Orange Leaf Frozen Yogurt

This is my favorite place for frozen yogurt. They have great flavors like coconut cake and strawberry cheesecake. They’re moderately priced in my opinion. I’m surprised they’re not more packed during lunch. The owners claim that the yogurt Is made in house by hand but I don’t believe it. Imma still eat it though ! Lol

New to the neighborhood and was craving frozen yogurt. Flavors are limited. Fruit toppings have been sitting out for who knows how long. The atmosphere is horrible — the chairs weren’t set up properly (they were still upside down and stacked on the sides of the shop as if they were closed) and it was the middle of the afternoon on a weekend. Staff doesn’t seem to care, and it’s clear management doesn’t care. But the place is clean and yogurt was ok. I recently spotted another yogurt spot about 4 blocks away by the theater so I’m going to try the other spot. Wouldn’t come here unless I had to.

Pricey but tasty. Best divide and get different flavors. The mama gent should instruct the staff to not good off, turn down the music volume and not play the profane songs. I love the music, but this is a family place.

Cute little frozen yogurt place. Service is pretty slow when it’s crowded, and frozen yogurt is not a food that can be served slowly. So, avoid at all costs when it’s packed.
A wide selection of flavors is available, which is pretty nice. I’ve been here a few times and it’s always delicious. All in all, it’s a worthwhile stop if you’re in the mood for something sweet and frozen.

First time here. The flavors were nice. I tasted the pink lemonade, pineapple and hazelnut. I didn’t quite fancy the hazelnut. I decided to mix the pink lemonade and the pineapple. AAAAAMMMMAAAAZZZZIIIINNNGGGGG!!! It lost two stars because it lacked adequate toppings. There was about 3 different fruit (lost one star) and no gummy bears (lost another star).

The service is really really slow. Expect your frozen yogurt to be mostly melted by the time you get to the register to pay. Nothing to write home about.

After disappointing experiences at nearby Frozen Peaks and Red Mango, we gave this new national chain a try and found it to be the best in the area. Customer service is very good and professional, unlike the competition. The texture of the froyo is very good, and I love the fact that the flavors change frequently. My only complaint is that the consistency of the froyo varies. However, the pleasant and friendly staff make this place worth going to. The rewards program is a big plus.

I really enjoy treating myself to a cup of frozen yogurt at Orange Leaf but they aren’t consistent with their flavors. The oatmeal cookie is by far my favorite but you can only find it once in a blue moon.

Swung by here around 9:40 p.m. after a yoga class. While I realize it was 20 minutes til closing time it was indeed NOT 10 p.m. yet but the doors were locked.
I live pretty close by and was excited when they opened but it kind of put a bad taste in my mouth (no pun intended) that they feel they can close the store any time they want and that’s kind of not cool (again no pun intended)
I even went directly to the website and notified them that very evening. It’s been two days and I’ve heard nothing back. Again, kind of not cool.
Undercover Boss should totally consider doing one of their episodes here!

The fro-​yo here is pretty good, but my fav thing about this place is their cute little orange spoons. They have a variety of flavors and they’re usually switching things up and adding in different ones. I would recommend the pineapple, but it might not always be available, since they’re constantly changing up their flavors. The cups to put your fro-​yo in are large (probably to get you to fill it up to the brim) and they charge you by weight.
As for sampling, the employees are not usually standing by the machines, ready to help you out. You need to get their attention, so that one of them can fill up a sample cup for you (they don’t let you self-​serve with samples, only actual purchases). But, when you do get their attention, they’re pretty helpful. So, I wouldn’t recommend standing there for staff to come by and help you; don’t be shy about calling them over yourself. As a customer you shouldn’t have the responsibility of doing that in the first place, but at least they’re pretty polite and ready to assist.
At the register they have a bunch of toppings and syrups, including Nutella. If you sign up for an orange leaf card, then you’ll get $ 1 off every $ 10 you spend, which isn’t a bad deal. Membership is also free. Make sure you move to the line fast after you get your fro-​yo, though, as it tends to melt pretty quickly.

Orange leaf opened few months ago and it’s a nice spot for froyo. Obviously, it couldn’t compare with the famous yogurt chain stores like pinkberry or red mango, but it did provide yogurt in special favors.
I went there when the store just opened and the toppings were not much, majority were just cheap options like Oreo chips, gummy bears, white chocolate chips, etc. It was such a bad experience and the froyo tasted so weird and nasty that I didn’t want to come back anymore.
Later on, orange leaf had promotion and provided customers free froyo when it weighted less than 5 oz. There’s obviously a lot line with a bunch of middle school kids fighting outside and tried to get the free samples. I went on line just to try on free stuff and I realized they eventually added some fresh fruits on topping options and the yogurt was much better.
I went again last week with my friend and he’s addicted to the Oreo froyo and I’m pretty sure this flavor was exclusively in orange leaf, therefore I came back again! They added more yogurt flavors such as lime. I got cherry with halzenut and it was amazing. Couldn’t believe this store improved a lot in such short weeks. You could always try free samples just like red mango.

Downtown Brooklyn definitely needs a fro yo establishment, so this place is a good introduction to the area. However, I’m just not a fan of Orange Leaf; too bad because they’re popping up all around NYC. Their fro yo is overly sweet and tastes very processed compared to their competitors. They are very zealous with the samples, though, and having some interesting flavor, which sound better than they taste.

Eh! They have a nice variation of flavors but each of them had a bad after taste. Perhaps it was my choice of flavors (egg nog, pumpkin pie, brownie, and hazelnut) but I will not be in a rush to try this again unless I see the green tea come back to their menu selection.

I really liked this place, great flavors at a great location in Downtown Brooklyn. With the many options they carry I love that you can customize. However, I walked by tonight at 7pm because I was so in the mood for their egg nog soft serve (without the calories:)) and as I pull the door open… it was locked and an employee who was sitting there said it was closed. RIDICULOUS, especially when their hours clearly say open til 10pm.
So I am sad to score this this low, but, I really wanted my ice cream and technically you were suppose to be open!!!