The Top 20 Hotels

Montauk, NY, United States

Show map

26 places in Montauk, ordered by rating:

Sunrise Guest House
3.8
4 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-668-7286
Address:
681 Old Montauk Hwy
Hotels / Bed & Breakfast
Burcliffe by-the-Sea
5.0
2 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-668-2880
Address:
397 Old Montauk Hwy
Hotels /
Harborside Motel
4.5
6 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-668-2511
Address:
371 W Lake Dr
Hotels /
Stone Lion Inn
4.4
5 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-668-7050
Address:
51 Edgemere St
Hotels /
Daunt’s Albatross Motel
4.0
5 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-668-2729
Address:
44 S Elmwood Ave
Hotels /
Montauk Beach House
3.8
13 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-668-2112
Address:
55 S Elmwood Ave
Hotels /
Haven Montauk
4.2
20 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-668-7000
Address:
533 W Lake Dr
Hotels /
Sail Inn
3.3
6 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-668-2800
Address:
548 W Lake Dr
American (Traditional) / Hotels
Montauk Manor
3.0
4 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-668-4400
Address:
236 Edgemere Street
Hotels /
Montauket Hotel
3.5
19 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-668-5992
Address:
Tuthl Rd
Hotels / Bed & Breakfast
Atlantic Terrace Motel
3.4
15 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-668-2050
Address:
21 Oceanview Ter
Hotels /
Gurney’s Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa
3.3
21 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-668-2345
Address:
290 Old Montauk Hwy
Hotels / Venues & Event Spaces / Professional Services
Wavecrest Resort Motel
2.9
15 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-668-2141
Address:
170 Old Montauk Hwy
Hotels /
Oceanside Beach Resort
2.3
19 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-668-9825
Address:
626 Montauk Hwy
Hotels /
Montauk Motel
2.3
6 reviews
Telephone:
+1 631-668-2704
Address:
76 S Edison St
Hotels /
Mayer Ralph Motel
···
Telephone:
+1 631-668-2704
Address:
Edison
Hotels /
Aqualina Inn Montauk
···
Telephone:
+1 631-668-8300
Address:
20 S Elmwood Avenue
Hotels /
Aaron Robert J
···
Telephone:
+1 631-668-2511
Address:
W Lake Dr
Hotels /
Roth Teddy
···
Telephone:
+1 631-668-5943
Address:
W Lake Dr
Hotels /
Ship Wreck Club
···
Telephone:
+1 631-668-5661
Address:
Navy Rd
Hotels /