Papa Romeo’s Pizza

Overpriced, purchased a large $ 30 pizza and it came teeny tiny pizza– then they still forgot toppings. Shame.

If I could put no starts I would.
This place is the absolute WORST pizza place or sad excuse for a pizza place. We ordered our pizza an hour before close and even included our phone number for any complications, and we were waiting until 5:30am. For a fucking pizza. I really recommend NOT giving them your business. They let our transaction go through and took our money but no food. THE. WORST. EVER. next time I’m visiting in Chicago or have friends visiting, I will tell them EXACTLY WHERE NOT TO GO. thanks for your NOT BUSINESS. Sincerely, fuck you.

Stay away! Ordered delivery at 7:36p and was told 30 – 45 minutes. At 9:06p the pizza finally got here. They took $ 4 off but I still won’t be ordering from them again as the pizza was adequate at best.

This location has closed. (which I greatly am disappointed with as the pizza was good and they were very close to home). They did briefly relocate further north to Pulaski and Montrose but attempted to call this past Saturday and there was no answer.

I just came back from there and they tried to charge me $ 60 for two medium pizzas because they thought I was intoxicated they got me messed up. They claim to have delicious pizza but it really sucked

If there was a way to give NEGATIVE stars i swear i would. So Ordered from this place today, it aid the order was going to arrive at 12:05, The time is now 12:35 and no food to be seen, My roomates call the place to see whats up and the people are rude and disrepectful. They say its going to take MORE TIME Seriously forget this place. Outdoor Grill, Giordanos, hell even mcdonalds beats this place. They are scumbags

Honesty amazed this place is still open. The worst customer service and food that is subpar. I ordered Gyro Sandwich and Jalapeño Poppers… I was first amazed how overpriced it was… $ 13 Dollars… The poppers were almost 6 dollars. The sandwich was barely adequte, the fries were terrible and the poppers felt as though they had been warmed in a microwave.
I stopped in the actual restaraunt next time hoping that they could redeem themselves… they this time screwed up my order and were out of sodas that accompany the meals. Maybe if they had mentioned this at the start? But upon waiting for said food. I began realizing how filthy the restaurant was… dirty floors, broken tiles, dirty counter and a kitchen that looked like someone might be living in it.
I try to support small business owners… but I was spoken poorly to, was not apologized to, the food is terrible, the actual restaurant filthy and they can’t even stock the products the sell.
There is no third times a charm! I will never return!

This place is pretty shitty. I only ordered the gyro. Nothing about it was fresh. The fries are clearly frozen and I was given a can of sprite for my drink. No other options. Won’t be back to try the pizza.

CREDIT FRAUD!!! My boyfriend and I had by far the worst experience here. We ordered a pizza, the driver called us twice but we did not hear the phone. My boyfriend walks outside only to see the driver selling the pizza to the people across the street. Either the driver or the neighbor forged my boyfriends signature on the receipt and they got away with the pizza. When trying to explain the situation the driver did not take any responsibility whatsoever and we had to drive to the place to refund the money after being put on hold 6 different times and getting the run around. This pizza is not worth the credit fraud or incompetence if these people. Go somewhere else.

I guess zero isn’t an option?
I signed up for this just to complain about this place.
The chicken sandwich is horrible, it’s the red mystery meat that they dye white worse than any fast food place.
The fries were not even cooked, took over an hour plus for uncooked fries awesome!
Twisty Breadsticks way overcooked & dried out it wasn’t even edible. Dessert was some ⁷⁄₁₁ brand crap tiramisu why is this place still allowed to sell food. This was actually the worst garbage I’ve had in a long time. Order from here and get top quality dumpster food.

Just got done with our extremely disappointing dinner from Papa Romeo’s. I had a taste for a meatball sub and my boyfriend wanted wings. We ordered from here for our first time since it was one of the only places still delivering late on a Tuesday.
The meatball sandwich was very small, but that wasn’t a deal breaker. The deal breaker was when I arrived to the last meatball, it was rock hard. Not even frozen, it was warmed through and completely solid. It sounded like a cowbell as I tapped it against my plate. BARF. I’m still wondering what on Earth I consumed when I ate the other «meatballs» before it.
The fries were not cooked thoroughly, they needed about 5 more minutes in the fryer.
The employees forgot to send the celery and bread which come along with the wings.
The wings were sub-​par and nothing to write home about.
The poppers were just about right, but again could have used a few more minutes of cooking.
100% disappointed with this meal and will never be ordering from Romeo’s again.

Good pizza, but they screwed up my order. I had ordered a pizza with pepperoni, sausage, and jalepenos. They only made it with pepperoni and sausage. As it was after midnight and the order was printed out from the online ordering service I used I am not sure how they made a mistake. To correct it, I could have had them remake the whole pizza, but instead they put jalepenos on the pizza and put it in the oven for a few minutes. It was an acceptable solution but not quite the same as having the toppings completely baked through. Also, the extra time in the pizza made it fairly well done, not that I minded — it did still taste good. They gave me a two liter soda in exchange for screwing up the order but I would have preferred them just getting it right the first time. Still, the pizza tasted good and if I need another late night pie I may order from there again.

We ordered Papa Romeo through GrubHub. Never again!
The gyro was extremely salty and the rest of our order was cold — jalapeño poppers, a thin crust sausage pizza and fries. All cold. Not to mention, the fries were limp and pale.
Oh, I almost forgot the salad — or should I say, the poor excuse for a salad not even worth describing that nobody ate because it was so unappetizing.
Papar Romeo — never again.

Late night pizza is a market of it’s own,. but this over-​priced pie was not up to standard. Large size looks like a medium, toppings are sparse. thus leaving each participant hungry. We could all taste the cheap Parmesan sprinkled on top. 2 stars for showing up on time and delivering the right product, even if that product arrives sloppy and underwhelming.

Late night pizza cook makes the most DELICIOUS pizza. The day cook, not so much. This was 2 months ago, when I ate the pizza one afternoon and one might.

The food is pretty good I got delivery and seemed about as fresh as u can get the most amazing part was the delivery driver… when I opened the door my puppy ran outside without question the delivery driver handed me the food and said excuse me and chased after my dog he caught him and brought him back… thank u very much charlie (the delivery driver)

Okay, this is the 2^nd time of have ordered from them and seems as though their pizza and service has improved big time! This will be my late night pizza joint. Those who live in Logan and Avondale please order from here rather than Saprinos their pizza is nasty

Worst service I’ve ever received from a pizza place. Ordered from
, with an estimated delivery time of 45 – 60 minutes. 90 minutes later my girlfriend called and was told they hadn’t received our order, they placed her on hold and 10 seconds later claimed to have spoken to eat24hours and received our order. Informed her it would be another hour wait.
90 minutes later, no pizza. I called and was told 5 minutes.
25 minutes later, you guessed it, no pizza.
I called again and was told that they had tried to deliver my pizza, but I hadn’t answered my phone. My phone was sitting right in front of me the entire time and had no missed calls or new voice mails. Has their driver never heard of a doorbell? I asked to speak to a manager, the guy on the phone told me the manager wasn’t there, became very rude, and hung up on me.
I called back and asked for the manager again. This time the guy, who I’m 99% sure was the same guy as last time, told me he was the manager, proceeded to be a massive jerk, and told me that it «isn’t my job to give you a refund».
I contacted
, they said they would cancel the order, 4 days later the charge just went from pending to deducted from my account and I don’t see a refund pending.
Definitely not ordering from here again, and will most likely stick to grub-​hub for my online ordering from now on.

Anyone who doubts the service and deliciousness of this place is blasphemous and has no idea what they are talking about. I’ve gotten delivery countless times from here, I mean, a lot of delivery. A LOT OF DELIVERY. To put in perspective, I’ve gotten so much delivery that I could of paid off one of my student loans instead of ordering from this awesome establishment!
(okay, maybe not THAT much, but damn I’ve gotten a lot of delivery from here).
The food is great, the service is great, the delivery is fast, and they have NEVER ruined an order, ever. They also allow credit card tips, unlike places like Congress Pizza (no hating, I love their pizza too).
So if you want to believe some of the comments below me, go ahead, but the last time I checked, I’m a semi-​overweight guy who likes pizza way too much and this place can make a damn good pizza. The wings are solid too!

The good? They deliver late.
The bad? «Chicken wings» are frozen value-​brand chicken nuggets, and are more of a disappointment than your senior prom.
The ugly? Your pizza won’t get cooked all the way through, and you’ll be lucky if you get a refund.
Stay. Away.