Which Wich

I really do like WhichWich subs. They are up there with Firehouse in quality but like Firehouse, no matter how busy or slow it is, it ALWAYS takes an insanely long time to get your order. But I understand quality takes time. The reason for the 2 Stars is because every time I’ve gone, at least one sub order is wrong. Seriously every time. They are always very nice about it and always replace it, but you have to wait AGAIN a long time for the replacement. Even worse when you get it To Go and don’t find out until you get home. Yesterday I ordered 3 subs and told the cashier my previous experience and to please make sure the orders are correct. I got it To Go (my mistake but I didn’t have another option) and even though I asked the girl at the end if she got everything that was written on the bags, I got home to find out my sub had the wrong toppings. Argh! I understand that you pay for quality and WhichWich IS the most expensive chain sub place. I get it, but if you pay THAT much and wait THAT long they should AT LEAST get your order right. For a comparable price, you can get excellent Capriotti’s which is very fast and friendly.

Best sandwich you can get. A bit more expensive then other sub sandwich places but totally worth it

Which Wich is an interesting sandwich option.
I really do enjoy coming here. The food is always good. It’s just when I look at my credit card receipt, I think «D’oh!»
I introduced a friend to the Which yesterday. His 10 ½ inch Sub was $ 9 and mine was $ 10. There was no extras on the Sandwich, like extra meat, etc.
Now, nearby Firehouse, Jersey Mike’s all charge about the same. But depending what you order, you may get more Veggie fillers than meat –which is not a bad thing if you are trying watch your weight.
Some more reasonable priced Sub options nearby are Jimmy Johns, ToGo, Planet Subs, Quiznos, Cousins and of course, Subways.
Now doctors will tell you that eating too much process meats is not good for you. Though we are a nation of fast food eaters and Which Wich changes it up a bit and makes it interesting.
So come for the funky, try to ignore the your bill and sign up for their discount club. At least you’ll get one free every so often.
Or, make a healthier lunch at home. Now there’s a fresh idea. Three and a half Stars, A-​Okay.

To start I do want to point out that I very much like the food at Which Wich, however there are a few issues that I have with them.
First off being that they don’t really adhere to the hours that they say they’re open. The main Which Wich site says this location in open till 9, and here on Unilocal till only 8:30. A little consistency would be great. If either of those times are accurate about when they close, why did I roll up to the store right after 8pm and find them closed? If you’re supposed to be open to a certain time, 9 or 8:30 still needs to be determined, then you should actually stay open for the people who would like to eat your food.
Second issue is indeed the cost. As I said I do really like their sandwiches and will buy them, but only once in awhile when I crave them (so to go to the store and see it closed when it shouldn’t be just adds a little more to that pile). However I would come back and eat here more if (they’re open) the pricing was more reasonable.
Third issue is after you manage to get to the store while they’re open, and pay for your expensive sandwich, you then have to wait for a strangely long time to receive your meal. Every time I’ve come to this location it’s take about 10 minutes to get my sandwich. It’s a sandwich… why does it take that long?
Sometimes if one really likes something they’ll over look certain things and continue to enjoy that but this is ridiculous. Get it together Which Wich.

Used to love this location, little problems here or there that were easily fixed but I think I’m done with them. This last time was AWFUL. They made my bowlwhich wrong four times. At the third, I asked for a refund and the employee said he couldn’t do that. Finally it came out right, got halfway through eating it and found an ant on a pepper, threw it away at that point. 20 minutes later I was throwing up and am now lying in bed miserable. THANKS, I’ll just go to Subway next time.

I love which wich sandwiches but this location blows. They are slow as sin and the dining room is always filthy. It really has soured me from choosing which wich over other food places. Also the trashes are always overflowing, come on!

The cost!!! My god, the cost. $ 14. For a single sandwich. That is nuts. The food was the same quality as subway. Honestly, if you’re going to charge that much, your quality or speed must be a differentiator, and they were not.
Save money and time, and hit the Subway for the same quality sub.

Saw Which wich in the news and since I didn’t plan on using their bathroom decided to give them a try. The place looked clean and the ordering station was easy to follow.
Ordered a pepperoni pizzawich and overall it tastes really good. While the marinara sauce was alright the bread and meat really made the sandwich. It might sound like I’m knocking the sauce but overall it added to the enjoyment of the meal.
I will definitely come back and try something different. Which wich is a huge improvement over a place like subway. It was a bit pricier but it was worth it.

Great place, great service, fresh sandwiches. I got the Cuban sandwich with best chocolate oreo shake.

Which Which’s store is like a grimy 5 year old: dirty and sticky. We’ve been to this location a few times and it has been a mess each time, from the table tops not being clean to food on the floor to even the glass doors being covered in smeared food finger/​hand prints. Oh, and they are ALWAYS out of napkins (i.e. paper towels). What gives?
I can’t speak for other locations, but this one needs to clean up its act.
If not for the dirty store, I would probably give 4 stars.

Don’t understand the hype. We enjoy all of the other sandwich restaurants (even Subway) more then this. Perhaps we didn’t try the right sandwiches but it is hard to justify the cost when the sandwich is just mediocre. Enjoy the bread more at Jimmy John’s and the meat and toppings at Potbelly. We did enjoy the ordering system and service was good.

Simplicity… get in get out with a quality sandwich or salad. I would choose this place over jimmy johns any day and subway by a long shot. Unlike other da which places that try to reinvent the wheel, this place makes sandwiches the way they should be… Awesome!!!

This place is very good for s quick, affordable sandwich. I’m sure there’s better sandwiches out there for more money, but this beats the pants off subway, Quiznos, any of those. Definitely recommend toasting your wich.

Went in for an ice cream cookie sandwich. Had never been to a which wich before so I was unaware of the ordering process. Someone I think was the manager was restocking items near the order bags. He’s barked «have you been here before»? I said no and he quickly gave a rundown about filling out the bag to order. I told him we just wanted an ice cream cookie sandwich and asked where I could get a writing utensil. He literally threw a red sharpie in my direction and went back to stocking items. Great first… and last impression. Never again. The sandwich was so so but the customer service was horrible.

«It has been well said that a hungry man is more interested in four sandwiches than four freedoms.» ― Henry Cabot Lodge Jr.
Oh, Which Wich… What can be said about this sandwich joint? You walk in, grab a bag, check off anything and everything you want, and sign your life away to whatever masterpiece you’ve created. While I’m not bonkers or a crazed enthusiast of this joint like some of my other friends, I’ll admit that they can make a delicious sandwich for a hefty price depending what you get. Buy a cookie, a shake, and grab a punch card.
The ingredients are fresh and everything I’ve ever had tasted decent. Come here when you want to switch things up. For me, I think I’ll stick to another sandwich place with the initials of JJ. ;)

I love this sandwich shop! I just ate there for the first time and it was great! There are so many different choices as to what sandwich to choose and what to put on top, and it’s so much easier to mark it on a paper bag and take it to the counter. Staff is friendly and the atmosphere is good. The only reason I give 4 stars instead of 5 is because my sandwich wasn’t hot enough in the middle; however it was still delicious! I’ll def be coming back!

Looking for a quick dinner I ventured to try a sandwich place. It was recommended to go there in which I’ve been hesitant to go but in surprise it was actually good! For a first timer I immediately ordered the seasonal special: gyro! You pick a paper sandwich bag that coordinates to your sandwich and mark any listed special requests on the bag. Varies from bread type, meats, sauces, veggies, etc. For shakes and cookies you mark a different card. Pay at the cash register to the nice worker. My authentic gyro was around $ 8. I never knew crinkled French fries work well in a gyro! Great comfort food. The paper sandwich bag was hung up at the line with a pin sturdy enough to hold the wich. Write your name on the bag so they can call your name when the order is ready.
The cookie was warmed up on the open toaster and nicely warm for the winter that’s soon to arrive. Oozing chocolate came at each bite. Yum!
They have a loyalty program card. For every 10 sandwiches bought you get one sandwich free! Eat up!

I enjoy coming to Which Wich for a quick lunch experience, even though it’s not consistently that.
I like that you can go in & mark your order on a paper bag, making it somewhat quicker than other sandwich establishments where they ask you whether you want to add this, that, & the other at the last minute. I like the variety of ingredients that can be put on the sandwich to make it full. Now & again they’re not consistent so not everything that I on the bag show up on the sandwich. Even so it’s probably one of the better sandwich places in town.

So, I’ve been to a which wich a few years ago in Chicago and I remember liking the caprese sandwich. I was Christmas shopping at the chandler mall and headed towards the target when my stomach started growling… I passed by the which wich and I was like whoa!!! There’s one here!
So, You order by checking what you want on one if the provided paper bags. I chose the veggie and picked the caprese with Olive salad and garlic dressing. It was sooo good! I was worried it wasn’t going to turn out good, but it really did! I also ordered the house chips which was peppery and I liked that. All in all, great experience. The staff was friendly too and clean store!

I work at PayPal, so I visit this place quite frequently on my lunch break. The menu, however can be a little confusing for a first-​timer. What you have to do is grab the proper sandwich bag and fill it out. For example, number 6 is the vegetarian bag and then you look up at the menu and see what your options are. The vegetarian options are: hummus, mediterranean, caprese, and there’s one other. You then fill out your bag on how you’d like your sandwich made. The first time I went I grabbed a bad that was like their ultimate sandwich or something like that, so when I got it, it was loaded with meat. Not so good for a vegetarian… lol.
The last time I visited here I ordered the hummus sandwich with crispy onion strings, lettuce, jalapeño, banana peppers, salt, pepper, oil, vinegar, pickles, garlic powder, oregano, olives, and bell peppers. It was seriously sooooo good!