches and a side of meatballs. Worst meatballs ever, really. They were obviously frozen. They were the meatballs you’d find in the Dollar Store. Seriously! They were that bad. And not even just bad compared to my Italian mother in laws meatballs. They were bad like my dog wouldn’t even eat them. Bad like my blind Jewish grandmother could have made better meatballs (I don’t really have a blind Jewish Grandmother). Bad like having to eat them could be considered cruel and unusual punishment. «We only use the freshest ingredients»…my @ss.
Third time, I ordered a pizza and a wrap. I placed my order over the phone for delivery, paid with my credit card and was told 45 mins. An hour and a half later, I call back asking about my order. The guy tells me my card wouldn’t go through. Low and behold, he had written down the wrong number. And he said they tried to call me 3 times but it wouldn’t go through. He had the number wrong. So maybe they should have someone who speaks fluent f*cking English take the phone orders so they can actually get it right! And the wrap was dry and the pizza was gross. So I had to wait 2 hours for gross food.
Oh, and no apology. No discount taken off. Being dicks can almost be excused if your food is awesome, but Attilios has nothing going for it. I’m throwing away the menu!

the food here is delicious, but the service is spotty. sometimes good, but more often horrible – hence the 4 stars instead of 5. if you don’t have a lot of time to kill, don’t order off the regular menu. but the yumminess of the place keeps me coming back, regardless. the best red sauce on the east coast.

This was very good pizza, right near the Seven Presidents beach. We liked it and thought the restaurant looked clean and well-​maintained. I recommend the ready slices. We went here because we like the ice cream place next door and didn’t want to travel far from the beach. It was good for a quick and easy meal with the kids.

Their pizza is better than most pizza I’m familiar with. The taste of the pizza gives you the impression that it’s made with fresh ingredients. My only dislike for the pizza would be that it was excessively greasy.
I wasn’t too happy with the décor however; it looks very dated and really needs an update. The table arrangement is awkward, obstructing the space available for walking around them. Service is honestly not the best either and the time it took for our pizzas to finish was notably long.
I would suggest to at least give Attilio’s a try.

The workers here are really as grimy as they look. The cashier here treated my boyfriend and I like idiots when we asked whether the provolone, salami, and ham came with any lettuce and tomatoes (menu is really really unclear). Is that really an absurd question to ask and does that really grant the response? Calm down brah. This ain’t Jersey Shore.
If I could give this place negative stars, I would. Not worth any of my money. Also, not worth any of my time and I feel bad for all of their future customers.

a local favorite from what i gather. In town from chicago, my boyfriends father suggested this place and the food is awesome! i had chicken marsala and its most likley the best i’ve ever had! very tasty. Great job!

I had always been a loyal customer and fan of Attilio’s, however after my most recent visit that has drastically changed. The two things that have turned me off to this restaurant:
1. They charged me an extra $ 1.25 for a whole wheat wrap, which was not posted anywhere. To top it off I did not even recieve a whole wheat wrap.
2. After placing an order for pickup of a sicilian pizza, I arrived at the restaurant to find that they had failed to even make the pizza. Not only were the employees behind the counter completely unapologetic, but they offered no solution other than «we don’t have a sicilian pizza, we have a plain one».
I would stay away from this restaurant until they can get their act in order. There are many other local pizzerias in the area that care for their customers and offer up excellent food.

Good, crunchy crust pizza.