Andy’s Diner & Pub

I’m surprised this place doesn’t have better ratings. I’ve eaten here twice in a month, and both my husband and I found the food good and the prices fair. The service is standard diner service.

love Andys wish they had Military discount. Or frequent flyer coupons with senior discount.
we go at the least once a week. sometimes 3x. just love andys.

Amazing food and great price! The weekend breakfast buffet has a great selection. The omelets are EXCELLENT! Made to order omelet. You can’t beat that. Love this place. Great to visit as an out-​of-​towner. I had no idea this place was here until someone recommended it!

I’ve been here for both breakfast and dinner.
Breakfast: The buffet is a good idea and the price is decent. The food is just so-​so. Even with high volume, the hot foods are luke warm and trying to get toast or a bagel is nearly impossible.
I have tried ordering a la cart and anything that comes off the grill tastes like onions or whatever else is being made at that time.
Dinner: Big portions of mediocre food. They claim everything is made from scratch but it sure looks like institutionalized food to me.
Overall, I would give Andy’s 2 stars but now he is a sponsor of the hate monger, Dom Giordano and even has him broadcast from the diner. I would never give a penny of my money knowing even a portion of it would go to Giordano. Shame on Andy for promoting this half-​wit, bigot.

They’re open 24 hours. However, checking Unilocal yesterday and today it said it was closed. Hope Unilocal gets it corrected.

Not bad at all. Solid good food, good prices, good service. I came in because WPHT from Philly broadcasts there every Thursday, so I wanted to see what Dom Giardano actually looks like. Nothing like I imagined!
I will go back for the food, though. Not bad at all.

My boyfriend raved about their stuffed french toast, so we came here for breakfast on Sunday. Unfortunately, despite the fact that they serve alcohol with breakfast, they did not seem to have mimosas. An unfortunate oversight [that has no bearing on this review].
The atmosphere here was really strange — not your run of the mill 24 hour diner. Some of the food smells wafting from the kitchen or buffet smelled pretty foul, and I never figured out what they were.
My boyfriend got his beloved stuffed french toast, and I went with the farmhouse breakfast. His french toast was good, but definitely too stuffed — almost had a nauseating amount of cream cheese in the middle. My breakfast was pretty good. Pancakes were perfect, french toast was fine, and the bacon was good. Our sausage was questionable — extremely greasy, moreso than usual. For our eggs, we ordered them poached with hollandaise on the side. Instead, they were presented in a soup bowl, suspended in yellow goop. I did try them, despite the appearance, and I’m about 90% sure whoever made the hollandaise forgot that it was supposed to have lemon in it. It tasted like a yellow roux with egg in it. So a portion of our meal was good, but the rest, not so much.

I will be blunt. This is the worst diner I have ever been. We came for a late night appetizer and dessert. I really didn’t expect much and it was worse than my no expectations. The coffee tasted old. The oil used to fry the appetizers tasted old. The mozzarella sticks tasted like the inside of a freezer. I got cherry pie a la mode for dessert. I had hopes but they were immediately dashed because the pie tasted like it had been made weeks ago. The filling was almost brown. Awful. I never send stuff back but I did tell the server and she apologized but said she had to charge for the ice cream. She was nice but really? I could say more terrible things about this place but why bother. Just do yourself a favor and go someplace else. Never. Again.

I went here with a friend and I thought it was great. The chicken cordon bleu wrap was amazing. The only problem I had was that it was filled with flies. So that kind of turned me off.
Food was really good though! And reasonable.

Great diner. The best place in and near Conshy for Sunday breakfast with the wife. We then follow it up with Sunday football in the bar area. Free appetizers, cheap draft beers and their wings are great! And the wife says the salad bar rocks.

About 15 minutes ago, I called the diner to place an order for pick up. The host who answered the phone placed me on a short hold. She picked back up and said that she couldn’t take my order because the waitress was too busy. This is crazy to me. If this host has a pen and paper, our order could easily have been taken. Or, perhaps she could advise that they are busy and our order make take quite some time to make. That way, as the customer, I can decide not to place my order if I do not want to wait. Or perhaps, I would be willing to wait. I was shocked. I’ve never been turned away like that from a place of business.

The food is honestly pretty meh save for the giant desserts. The Tuscan steak panini is pretty solid and I have yet to meet a slice of cake here that I do not like and one slice will very easily feed 2 or even 3, The Thanksgiving turkey cupcakes and mouse chocolate mousse cake are adorable, Plus, it is the only place that is open 24 hrs.

Still a fan! Went back for late night snacking, since it is right off of the turnpike, convenient. Even for late night, it was good. The only thing we didn’t like were their fries. They were the steak fries and a little under cooked. Other than that, our meal and service was good. One con about the diner, it is pricey.

Food comes out super fast
195 egg pancakes and French toast from 9 to 11 am
Nice bar
Great brunch buffet on Saturday and Sunday for only 1095 great place a lot of food great soup

I’m a local to this place. Been there a bunch at others requests. Simple items like French fries are always terrible and smell (like they fry them in bad oil or the fries are bad). The breakfast buffet is affordable but nothing to write home about. Service is always terrible and the place isn’t that clean if you really look around. They need a better diner in the area for sure.

Awesome diner! Came here on a Sunday late morning for brunch. They offered a breakfast buffet complete with an omelet station for just $ 10.95 (all you can eat).
Waitress was friendly and attentive, got our drinks right away. This diner is particularly awesome because it’s also a «pub» aka it serves alcohol, so there were lots of diners around us having drinks with their lunch.
I got the stuffed French toast combo which was amazing– French toast stuffed with sweet cream cheese topped with bananas, strawberries and whipped cream. Also came with two eggs any style, bacon and sausage. I cleaned my plate.
My friends got the cheese blintzees and devoured them, as well as the florentine omelette with home fries. They loved it too.
Some reviews really give this place a bad rap, but if you’re expecting a five start lobster dinner when you go to a diner, then don’t act sad when you don’t get that.
Food came out super fast and it was all good. Will absolutely come back again!

Last night, I had a craving for waffles and suggested this diner to my friend after reading the reviews. I ordered waffles, bacon, and scrambled eggs; my food was delicious and I was satisfied. Tracy, our waitress was AWESOME!!! She was on point with everything i needed before even asking her. One thing i dislike is having one napkin the entire meal and she made sure we had extra napkins, condiments, refills on our beverages etc… Great Job Tracy! She also made sure my eggs were scrambled with cheese. I hate when cooks place a thick slice of cheese on my eggs. If you’re in the area and looking a decent breakfast, check out Andy’s.

10 minutes to get seated, while looking at empty tables, 10 minutes to get drink order, 5 minutes to get drinks, waitress forgot drinks, food and drinks finally came out together. Food order was wrong, and missing mayo.
Would never eat here again and tell people to avoid at all costs.

I was taken here by a friend who swears by the breakfast offered. Who am I to turn down a free breakfast. I figured he is the type that visits lots of places so I trusted his judgement that the food would be tasty. I wasn’t disappointed. The breakfast was a buffet with an omelette station. I enjoyed that fruit, waffles, sausage, bacon, creamed chipped beef and a few other offerings were on the menu. I went back for seconds and all this if offered for $ 10.95.
After reading the reviews, this place seems to run hot & cold, but I can only say — I enjoyed the breakfast and the service was adequate. Not sure if I would return for other meal times.

I gotta say, the reviews made me a little nervous, but I decided to try Andy’s anyway. And I was not disappointed! The waiter was attentive and the restaurant clean. We were there for Christmas, so wasn’t extremely crowded.
The salad bar was decent, and the two soups I tried (chicken and shells, and bacon potato) were delicious. I ordered the pasta carbonara, which was a delicious and HUGE portion. I ate some leftovers today and still have enough for a third meal. The sauce was a little bit of an overkill with possibly 3 or 4 cups, but luckily I like that because it keeps the leftovers moist when reheating.
The food did take a while to come, but we were chatting away and catching up, so it wasn’t a big deal. The bathroom had paper towels all over the floor and could have been cleaner.
All in all, I’ll definitely be back. Looking forward to trying the other meals on the menu (and there are a TON).