Krazy Karl’s Pizza

Fort Collins, United States

3.7

Open now

20 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards
Free Wi-Fi

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 970-224-2000
Website:
www.krazykarlspizza.com
Address:
1124 W Elizabeth St, Fort Collins, CO, 80521
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
590 ftShields & Elizabeth
780 ftPlum & Bluebell
910 ftElizabeth & City Park
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Takes Reservations
No
Delivery
Yes
Take-out
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Good For
Lunch
Parking
Private Lot
Bike Parking
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Good for Kids
Yes
Good for Groups
Yes
Attire
Casual
Ambience
Casual
Noise Level
Average
Good For Dancing
No
Alcohol
Beer & Wine Only
Happy Hour
Yes
Best Nights
Mon, Tue, Sat
Coat Check
No
Smoking
No
Outdoor Seating
No
Wi-Fi
Free
Has TV
Yes
Waiter Service
Yes
Caters
Yes

Today

Today 10:30 am – 3:00 am
Open now
Local time (Fort Collins) 01:27 Sunday, 1 June 2025

Business hours

Monday 10:30 am – 3:00 am
Tuesday 10:30 am – 3:00 am
Wednesday 10:30 am – 3:00 am
Thursday 10:30 am – 3:00 am
Friday 10:30 am – 3:00 am
Saturday 10:30 am – 3:00 am
Sunday 10:30 am – 3:00 am

Related places

Explore similar places:
230
ft
Panhandler’s Pizza
1220 W Elizabeth St
950
ft
Cosmo’s Pizza
1401 W Elizabeth
1
mi
Paninos Restaurant
310 W Prospect Rd
1
mi
Uncle Vito’s Too
1015 S Taft Hill Rd
1
mi
Little Caesars
1720 W Mulberry St
1
mi
Papa Murphys Take N’ Bake
1031 S Taft Hill Rd

Nearby

Browse nearby places:
10
ft
Hot Wok Cafe
1122 W Elizabeth St
150
ft
Road 34 Deli & Tavern
1213 W Elizabeth St
180
ft
Road 34
1205 W Elizabeth St
180
ft
Road 34 Bike Shop
1205 W Elizabeth St
210
ft
Jim’s Wings
1205 W Elizabeth St
220
ft
Aussie Tans at Sunset Beach
1121 W Elizabeth St

20 reviews of Krazy Karl’s Pizza

No registration required
Place rating: 4
Chicago, IL
Ordered «The Works» pizza — Super tasty
Place rating: 4
Maryland Heights, MO
Deals on beers. Good jalapeño poppers. Pizza is good. Wings are good, get email Xtra hot and crispy.
Place rating: 5
Hauula, HI
This pizza is tasty and affordable. I love the new creations they have each week but my go to pizza here has been their buffalo chicken. This comes with either ranch or blue cheese as the base and then it is topped with fresh jalapeños, cheese, and buffalo chicken. The flavor a are great and so good. They even put cream cheese which is a good addition.
They also have great cinnamon sticks and garlic bread. They have lots of good local beverages and lots of of variety. They have amazing specials during the week and they deliver. They get super busy in the evenings so order early and get lots of pizza!
Place rating: 3
Fort Collins, CO
These pizzas are great. They’re always delicious. (although I’ve never tried this cream cheese thing the other reviews are talking about) My absolute favorite is the chicken bacon ranch, which is only $ 12 for a large. They charge about $ 3 for delivery, but they will deliver across town (they deliver to me at harmony and timberline). The delivery times are always 1 – 2 hours for my house, which sucks. Their service is pretty hit or miss, and the atmosphere in-​house is 100% geared towards the college students. They have beer and even karaōke sometimes. It’s pretty lively on the weekends.
Place rating: 1
Fort Collins, CO
This place sucks.
No craps given about their customer’s money and time. 2 & ½ hours & hung up on 4 times after being on «hold». ALL for cold food.
Should have fallen asleep to give them the same respect they showed to us.
Place rating: 1
Santa Barbara, CA
Delivery estimation is bull crap. I would swear but I think it would block it out.
So hungry. So angry. I just want my pizza man.
2 ½ hours later… Everything is cold. So that’s f*cking cool BRO
Place rating: 1
Fort Collins, CO
Great pizza and food but don’t ever order delivery. It took us 2 hours to get out food last time we ordered. Next time we’ll just go in and get our pizza.
Place rating: 5
Kearney, NE
beat the clock is a great deal
Place rating: 5
Fort Collins, CO
Business has really turned around after their expansion! No more cold pizza! They have a bigger space now as well. They always have a discounted pizza of the week on facebook.
Place rating: 4
Phoenix, AZ
My daughter who attends CSU took me here and it was great pizza and a fun college town environment. It is definitely known as one of the best pizza places in Fort Collins!
Place rating: 4
Winston-Salem, NC
I have eaten here a couple of times and been happy with the food. The service for take out wasn’t the best, which is why I give 4 instead of 5 stars. My order was supposed to take 15 – 20 minutes and I waited for 45 minutes for my food. However, it was hot and delicious. I will give take out another try, but in restaurant service was better by far.
Place rating: 3
Englewood, CO
Wanted to give 4 stars, but the service was awful, waited about 30 minutes after we finished eating for the bill, finally had to flag down the waitress. Other than that the food was great, we had the Krazy Hawaiian and North of the boarder. Cream cheese is a must! Next time I’ll order to go.
Place rating: 1
Fort Collins, CO
I was excited to try krazy Karl’s after the glowing reviews, but wow what a disappointment! We ordered delivery and the estimated delivery time was 60 minutes, which was livable. It ended up taking 2 hours to get here, and the delivery man actually asked my son for a tip, we told him no. The pizza was cold and the steam had condensed under it making the crust a slimy, pile of goo. The chicken fingers we ordered for my daughter were burnt. Needless to say we ended up eating pb&j for dinner. Nearly $ 40, poor customer service and a two hour wait, for burnt and slimy food, don’t waste your money, we certainly won’t ever again!
Place rating: 4
Los Angeles, CA
Not your average pizza… in a good way!
My friends ordered the pizza late at night and picked it up. It was delicious. I don’t even know what kind of pizza I ate because my friends ordered it. I think one had feta cheese on it and the other had some kind of meat (I know, super descriptive). It was delicious, that’s all I know… and that wasn’t just the 3am munchies talking.
Next time I’m around Fort Collins I’m sure I’ll stop by here again.
UPDATE: My friend told me one of the pizza’s was the Sweet Chili Chicken Pizza.
Place rating: 5
Colorado Springs, CO
As pizza places go, the atmosphere is typical college town décor. nothing special, but I wasn’t looking for ambiance on this fine friday afternoon. I was looking for good grub, and we were not disappointed. My wife went with pizza, my son and I both had grinders (me — the pub grinder, him– buffalo chicken). To say the food was awesome would be an understatement.
The service was also excellent. waitress was patient with our spazzy, couldn’t quite decide moments, but cleverly distracted us with some nice beer on tap. Once orders were in, we were good to go. We ordered some garlic knots, which were excellent, but one of the wait staff (maybe a manager??) said that they were not happy with the size, so they put in a 2nd order for us. (BTW, the were completely fine and we wouldn’t have noticed the difference). How is that for service?
Will be one of our go to places when we visit CSU and FC, which looks like it will be regularly for the next 6 years!
Place rating: 5
Arvada, CO
Dang this place is so good! The pizza I got called North of the Boarder was worth crossing the boarder for (whatever that means). It was so good eating it hot and even better cold after a night on the town. I am personally a huge fan of cream cheese on pizza (if you aren’t I feel bad for you). They have a lot of specials so just check the website or any of those campus coupon books before you go. The wait is generally a little bit longer since they are so busy but they have good beer deals if you eat there.
Place rating: 5
Charleston, SC
On vacation here in Fort Collins from Charleston, SC for the Cannibus Cup, my friends and I had a long day of hiking up Horsetooth Mountain so we decided Krazy Karl’s would be our best bet for satisfying our every craving. We were stoked to learn they offer a Triple Tuesdays deal, three 1-​topping pizzas for like $ 13, so of course we got on that and added twenty wings as well as a cherry pie desert. Everything is absolutely amazing! The wings are juicy and hot, larger than most wings in the area. The pizza was perfection and the cherry pie was an orgasm in my mouth. I would definitely recommend this pizza spot to everyone. You won’t be disappointed!
Place rating: 4
Fort Collins, CO
Easily the best pizza for the price in Fort Collins
Delicious quick and always courteous.
When they were late (by a margin that was not noticeable personally) they had included a voucher for a free pizza! of my choice! none of this medium one topping non-​sense the next pizza I ordered was a free large specialty pizza!
Arrived 15 minutes sooner than I was quoted.
Definite repeat and my go to place from now on!
(At one point I was purchasing these pizzas from them at least every friday) (Don’t you judge me! there’s a reason you’re reading this!)
Definite recommendation
Place rating: 5
Cheyenne, WY
After seeing all the great Unilocal reviews, my husband and I tried Krazy Karl’s pizza for the first time today. The pizza was incredible! The best I’ve ever had. My husband and I ordered the White and the Spinach pizza. Both were excellent! Great crust, flavorful and great toppings. We also ordered a side order of garlic nots with homemade ranch. Yummy! We will definitely return to Krazy Karl’s. A++++++
Place rating: 5
Fort Collins, CO
I really love the pizza here! It’s one of the best ones I had in Fort Collins. Here are some things that I like about this place:
GREAT FOOD! Everything you want in a pizza and more. The crust is my favorite because it’s soft, seasoned well, and the perfect proportion. I love the toppings too. My favorite combo is their ricotta, meatballs, and red onions.
GREAT DEALS! If you check out their Facebook, they have weekly specials for an $ 8 large pizza. These usually contains 3+ toppings, and they always taste awesome. Sometimes they have other specials too.
I like the atmosphere as well. It’s a great place to just hang. They are relatively quick with making the pizzas too (20 – 25 minutes). It’s perfect if you can call ahead.
This is my new go-​to pizza joint! :) 5 stars!