Evil Olive Pizza Bar

Very pissed. Order from them 2… sometime 3 times a week. Always something wrong (they forget bacon in my pizza, they forget to bring sodas etc.) Always a loooong wait even they know me, i live close and I tip very well. Once had to wait more than 2 hours for delivery. But today the guy was so arrogant on the phone that I have to write this review. If you guys are busy it doesn’t mean you have to treat your clients like you don’t care, especially good clients! That attitude will make you not busy very soon!

Evil Olive is a great place to grab a slice, shoot some pool and hang out. They have variety of toppings such as roasted peppers, jalapenos, meatballs, roasted chicken, hot/​sweet sausages, bacon, blue cheese, etc… the options are endless !
They have several specially designed pies such as the Brooklyn Besh’t which I personally loved. It comes with sweet and hot fennel sausage, mozzarella, plum tomato sauce, broccoli rabe topped with fresh mozzarella. I ordered a small pie and it came out to around $ 13 bucks.
They also have a variety of oven roasted heros, empanadas, appetizers and salads.
I love the fun atmosphere in the back which has a full bar, several TV’s and a pool table. The front of the restaurant has throwback arcade machines for a fun filled nostalgic time. The owner and staff are cool and the environment is relaxed. I’ve been here several times and will definitely be back !

Don’t bother getting delivery from this place. I’ve waited more than an hour (more than 2 hours at one point) for my food on multiple occasions, and I live 10 minutes away. The food is good, but not amazing. Certainly not worth the wait. Just go to Williamsburg Pizza, where the pizza IS worth it.

Ive only ate twice from here about 5 pies in total. I thought I’d love this place but it’s too much of a gamble. On my first try the marg pie was sweet then on the second try, it was sour. Overall I’d say it’s a good try but not a place to be a regular.

Meh. Lapin and I walked into this pizzeria last night for two slices. The staff behind the counter ignored us for a bit and one was eating pizza while taking our order. Guy, put the slice down or let someone else take our order. The slices were $ 2 a pop and mediocre at best. The menu talks about using local ingredients but to be honest I couldn’t taste anything spectacular.
FYI — he didn’t wash his hands after eating and used the same hand to touch our pizza and money. I am not sure if you can bring outside beverages/​food as one guy behind us was drinking Tropical Fantasy soda from a black bag and no one said anything to him (he was siting right in front of the cashier).

Ridiculus! 2 hrs and a half for delivery! When I placed order they didn’t even notice me that is going to take that long! If that’s that waiting time just update ur delivery info for NO

Love this place! Always great pizza

The pizza was good. The service was horrible. Both workers were sitting in the back at the bar and ignored us.

Was excited to order from here for the first time because the reviews were great and it’s close to my apartment.
Unfortunately, the pizza came two hours after we ordered (they said 45 min to 1hr) and when it finally showed up they forgot to give us a side of ranch.
It was also super room temp (almost cold). The pizza itself is… fine. I’m sure it would have been better if it was hot and not an hour late. Yikes.

Very good NY pizza. Friendly staff — all the guys are super nice. Delivery (with
) can take a long time, so I prefer to go in person.

The pizza is delicious and always fresh. They always have different specialties with creative toppings. Really nice staff. Also it’s a fun atmosphere with a great bar in the back. This place is a gem!

The pizza is so so, no real wow factor. The price is economical but I really wish there was a wow factor, I had a slice with BBQ sauce, chicken and 2 different cheeses. The garlic knots needed a little butter as well.

I went here yesterday with my family and asked for my beef empanada and told the guy no cheese he said well you get less meat. I looked at him and said I am allergic to cheese. This is bull shit to serve me a deflated empanada with hardly no meat. The meat is what makes the empanada. Then I had to ask to clean the table and ask for the sauce that I usually get with my empanadas. Not ordering from here again. Very upset.

When this place first opened up, my husband and I were not impressed, but he recently visited with his brother, and I think it’s under new management because everything has changed, so i decided to give it a second chance. I had the «King Of Hearts” — marinated artichoke, plum tomato sauce, mozzarella, bleu cheese crumble, fresh basil and oh my god, amazing. My husband had «Chicken Barbie” — bbq chicken, bacon, ranch sauce, pizza sauce, mozzarella which he loved and our daughter had a plain slice — you’d be surprised how many people in New York can mess up the original plain slice — these guys are not one of them, absolutely delicious. They do have to work on their customer service a little — they seem to get a little overwhelmed if more than 1 customer comes in at a time, or if you are ordering more than 1 slice at a time, but the guys are nice in there. Overall — we are fans again

My friend told me about this place: its great pizza and cool owner and workers. It lived up to the hype. I was really surprised with their sauce. I loved its sweet, tangy taste along with the eggplant on my pizza, so good. I can’t wait to go back. Three slices of pizza and a small drink for only $ 13. Hellyah. Two sections: Bar or Eatery. Pick your poison.

I can’t speak for the bar in the back (yes, there is a bar in the back!) — I’ve only gotten pizza here. And WOW is it great pizza. Highly recommended if you live/​are in the area. The guys working are super friendly, and it doesn’t take long at all. Must visit in the area!
For the record, we got a large veggie pizza (the one with lettuce on top). It was under $ 20 — so definitely affordable!

I love this pizza truly and the employees seem super nice and FULL BAR = amazing but do not order through Unilocal.
I ordered through Unilocal and apparently my order automatically went through
and it was just A MESS and it took three phone calls and two hours for my medium pepperoni pizza to arrive.
But again, their pizza is delish so I’m still giving them four stars.

You pretty much can’t do pizza badly in Brooklyn. You also have to do something really special to stand out. Evil olive hits the mark. I wish I had a second stomach to eat even more Evil Olive Pizza. This place is like a mullet, business in the front and party in the back. You will find pizza place in front, and bar in back.
Margarita pizza == incredible. We had a pizza special that night, it had artichokes and my heart skipped a beat when I ate it…
Great beer selection! REALLY GREAT STAFF.

I wanted to make sure I give this place its due props!
Saw it on show, Hungry Investors.
It is like two businesses. It is a pizza shop in the front, and they have a back area with a full bar and a pool table.
The Pizza was amaznig. We got a Margherita pie and a plain pie. I had 5 slices on my own, when I normally eat 3. The pizza was that good that I wanted to keep going.
The pizza is not too light and not too thick or doughy, it is almost a perfect medium.
I really like this pizza. I am not from Brooklyn so i cannot compare, but this pizza is legit. It blows NJ pizza out of the water!

This place has slowly been transforming from an empty nightclub in a neighborhood pizzeria for the better part of three years. (I mean, there were some pretty rapid changes, then a period of rest, but really it’s seemed like something of a process to the very casual observer.) And well, I’ve wanted to check it out for some time, but never really could work up the energy.
You see, there’s a wonderful neighborhood pizzeria two blocks away called Williamsburg Pizzeria, which is truly just delightful. Right outside my door is a place called Danny’s Pizzeria, which is pretty dire but does meet the «pizza within 100 yards» test. And Roberta’s delivers to my house. So what’s the point of a place that serves ordinary looking slices and isn’t downstairs?
Nine months, I stopped in to use the bathroom. Six months ago, I bought a Coke. And finally, the other day, I actually had a slice of pizza.
The verdict? It’s fine! Totally normal, New York pizza. The sauce could be more flavorful and there’s no good char underneath but I certainly wouldn’t kick this out of bed. There are also great pizza and beer specials, so you could drag a few friends here on the cheap. A viable option for the area, if hardly the most exciting.