Nonno’s Pizza

Excellent Grandma pizza, but very small pizza for price. Didn’t realize until I brought it in the house and opened it that the pizza was not as big as the box. But it was really good!

Great buffalo slice and decent garlic knots. Officially in the rotation for my Bay Ridge visits (in case Paneantico isn’t the call.)

Veeeery good Gluten Free pizza!!!
Great crust, nice toppings (I’m vegetarian therefore can only vouch for such toppings).
One pizza can feed 2 people. Custom made. Waiting time around 15−20min.

Delicious pizza, rice balls, etc. Friendly guys. Pizza’s not too greasy like some competitors on 3^rd ave.
Also, this is a comfortable place to sit in to eat.

Good Pizza. Quick delivery.

This is definitely one of the best pizzerias in Brooklyn. Everything I’ve tried here so far has exceeded my expectations.

The best Grandma’s Pizza in Brooklyn! Their Chicken Caesar Pizza is also worth trying.

I came here for a regular slice at first it was really good but I wasn’t that hungry. A month later my crew and I stooped for lunch because we had a job in Bayridge, some of us ordered pasta and some ordered heroes and man every body was happy and satisfied and it became my only stop for a pizzeria in Bay Ridg.
Thank you so much.

Givin them five stars because they’re good dudes, and they have my favorite regular slice in the hood. Only knock I have is they forget the side of sauce about half the time i order from them, so usually just chillin with a rice ball and no sauce… so just politely remind them to throw it in the order.

Excellent Pizza! The ingredients were fresh and yummy!

I went in to have a slice and not only are the guys behind the counter very pleasant and friendly but the pizza was good. I feel like getting a slice or 2 in the shop was better then getting a whole pie delivered. I will be back for sure. I got the regular triangle pizza. Yum.

Best pizza in Bay Ridge. The crust is just the right amount of thickness where it’s chewy and crispy at the same time. The toppings are delicious and the people that work there are quick and friendly. The place itself is clean and a notch above your typical pizzeria when it comes to the décor. Their delivery service is also efficient and we usually get our order in a timely manner.

Placed an order with them and the food came an hour and 35 min later. cold and incomplete… called back spoke to tony and was told he will bring the rest right away… almost 1.5 hrs later NOTHING! Will never ever order food from this place again.

Went for a neighborhood walk for a quick bite and the guy at the counter was nice. Ordered a slice, I had a feeling it was going to be tasty. It smelled amazing, the crust is thin and a perfect amount of cheese.
I will definitely be ordering my Italian fix from them!

I ordered a medium cheese pie, eggplant rollatini, and spinach and ricotta calzone. Unfortunately everything was cold by the time it was cold. Counter staff said the pie hung outside the oven for no more than ten minutes, plus my ten-​minute walk home, probably contributed. Honestly, the pizza and calzone were very average, but pizza toppings were $ 2 per half! The calzone was $ 6 so may be worth the price point. The eggplant rollatini was pretty good. I can see giving this place a chance for more pasta dishes in the future. Pizza is a lot better from Pizza Wagon.

After Gino’s closed for vacation, we needed another place for our Italian fix. Enter Nonno’s! We had the rice ball special (so yum), chicken parm plate, and veal cutlet hero. Everything was great, delivery was on time, and the prices weren’t too bad for the neighborhood. I think we found our new spot!

Great customer service! I had the BBQ chicken pizza and it was absolutely delicious!

I wanted to like this place because it’s very close. They took 45 minutes to deliver a medium pie with 1 minutes away from the store. The guy who pick up the phone has worst attitude I have ever heard. Finally, the delivery guy had high negotiate ability and zero apology for being delayed. ZERO STAR!

First if all, I haven’t actually been inside. But I have had delivery from them three times! Each time has been two gluten-​free pies. My family’s favourite gluten-​free delivery pizzas in Brooklyn ever.
Second, aside from the g-​free pies being yummy, the service is also great. We usually get our order quickly and the pizzas are fresh and yummy. Also, the last time we ordered, we forgot whether we were supposed to order large or personal size and we order large. They called us immediately (because we’d ordered through seamless) to tell us that the gluten-​free pies only come in personal size (though to be honest, the personal size gluten-​free pies are actually more like mediums). Anyway, the personal size gluten free pizzas are half the price of the regular large pizzas. So we were over-​charging ourselves by ordering wrong. We were grateful for them picking up on that and redoing our order so we payed the appropriate price.
So, we’ll be ordering those gluten-​free pizza pies again and again. And I do look forward to checking the actual place out eventually. ;)

Out with the old, in with the new! Nonno’s replaces Buon Gusto with a major upgrade to décor and customer service. Ample/​comfortable seating provides an ambiance for casual dining, whether it be to enjoy a slice or a plate of salad or pasta.
I came in because it’s just around the corner from relatives that live nearby and, as everyone else has already noticed in the past month of when it opened, it had changed ownership.
I ordered two slices, a vegetable and Sicilian and was quite satisfied. Their veggie slices probably sat for awhile, which is understandable, but the Sicilian was quite fresh and piping hot after being reheated in the oven.
I’ll be sure to return and try out the other pizzas and sandwiches soon for which I’ll have an update ready when that happens.