Stanley’s Bakery

East Islip, United States

4.3

Closed now

20 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 631-581-1230
Website:
www.stanleysbakery.com
Address:
68 E Main St, East Islip, NY, 11730
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
1.1 miGreat River
1.1 miIslip
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Delivery
No
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Parking
Private Lot
Bike Parking
Yes

Today

Today 6:30 am – 6:00 pm
Closed now
Local time (East Islip) 04:50 Monday, 23 June 2025

Business hours

Monday 6:30 am – 6:00 pm
Tuesday 6:00 am – 7:30 pm
Wednesday 6:00 am – 7:30 pm
Thursday 6:00 am – 7:30 pm
Friday 6:00 am – 7:30 pm
Saturday 6:00 am – 7:30 pm
Sunday 6:00 am – 5:00 pm

Related places

You might also like:
640
ft
The Sweet Spot Bake Shoppe
1.1
mi
Bagels and More
167 Islip Ave
1.3
mi
Manhattan Sweets Boutique Bakery
547 Main St
1.5
mi
Bagel Brothers Cafe
201 Monell Ave
1.7
mi
Cookies United
141 Freeman Ave
2.5
mi
Terrace Bagelry & Bake Shoppe
876 Connetquot Avenue Ste 17

Nearby

Near this location:
1
ft
Vitamins Supreme
66 E Main St
1
ft
East Islip Stationary, Inc.
64 E. Main Street
1
ft
Long Island Tequila Fest @ Verde Kitchen & Cocktails
70 E Main St
100
ft
All Friends Veterinary Hospital
84 E Main St
180
ft
East Islip Medical Assoc
45 E Main St
180
ft
Dr. Vikas Desai
45 E Main St

20 reviews of Stanley’s Bakery

No registration required
Place rating: 4
Bayport, NY
Best bakery that I’ve been able to find within 20 miles… The gals working behind the counter are young and pleasant. They have awesome fresh donuts and danishes. I’ve never ordered a cake from there, so I can’t comment on that. Check out their egg sandwiches also, they’re really good and the coffee is yum! Worth a try for sure.
Place rating: 1
Bay Shore, NY
I am a regular customer of the bakery and have always gotten quick, courteous service from the young ladies up front. Unfortunately last week I went to pick up a birthday cake for my daughter and had to deal with an older blonde hair woman who seemed to have an attitude our entire conversation. That wouldn’t have been a problem, everyone has bad days. But she managed to give me the wrong cake as well. I asked for the strawberry and whipped cream cake and when we cut the cake at home it turned out to be cannoli cream, such a disappointment. I understand that all the cakes in that section look alike, but through the years I’ve never had any issues with the wrong order but this woman’s rudeness, bad customer service, and mistake about the cake just ruined the usual great service I have received at Stanley’s!
Place rating: 5
Holbrook, NY
The best tea biscuit I have ever had in my life, make sure you get there early because the ones with the icing sell out quick. They also have delicious cookies and donuts.
Place rating: 5
East Islip, NY
Always shop here for bakery goods, fresh bread and rolls, pastries and they make egg sandwiches too, they have amazing cakes and deserts.
Place rating: 5
Bay Shore, NY
My new favorite bakery!!! My earliest childhood memory was going to the bakery with my mother and siblings and being tempted by the rows and rows of delectable italian butter cookies. After living in three different states I can honestly say that I missed those tastes of home more than anything else.
I have been back numerous times for their cookie platters (always a HUGE hit for family functions and office treats), small pastries (the mini napoleon is clutch) and cupcakes (very tasty). I have yet to try their full cakes only because I haven’t had a special occasion to buy one yet! If you are looking for a good, family bakery with an excellent selection for every budget and taste, come here.
Place rating: 5
Blue Point, NY
Five star doughnuts no doubt… I have to get there to try the other items. Coffee breaks are better when the jobsite is close to Stanley’s.
Place rating: 5
Long Island, NY
Wow. I’ve gotten egg sandwiches here a few times over the past year now (Including this morning) and they are beyond amazing. Like… they are noticeably well beyond the quality of any other place remotely in the area. I’m mildly upset now that I have no choice but to drive 5 miles, and not go to at least a dozen other deli’s/bagel stores that are closer to me. What really does it is the quality of their rolls or Italian bread (I got the Boomer today which is on Italian bread…3 eggs, 3 meats, american cheese) They are just unbelievably fresh. This was always kind of an afterthought anywhere I got a breakfast sandwich, but it really can make it. Cheese is gooey on arrival. I really can’t imagine a better, classic egg sandwich. The coffee is also excellent. Do yourself a favor, go here… tomorrow morning.
Place rating: 5
Oakdale, NY
Stanley’s Bakery has *the* best rye bread on Long Island.
Place rating: 4
Stony Brook, NY
My awesome clinical instructor brought me and other students jelly donuts this morning and they were glorious! Not too sweet, perfect amount of jelly, and yummy bread. The only jelly doughnuts I had were from Dunkin Donuts and I was never a fan. From my first bite of Stanleys jelly donut, I realized that what the DD chain is doing with jelly donuts should be a SIN. Stanley Bakery has truly converted me. I will be going there myself to buy a box for myself! Delicious!
Place rating: 5
West Islip, NY
Just got a ¼ sheet Napoleon cake for my sister-​in-​laws birthday. It was amazing! The cream inside was perfect! Some bakeries use too much whipped cream and not enough custard. This was a perfect mix and the cream was sweet and fluffy. It taste so good! You need to try it!
Place rating: 5
Brookhaven, NY
Hands down the best donuts I’ve ever had. I buy them for co-​workers every week and they never get enough of them. Jelly and Boston Cream are the top picks.
Place rating: 5
Islip Terrace, NY
Best damn rainbow cookie I’ve ever had. My boyfriend ordered the egg sandwich special, really good! I’ll be going back!
Place rating: 4
Port Jefferson Station, NY
Really good jelly doughnuts (I have to buy pastries and doughnuts for work all the time, and they are all always a hit)
They have a chocolate cake, that is the best around.
The service… could be a little better, but nothing to complain about specifically.
Place rating: 1
Islip Terrace, NY
They’ve gone from bad to worse. Not only has their quality gotten worse over the last few years but so has their customer service. The girls in the front have an attitude and they don’t care if you’re not happy. The final straw is getting a birthday cake with the wrong name on it. They just suck…
Place rating: 5
Sugar Land, TX
I grew up on Stanley’s and love going when I’m back home. They’re donuts, crumb cake, and italian cookies are the stuff dreams are made of all at great prices. As Long Island becomes more Hamptons and less fishing villages and small marinas it’s nice to know that Stanley’s will be there for a great taste of home.
Place rating: 4
Ocean Beach, NY
Love Stanley’s – great Danishes, crumb cakes, and egg sandwiches!
Place rating: 4
Copper River, AK
Was looking for a great place to get some linzer tarts for my dad. Heard about this place from a friend and saw their website. We ordered a 12 inch cake with vanilla on the bottom, chocolate on the top and whipped cream and fresh strawberries in the middle for the filling along with whipped cream topping and fresh strawberries around the cake. It feeds around 25 people and costs $ 50.00 — A wee bit high for the cake we ordered — not even a half sheet size but the cake was really good and looked special. Also bought 5 Linzer Tarts which are double the size than other Linzer Tarts and 5 Black and White cookies which are really good. Great staff, great cookies and cake. Wished I lived closer I would come here more often.
Place rating: 5
St James, NY
Stanley’s is an incredible bakery located in east Islip. It’s right on Montauk highway just east of Carlton Avenue. They have incredible selection of baked goods. A lot of Italian and French pastries.
They showcase Irish soda bread for the holiday. They have plenty of different types of fresh breads and rolls. You can get a cup of coffee or tea. In particular we like the chocolate raspberry cake. It’s a chocolate cake with raspberry filling enrobed in a hard chocolate shell. Apple turnovers are superb. You can’t lose here definitely check it out.
Place rating: 5
Garden City, NY
Just simply awesome.
FAST SERVICE, nice staff & quality baked goods.
Everyone tries to be like stanleys and horribly fails. There is a reason stanleys has been around forever. An even bigger reason that you see so many «bagel stores» last only a few years at most…
Place rating: 3
Queens, NY
I always look forward to Fridays at the office… not only because it’s the end of the work week, but because Friday means my Building Manager will bring in goodies from Stanley’s Bakery!
I’ve liked everything that I’ve tried from here. My favorite is probably the Pecan Danish. It’s ginormous (almost a foot in diameter!); enough for 8 people to share… although if I wasn’t forced to share, I can see myself devouring the whole thing. It’s always fresh & flaky, sweet & cinnamony, and loaded with candied pecans & raisins. SO GOOD with a cup of coffee.
Since I’ve never been to the actual bakery, I can’t comment on customer service, cleanliness, etc., but I know that he’s been going to that bakery for YEARS, so that has to say something.