Neptune Pizza

I wanted to love it! Such good reviews and such dire need for better pizza delivery in the neyb. We have Totonno’s (who don’t deliver, natch) and obviously nothing is gonna compare to that — but I really expected more. The crust was thin, but not very tasty and not at all chewy. The cheese and sauce were solid and better than most regular delivery places down here. The GARLIC KNOTS were an ATROCITY though. They were this bizarre texture — like Pillsbury dinner rolls — totally smushy, no crispy or chewiness anywhere, and worst of all, they were covered with JARRED garlic. Not enough oil (though I fear what the oil would have been), not parm or seasoning at all that I could detect, and endless JARRED garlic with its nasty jarred OLD taste. GROSS! c’mon guys!
Service was friendly and fast!

This place has the best pizza I’ve had in my life of 30 years and having tried pizza from places all over the world to include Italy & Greece. It’s seriously amazing pizza, I can’t say that enough. I recently moved into the Brighton area, I don’t know how long I will live here but as long as Neptune Pizza exists I will always come back!

Stopped in recently and tried the pizza. Really just ok nothing spectacular typical of your average new york slice of pizza.

I’ve been coming here since I was a kid when the pizza used to cost 50 cents. It’s still here and there’a a reason for it. Unassuming little place which has been making great oven fired pizzas for low cost since at least the 80’s.

Stopped in on a whim last night for a slice. Average pricing at $ 2.25 each and $ 14.00 for a large pie. The slices are a good size. Two will make a meal.
The crust is perfectly thin, crisp and tender. The cheese and sauce are perfectly portioned.
They also make little mini apple pies for $ 1.25. Don’t skip dessert.
Glad I found this place in the Italian food desert of Brighton Beach.

Ok I read a review on this place and decided to try them. So I ordered a large pizza pie with extra cheese for delivery. They took my order and delivered my pie quickly. Very pleased with my pie it was delicious, should have ordered two my son ate 3 slices and didn’t want to stop. The pie is a nice size, big slices, presentation great I should have taken a pic but we were greedy. Definitely will be ordering from here again.

I read about this place somewhere, maybe in Time Out? I dont remember. But I got a bug up my butt to try it and ventured out in the pouring rain all the way to Coney Island to do so. And it turns out its really in Brighton Beach so I walked for like a half hour before reaching it. And I got a cold from the experience.
BUT WORTH IT! Holy crap. BEST f’ing New York pizza in New York City! Seriously. Not kidding. Very unassuming, you may just pass it by, its a dinky hole in the wall with only 3 tables that looks like every other crappy pizza joint. But its not. Its f’ing fabulous. Turkish-​owned, family-​run. Owner’s own dough recipe that will blow your mind (I asked, «how the hell do you know how to do this?» He smiled, very humbly.). Im franchising this place one day, NOBODY STEAL MY IDEA! But if you CAN steal my idea, do it soon (and bring them to LIC!). The landlord just jacked the rent and they’re barely hanging on. At least support them and buy a few pies.

Humble joint with FABULOUS PIZZA!!! You need to stop by and eat some great pizza here. Enough said…

Delicious pizza, yet the place itself could be better…