Mystic Ices & Creams

ice cream is delicious, they have many toys around tables, apparently they offer some sort of activity every night and stuff is really nice!!!

The absolute best! The Adult ice cream (laced with alcohol) is amazing as is the regular ice cream. Every night there are activities for anyone who wants to join in– such as Trivia, Name That Tune, etc. It has become our favorite place! No question about it– it IS the BEST place around.

This place is amazing! You can get ice cream with liquor in it… they have a liquor license. Be prepared to be carded if you look 30 or younger. Everything is made on-​site so the ice cream is creamy and FRESH.
It is a large place with many kitchen tables that are mix-​matched with different chairs. There is also a couch. They have a stage for karaōke night. They play different music each night. On Saturday, its oldies music. It is easy to have a conversation because music is kept at a low volume.
You order at the counter and then go sit down with your treat. There is no outdoor seating. There is a water cooler so you can get free cups of water.
The décor is very homey feeling. There are a lot of lava lamps and knick knacks to look at. There is a coffee bar with about 10 stools.
We had ice cream with Kahlua, vodka, and amaretto… and topped with HOT fudge… delicious! The peanut butter ice cream had chunks of peanut butter. The small is $ 6, but the serving is HUGE. Two people can easily split it.
Plenty of parking in the attached parking lot.
I will definitely return on my next visit to the Villages!!!

Brilliant idea & execution ! Adult flavours of deliciously hand made ice creams. They are very protective of the purity of their treats so please don’t ask for multiple flavours in the same cup our cone. They don’t offer it. They are to be savoured on their own.
Place is always packed. Karaōke nights, Name That Tune Night and many other fun evenings. The walls are decorated with fabulous vinyls and covers. Makes you say– Why didn’t I think of that !!!
They have a very special place! Open 6 – 10 Tuesday to Sunday only.

I must say, I read some negative reviews and I completely disagree. The service was outstanding and the ice cream very delicious. Plus I was pleasantly surprised that each night has a theme. I will go back, highly recommended.

Excellent ice cream, but the staff was so cranky!
I came here for the first time tonight, so I wasn’t familiar with their home-​made flavors. They don’t give samples. I saw that they put 3 scoops in each dish, so I asked if it was possible to scoop more than one flavor. Not only was the answer, «No», but it was a curt, rude no like I was stupid for asking.
There was no one waiting behind me, and no explanation was given for the one-​flavor-​only rule. I am surprised I didn’t hear, «No ice cream for you!»
The butter pecan ended up being very good, Unfortunately, I can’t comment on the other flavors.

I went here on a Saturday night with my mom, stepdad, and husband. We had received a recommendation from a friend that we MUST go here to try the adult ice cream.
Cash only, and the alcoholic ice creams are $ 6/​each. However, the portions are quite large and include a little waffle bowl and a pretzel. No samples are given but the ladies working behind the counter helped me narrow down my selection.
We tried Cherry Heaven, Margarita, Long Island Iced Tea, and Mystic Blend. The Long Island Iced Tea was the most subtle. They were all quite good. I will definitely go again the next time we are in town visiting!

Good ice cream but it’s hard to really know what your getting and they don’t have a lot of non-​alcoholic ice creams.

Yes, the ice cream is delicious but I can’t get over how rude the employees are. I tried to visit Mystic once before and the ladies at the counter were not the least bit welcoming. The setup is strange as the menus are behind you. They have «adult» ice cream which they very aggressively stated we would need ID for even though I was in the market. They also only take cash so my friend and I bailed.
I decided to try again. I got the same ladies that made me feel like I was putting them out with my presence. They seemed judgmental when my sister ordered the Frankenstein aka chocolate ice cream for her son.
The apple pie ice cream was delicious but I wasn’t crazy about the coffee fudge. The ice creams don’t have descriptions so I’m not sure what was in the coffee fudge but it is more than coffee and fudge. And the Apple pie had raisins in it!!!
Overall, I paid $ 20 (plus atm fees) for three ice creams to some people that don’t seem to care about being polite to their customers. I won’t go back. A smile goes a long way people. Your product is expensive.