Which Wich

These guys are super fast at getting the orders out. There’s no messing around behind the counter: they’re all business, and hand you your sandwich quickly and with a smile.
My standing order at Which Wich is the Thank You Turkey, which is a turkey sandwich with cranberry sauce and stuffing. I got mine with wheat bread, and you can get it either cold or hot, but you need to get it hot! Hot makes all the difference.
Don’t sleep on the house-​made chips — they are the perfect accompaniment to their sandwiches. Get some!

This place is fun. I dig how you order and the customer service was on point. Everything looks nice inside too. It’s bright and cheery. I had an ice cream peanutbutter cookie and it was bomb. The sandwich wasn’t premade so the cookie was soft and there was tons ice cream. I would for sure get one again. I had the gyro sandwich too which was fairly good. The meat was a bit sparse, but I still enjoyed my sandwich. If you get hummas on your sandwich there will be crazy amounts of hummus just warn you. You can create so many crazy sandwiches which makes this place fun.

Which wich is a step up from Subway but as good as Jimmy Johns or Potbelly. I love it as an option when you are feeling like something a little different. Their homemade chips are delicious and I would love to make my way through some of their different sandwiches. I have tried the peanut butter banana and bacon (Elvis) which was yummy and their club sandwiches. The first time I tried this was during a Ragnar run — which made it one of the best sandwiches I had ever eaten at the time.

I love which wich. I’ve been a lifelong Subway and Jimmy Johns person. That is until which wich moved in across the street. I’ve been hooked since the first time I ate there. The subs are excellent, and the the topping choices are really top notch. The only reason I rated it 4 stars instead of 5 is due to the semi long wait. While I do think it’s worth the wait, sometimes it’s just easier to get in and out of subway in 5 minutes if you’re pressed for time. Also, I’d recommend the cookies n cream milkshake.

Ordering from a bag is so simple and so easy. I am shocked no one came up with this concept sooner. I have never had an issue since they just follow what I wrote on my bag. You can get your sandwich hot or cold, on white, or wheat, in a bowl, or with lettuce. I get the medium which is 10.5 inches and really the perfect size.

This place is garbage! $ 11 dollars for the worst Reuben I have ever had in my life! It was maybe ½ inch thick and no thousand island or sauerkraut. Never eating here again.

My favorite sandwich shop. Always a line, this place is popular. But the line moves quickly! One time, I had a longer wait, and they gave me a free drink. Great food and friendly staff = 5 stars in my book!

I overlook this place a lot simply because there are almost too many options. I have a hard time whittling the choices down to something with a distinctive (eg less than everything) taste. But that’s a good problem to have, and so are their shakes…

I have been feeling a real void in my life since Lenny’s closed, but Which Which is totally going to fill that hole! I love the bag ordering system! It’s so easy to check off your own toppings after you of course pick the category of sandwich you want. Today I went with Seafood, but got the best of both with the Surf and Turf! It had roast beef and crab. I know the crab was imitation, but it was really good. I added spinach, black olives, cucumber, hummus, and tomato. There may have been a few more things I checked off, they had so many fun toppings.
My sandwich came out perfect!
We got there at 11, which was the perfect time. The later it got the longer the line got. There also isn’t much parking, but we will for sure be back.

Good location, parking spaces dedicated just for its patrons, delicious fresh food! As if that’s not enough… They also deliver amazing customer service! Human error happens and in the case of my sandwich being made wrong, they not only remade it free of charge but upgraded me a size and delivered to my work. Stellar!

A good sandwich, of course, though they were out of my first choice. But the milkshake was disappointing, the food preparation process sloth-​like, and the prices way to high for the experience they deliver.

This was the first Which Wich I ever visited, and I LOVED it; and still do! The service here is super speedy, even during the lunch hour rush. The employees are friendly, upbeat and helpful with suggestions or explanations on menu items. Milk shakes are awesome — they taste homemade to me — chocolate is my favorite. Come here for an adventure in some very unique sandwiches, such as Thank You Turkey, or for a break from the bland and boring subs from Subway or Jimmy John’s. Compared to Jimmy John’s, Which Wich is a great value for the unique sandwiches and treats that you get.

Once you go to Which Wich you will NEVER go back to Subway. The array of toppings is great and toasted subs are always the best. The bag ordering system is great and I always end up with the exact sandwich I wanted.
Tuesdays and Fridays are always packed for lunch so go early or late otherwise you will be waiting around forever. Tuesday you get two punches on your reward card instead of one — hence it being really busy. I also suggest drawing something on the back of your bag so you know where it is in the line up :).

Best quick sandwich option around
Somehow they’ve managed to stand out against other sandwich options by making a quick, self-​sufficient method where the customer gets to check all of their sandwich toppings on a paper bag, making for a quick and fun process
The milkshakes are also quick– not to mention incredible

If you really want to try the best sandwich? you have to try the Gyro.
Gyro, double meet, toasted, sliced egg, honey mustard, mayo, tomato, cucumbers, 1000 island sauce. That’s my combination: D

We visited Which Wich quite by chance when in town in business.
We cannot recommend this place enough! It is so fun, you choose your type of sandwich and then write your special requests in the bag in which your sandwich will be delivered! So creative! My sandwich actually had their special potato chips on it! Better than any sandwich place I can think of.
LOVE IT!

Which Wich can be a good experience if you have a go-​to sammie to order each time and you order a small, which is a good portion size in itself. We must have come in between the dining rush because service was quick at this location. Also if you get chips always, always go with the house chips. You’re welcome.

Which Wich? Great question. They’re all so amazing. I’m going to do this High Fidelity style. Top 5 All-​time Best Which Wich Decisions.
Number 5. The Reuben. Because sauerkraut lands almost anything on a top 5 list. It’s a natural born x-​factor. Which Wich (heretofore to be referred to as WW) has the ratio formula down perfectly on this, the key to a good Reuben.
Number 4. Egg Salad. A lot of people don’t like mayo. I am not one of them. Put mayo on my mayo-​based sandwich filler please! I add pickles, spinach, and onions to this one. Because it’s my which, the way I want it.
Number 3. The Monte Cristo. Add some Swiss cheese and warm it up for a perfect brunch or lunch entrée. Be forewarned on this one — that powdered sugar gets everywhere! You’ll have a strong desire to bathe after indulging with this one. Standard hand washing may not be sufficient to remove the sticky layer left behind. Your belly won’t care.
Number 2. The Cuban. Again, pile on the Swiss cheese. Don’t forget the yellow mustard. Cuban sandwich connoisseurs, earmuffs please. I add mayo to this one, too. Because, again, it’s my which.
Number 1. The sandwich that first drew me to WW and still remains what I would consider their marquee offering. Ladies and gentlemen, the Elvis Which. It’s…epic. The peanut butter hugs the gooey bananas and has seduced the chunky bits of savory bacon to all cuddle under a heavenly blanket of honey. Get this one warm to delight in its highest goo factor. If you thought you wanted to bathe after the Cristo, you haven’t seen anything yet. Bust out the hose for this one. Worth. Every. Second.
So those are my top 5. There are others with which I’ve had flings, but these are my most consistent relationships. None of those appeal to you? Grab a bag and a marker, get creative. The possibilities are endless at Which Wich.

Which Wich is good, but not wait 20+ minutes good.
Friday lunch is prime time for going out and Which Wich must be THE place to eat in Carmel. The place was absolutely packed.
I like the format of filling everything you want out on a bag and still getting the specialized sandwich you want. There are tons of options: turkey, ham, pulled pork, roast beef, corned beef, and nearly every condiment and topping you can think of.
I would definitely recommend Which Wich, just avoid it around 12:00 on Fridays.

My first visit, and I really liked the food. It was fresh and tasty, with many options. The bag ordering process was different and kind of fun. I ordered two sandwiches to go.
I would rate four stars for the food but only two stars for service. The order-​taker was friendly and helpful, and even offered me a free drink since it was my first visit. Then when I checked my receipt after I got home I found out I was actually charged for the drink.
One of the sandwiches was actually not what I had ordered. I had ordered the Tomato and Avocado but actually received a Caprese, which I didn’t discover until I got home with the food. It was a good sandwich but not the one I had checked on my bag.
Customers were attempting to get ice at the soda fountain, and it wasn’t working. One of them told the sandwich-​making employee that the machine was out of ice, and she said, «Oh, the ice maker isn’t working.»
It would have been nice to post an «out of order» sign on the ice dispenser since so many people were standing there trying to get ice. Or perhaps an employee could have gone across the parking lot to buy a couple bags of ice from Meijer.