Anderson’s Frozen Custard

Well hello there, COMPLETE SATISFACTION. It was very nice to finally meet you (at Anderson’s).
Did you know September 8^th was 99₵ Cone Day at Anderson’s? Put it on your schedule for next year because it’s a thing. I would normally be willing to trade a new born baby for a scoop of Anderson’s ice cream, but on Septemebr 8^th I got myself a giant scoop of some of the creamiest, most decadent ice cream one can find in Western New York for a fraction of the price.
Unfortunately, Anderson’s won’t allow multiple scoops for that price. For obvious reasons, I wanted a cone with two scoops of ice cream and they refused to comply with my requests. So, I said, «Fine. I’ll take two ice cream cones then.», and I got them both for 99₵ each.
I’m a huge mint chip ice cream kind of guy. Naturally, I also like Oreo cookies and fudge. So when I realized that Anderson’s makes Mint Oreo Fudge ice cream I almost suffered a stroke but caught myself before it was too late (a close one). BEST ICE CREAM EVER. The mere thought of scoring scoops of that ice cream for 99₵ was almost too difficult to imagine.
But fate would see it a different way that day. Instead of getting the two ice cream cones each with Mint Oreo Fudge I had ordered, my server accidentally gave me two cones of mint chip instead. I got about 4 – 5 licks deep before I caught the error and when I let her know what happened, she apologized to me and gave me two more scoops of the Mint Oreo Fudge for free!

Nine bucks and change for two small turtle sundaes, yikes. The custard and toppings would fit in a half cup measuring cup. It was fresh, it was tasty, it hit the spot, but holy cats it’s expensive for the portion size. I won’t be back. :[

Anderson’s is one of my favorite places to go to when I’m in Buffalo. The Buffalo Chicken sandwich is amazing. The Buffalo sauce is perfect and throw in a side of their hot curly fries and you are in for a lunch that will hit the spot. You can’t forget their amazing homemade Vanilla custard. It is some of the best I have had anywhere. Also, you get ½ price cones while it is snowing out (I have one of the shirts).

I’m very picky about Beef on Weck but I do like the version sold at Anderson’s. The beef is tender and not overcooked. It’s not as good as Bar-​Bill or Charlie the Butcher but it is still better than the roast beef served at most establishments, and the fact that it is cooked medium/​medium-​rare sets Anderson’s in at least the top 10 for Beef on Weck.
Curly Q Fries are also pretty good. I think the prices are a little high for a fast-​food atmosphere, but considering the quality of the sandwich, I’ll still stop here frequently.