Amazing crumb cake! Good Italian cookies and nice variety of pastries and cakes. The bread looked good but I did not try it.
Albert I.
Place rating: 2 Mantoloking, NJ
Question asked to owner of the Colonial Bakery: Why did I only get 12 bagels with my order for a dozen bagels? Answer: if we gave you 13 that would be a bakers dozen. My reply: This is a bakery right? Her answer we don’t do bakers dozen here. That’s when I noticed that the Colonial Bakery is struggling to find an identity. In one corner they are selling fudge. Another smoothies and juices. The outside of the building looks great post Sandy. But the management need a rebuild as well.