The Cake Shop by ButterSweet Cakes

I WAS going to be a first time customer, i called them to make a cheesecake for my son’s bday, which, they don’t do. Cheesecake is pretty popular. Something worth adding. just saying :) I Your cupcakes are fantastic. Wish u could make a cheesecake.

Great cake. Tastes so good and the cake was so moist. It was nice finish for my sons birthday! I also loved his smash cake. I would totally order from here again.

Truly spectacular artisanship! Both presentation and food are absolutely AMAZING!
Butter sweet is the only high end commercial cake I’ve ever eaten where the frosting didn’t taste like dyes!

Delicious cupcakes! Loved that you could buy minis or full size. I like to try different flavors so the minis are perfect. Great cake with the right amount of icing. Also they had buy 3 get 1 free when I went on both the minis and the full size. Highly recommend this curls shop! We will be visiting again. Oh and follow them on Instagram (that’s how I found them) for daily specials and pics of what they are offering each day.

I love this place! If you need a cake for a special occasion (esp. a wedding) this is the place to get it! Beautiful cakes that are so delicious.
And I love their cupcakes, especially the strawberry!

Best cupcakes in Oklahoma! The girls are always very sweet and friendly. Me and my daughter drive from the city just to get them! Highly recommend going.

This is the best quality and tasting cupcakes in the metro! They never serve day old cupcakes so you will always get fresh made that day cupcakes. They are also super cute and recently they did them all in pastels for Easter. Their themes flavor weeks will keep you coming in for more.

I can’t say enough good things about this place.
One of the girls in my bunco group brought their large cupcakes for dessert once and I’ve been hooked since. They have so many different flavors and everything tastes like it was made fresh that day.
Last time I was there was Valentine’s day and I dropped by to see what they had. It was close to closing time and they were in low supply (because they’re so good!) but an employee offered to pull some cupcakes from the back to fill my order. Great customer service.
Each week the store has a cupcake flavor theme and has a daily cupcake special to fit that theme. They are so creative with their flavors. Sometimes they also have specials a few hours before closing, like buy 3 get one free, etc. Nothing here tastes artificial like some other stores. Everything is fresh.
The prices are very reasonable and you can order by phone or online. Next time you have a craving for cupcakes, this is your place!

I love this company! I had my friends baby shower here this weekend and it was perfect! I ordered a special cake and it was beautiful. The cake tasted delicious also.
I rented the party room and it was worth every penny! We had someone help us set up and also clean up after. They provided cups, plates, silverware and napkins. Water and lemonade were provided also.
The cupcakes are so good! I am a huge fan of cupcakes and these are some of the best I have ever had. I am so beyond impressed with this shop.

We have been going here since they opened. We love pretty much everything they make. The family favorites include the Turtle Cheescake, Choco-​Latte, the Doozies, Cookies and Cream, and the elusive Cinnamon Roll. Do yourself a favor and stop in to try some of this awesomeness!
Happy hour specials usually start at 7pm (i.e. buy 3 get one free)

I’m a fan. I ordered via email, and a friendly gal called me to collect a credit card number, which also gave me the chance to verify my order. They did a great job making sure they read the email properly and had all the facts right, which I appreciate so much.
One of the main reasons I decided to drive out to Yukon to get cupcakes is the minis that Butter Sweet offers. They are a dollar a piece, and a very suitable alternative to $ 3 large cupcakes from other shops, especially for parties, especially parties for women. I host a lot of showers, and I find that women are a bit reluctant to take a big cupcake and knock it back over polite conversation and without a fork. But give them minis, and everyone will have at least one. Well, I can afford for everyone to have 3 minis for the price of one big guy, but instead I sort of split the difference. It really is a good way to do it.
When I went to pick up the cupcakes, they took great care of me. I had a few questions for them about some decorations I was planning. The girl who was helping me wasn’t sure, so she went in the back and brought back a few other people back with her. The decorator and another woman came out to show me a few different ideas. This was 7 pm on a Friday, and I had made a relatively small order, so the extra mile really impressed me.
The cupcakes are moist with just the right amount of frosting, served in excellent flavors. What’s not to love?

I don’t want to sound mean, but what is everyone else talking about? The cupcakes are horrible! All I tasted was boxed cake mix and just add water icing. The cake was dry, hard on top, and oddly spongy. The icing was really gritty, too. It’s really sad that you have to go to a franchise to get a decent $ 3 cupcake in Oklahoma, as I love supporting local businesses. But I will go to Gigi’s from now on, like I have before, as their cupcakes are awesome, even on a bad day! And I’ve had a few «bad» cupcakes there, but they weren’t this bad.

Once again, you fabulous Unilocalers helped me find a great business. Even though it is a mile or two from my house, I probably would have never tried it otherwise. We co-​hosted a shower for some dear friends and decided to order cupcakes here. Once we selected the flavors, the owner asked what we would like to see on the cupcakes in terms of colors and decorations. I sent her a copy of the invitation, and she coordinated colors for the toppers– what a nice touch! The extended hours allowed us to pick them up late on a Saturday for a Sunday shower.
Every flavor I tried was delicious, moist, and unique. The only thing I will say (and this is a first world problem) but the cupcakes were maybe a little too big for this particular event. At $ 3/​cupcake, I am glad for that, but after grazing on finger foods and cheeses all day, sometimes you just want a bite. We hosted a second shower (I am friends with a of matrimonial/​life-​affirming bunch) and had the mini cupcakes ($ 1 each) and they were the perfect size and price. I highly recommend dropping into the store to pick up one of these tiny morsels when you need something sweet– but beware, it may be a deliciously slippery slope!

After my first visit I was unsure of whether I was going to attempt to order cupcakes for a baby shower I was throwing, from Butter Sweet Cakes. I decided to email a request. I was happily surprised when I got an email back saying how delighted they would be to do cupcakes for my shower. They required a 50% deposit, which they took over the phone. The week of the shower I got an email confirming my order, and I had a last minute request. It was happily granted. It wasn’t even a small request, it was a whole extra dozen! The cupcakes were done right on time and were packaged perfectly. They were a huge hit at the shower and the best part, we had extras and were able to send some home to the «boys» that weren’t at the shower. While we are devoted Sara Sara customers, we went with Butter Sweet Cakes because of their mini cupcakes. We absolutely loved them for this event, and will probably use them for future events.

Let me start out by saying I’ve never stepped foot in the store. I’ve only had delivered cupcakes. That being said, what I’ve had has been excellent. I’m a red velvet guy so that’s my go to flava and it is divine. I really like their mini’s but I usually take some frosting off for a higher cake ratio (don’t want to get the diabetes).
A quick look at their website reveals they also do full size cakes… wedding and events. Check out that beer barrel grooms cake!
I’m really looking forward to going inside one day and getting a fresh Vanilla Thrilla and comparing it to my other fav place, Cuppies & Joe. I hope the people of Yukon will take advantage of this location.