Fatte’s Pizza of Grover Beach

Three stars to match the rating system of central coast. It’s decent and good for the price point.

This is definitely a place to get to go or order for deliver. The pizza itself is fantastic and so unique. Also my number one choice on a Friday night or really any night of the week! I’ve never been disappointed with this place.

Very good! I don’t like meat especially Italian sausage but I like their Hawaiian deluxe, fatte special, meat medley, and their combination. Love their white sauce on all of them. Very friendly delivery driver too!

With the buy one get one free pizza you can not find a better deal in town. I really enjoy the sticky finger pizza. Delivery is generally very quick and a pizza is gooooood. I recently ordered a chicken and bacon and mushroom pizza with white sauce and it is my new favorite. I I always order our fatties when I have company coming it’s an affordable way to feed a large group

Consistently great pizza. Although not gourmet by any stretch of the imagination, these are the kind of simple, greasy, stick to your bones kind of pies that are a good break from the higher end offerings in SLO county. On top of that, the deals can’t be beat. Always two for one. Try this place out!

First timer and pretty impressed. Nice people, great deals– we had 2 large 1 topping pizzas for $ 15.99 and not only lots of toppings, but they pack in lots of cheese as a starter. Will definitely come back and try out the white sauce.

We have been ordering Fatties Pizza for a very long time. We switch up pizza places from time to time so we don’t get tired of it… However, Today we decided to give them a call and order two pizzas. Unfortunately it will be the last time I call them. I believe good customer service is a must for a business. Today I didn’t get that. I live on the mesa, and have been getting delivery from fatties for years… for whatever reason they don’t deliver to the mesa area anymore. At least to where my house is. They were also very rude, telling my wife they NEVER delivered to my address.
Well Im not going to get into an argument with some pizza kid. He actually told me they would deliver to a specific intersection and I can get my pizza there… but I needed to be there on time because they weren’t going to wait. Really?
This place always delivered to my address and for whatever reason they changed. Kind of sad because We enjoyed their pizza and their deals… and I was a good tipper.
I would have had more respect for them if the guy I spoke with told me there needed to be a slight charge now for my address because of gas… or whatever. But to tell us they NEVER delivered to our address, and then we could go to an intersection and wait. I don’t think so.
Maybe one day I will give them another chance… but for now, Im disappointed and will give other local pizza places my business.

This place has very good, but not excellent pizza. Usually order take out. Great price keeps you coming back. Usually have a buy one get one free deal. If you want good pizza for the best price in town, this is your place.

First time here. Walked in and ordered a meatball sub and garlic bread with cheese. Paid $ 11.86 and was given a wait time of 15 to 20 minutes. It’s Saturday night and they be busy with them pizzas, which seems like an awesome deal when it’s basically BOGO. I’ll have to get in on that some time! Wait time was very accurate.
Both items came out nice and hot. Both items were also the same size so it’s like I ordered two 12″ subs! Meatballs in my sub were huge! Only finished half the sub and less than half the garlic bread with cheese. Wow, I was starving and now I’m so full with a few more servings left: D

Great pizza

We decided to pick a random pizza place to deliver to the hotel we stayed at… and this was a great choice! Good food, quick and friendly delivery and for a good price.

Solid pizza for those lazy days you don’t want to be bothered with cooking. The two for one deals make the price very appealing. To be honest, I had low expectations the prices.
Sure, the toppings aren’t the most generous and the the cheese isn’t overly abundant. However this is still a very decent pizza. I prefer the white sauce (an insider tells me it’s mayonnaise with a bit of buttermilk) but the red is ok too. I like the garlic chicken on white sauce. The meats combos are too salty for my liking.
Bottom line: don’t be afraid to try this place. It’s not bad.

When I think of two for one pizza I think of high volume poor quality pie. Fatties delivers a hot delicious pizza in about an hour. Our family orders two large one topping pizzas and the charge including tip is $ 23.
I would recommend Fatties over Dominos or Little Cesar’s. This review may sound too good to be true. If you are looking for pizza delivered that won’t break the bank then here you go.

Being on vacation, it can be scary trying new places, especially if you’d had bad experiences! I tend to stick to my usual favorite spots, but tonight I decided to give this place a try. I was not disappointed. The staff was friendly, it’s a pretty small place, but I was taking it to go so I didn’t mind. The wait was short, and I only paid $ 20 for two large pizzas. The pizzas were very hot and baked to perfection. It was a real treat, we’ll definitely be back next time!

After a full day of beach activities while on a trip to Pismo Beach, my husband and I were starving so we were looking for a local pizza place close to the beach.
Surprisingly, there were several joints that were closed on a Sunday and so we didn’t have very many options to choose from so Fatte’s Pizza was the one and conveniently just a few blocks away from the beach. Not a dine in restaurant however, they did have a few tables inside where you could sit and enjoy your meal. The first thing we saw as we stepped foot into Fatte’s was their 2 for 1 pizza deal. How could we say no to that? We ordered a small chicken combo with white sauce and the husband got the deluxe hawaiian with jalapenos. Let me tell you that we were so hungry we even ordered a side of buffalo chicken wings. I’ve got to say though upon entering the restaurant I was a bit intimidated because the employees didn’t seem so inviting? I’m sorry i’m just being honest but we placed our orders and our meal was ready in about 15 min or so. They did forget to put the jalapenos on my husband’s pizza but we’re very nice and apologized several times for forgetting.
The pizza was delicious perhaps it could have been because I was so hungry but the crust was amazing. Not too thick and not too thin but so tasty. The chicken combo pizza had fresh tomatoes, garlic, olives, onions and white sauce and was so flavorful!!! The chicken wings I could have done without though just your basic buffalo chicken wings nothing too special in my opinion. If you like your chicken wings fried and crispy with sauce then this is not the place to order it at.
All in all a pretty good first time experience. Everything was made quick, ingredients were fresh, and tasted great! Great local spot.

their pizza was okay not anything to boast about klondikes pizza in santa maria is better but more pricy but worth it for the awesome taste
okay now order their SUBS!!! their subs are AMAZING!!! way better than the pizza… i will recommend the subs for sure!

Tonight is a chilly friday night and I was debating on cooking or going out so my son suggested we get a pizza. I called Fattys and they had an amazing deal buy one pizza get one free.
We ordered the first peperoni and on the second olives, they said it would be 45 to a hour and it came within 30 minutes. The pizzas were hott, smelled so delicious and just the right amout of cheese and toppings for both pizzas. We were vary satisfied with our expiereance from ordering to eating!.. Will definatly be ordering from Fattys again!

I like to get the same pizzas on the 2 for 1 deal one with white sauce, one with red sauce. Service is good. Pizza comes out fast. Which is great cause there isn’t much waiting room.
The crust is good but I would like it better with a brush of oil and sprinkle of seasonings.

Was excited to try… girl on the phone seemed shocked the phone rang!
1 ½ hours later they still didn’t deliver my pizza. I literally live down the street!!! Tried to give a them a try, instead, after 2 phones calls inquiring about my order… it never came. Time will tell if I’m reimbursed on my debit card. Oh, and i ended up driving by their restaurant… no one was in there! No customers! Zilch! Nada!!!
Margaritas pizza on Grand is good tho… they don’t deliver, but at least they get business, so that’s a good sign! Screw you Fattes!

When you call to place an order the phone is always busy, then when it’s answers you are put on hold. When I ordered we opted to pick up.
Lo and behold they had no record of our order! REALLY??? I checked my phone and yes I dialed the right number for the right location and with multiple attempts. So I know I placed my order!!!
Really people it was 1:30 on a Sunday afternoon, not a Friday night or Super Bowl Sunday!
Ok so the boys I sent to get the pizza decided we were so hungry that they just waited for the order.
So they get back with what was suppose to be two large pizzas and it was two mediums!
The pizza was decent, but the kicker in all of this is two hours later they called and wanted to know why we didn’t come pick up our pizza??? You have got to be kidding me??? Said when the guys were there that there was no order with our phone # on it but then they call us and asked for some random person too.
Ok you get my point this was just bad from start to finish with mediocre pizza.