I had the Goodfella and I must say: this is one addictive sandwich. Pesto greets your mouth first, then you experience the saltiness of the fried eggplant, all topped off by the delicious prosciutto inside. Plus they gave me a free coffee because the urn was running low. I’d highly recommend this deli. Stop off for a great meal.
Joe C.
Place rating: 5 Saugerties, NY
Stellar sandwiches! Atmosphere is equally stellar for an Italian deli/eatery. Staff is lively & accommodating.
Christie B.
Place rating: 5 Yonkers, NY
Always yummy, guys who work here are really nice too. I love the sandwiches everything is always very fresh!
Dan B.
Place rating: 5 Yonkers, NY
If you are looking for a deli that makes a great sandwich, this is definitely the place. It’s kinda of in a bad location and the store itself kinda looks a bit run down, but their food is amazing. I wouldn’t let looks hold you back from going to this place. The obviously use fresh ingredients and it shows. I generally judge a deli by their ability to make an Italian combo. I know it’s not complicated, but in my opinion is the bar that sets a good deli from a bad one. Their Italian combo is fantastic, I can say it’s probably the best one I’ve had in years and easily the best one I’ve had in yonkers. They have different specialty sandwiches that a few people have already suggested and so far everyone I’ve had has been great. I’ll probably go there for lunch again today it’s getting me hungry just thinking about it.
Frances C.
Place rating: 5 New Rochelle, NY
Stopped in because of the reviews I read and they were right on point. The ingredients were amazingly fresh and the staff was courteous and friendly. I was helped immediately and my sandwich was made within minutes. Definitely my new go to. Can’t wait to try everything else they have to offer.
Roc S.
Place rating: 5 Manhattan, NY
Everything from here is sooooo good!!! Love! Rare to find places like these. Happy to have an this close to home.
Matt F.
Place rating: 5 Yonkers, NY
A GEM in Yonkers. I can’t recall how many times I’ve wanted to come here, but never made it inside for one reason or another. Recently I forced myself to come inside and finally try this place already. The only regret I have is not ever coming here sooner. I’ve had breakfast rolls and sandwiches here — both have been excellent. I’ve taken some of the refrigerated items(garlic bread, pasta) and everything has been very good. They sell Italian bread, bread, oil, cookies, eggs, cheese and the list goes on. Some names I recognize and I know are great quality. Clean inside with tables if you want to eat inside. The staff has been very friendly and courteous. The prices are very good. For a great sandwich(breakfast or lunch), this is a dependable and reliable place.
David V.
Place rating: 4 Suffern, NY
They make great a great sandwich! Worth the 4 miles for me to get good food good service, and prices. I recommend it to all my friends!
Ivan K.
Place rating: 5 Yonkers, NY
Great food and excellent service. Also had them cater a few parties and the guests were extremely satisified with their food.
Jackie B.
Place rating: 5 Orange, CT
Tried this place based on a Unilocal review(I’m not from the area) and it was EXCELLENT! I had the goodfella with prosciutto, eggplant, mozz and fresh pesto and it out outstanding. My husband’s food was delicious as well. The staff were all so friendly, if I am in the area again I will be going back. Only warning is there is a $ 15 minimum for purchases on a card.
Cam G.
Place rating: 5 Yonkers, NY
When you walk into this deli you feel like you’re getting a taste of little Italy in the Bronx! Their sandwich selections are awesome, although My favorite for the last 10 years has been the Mona Lisa, hot peppers, mozzarella cheese and thinly sliced prosciutto. Definitely recommend stopping in if you are in the area.
Anthony C.
Place rating: 5 Yonkers, NY
The only choice for a sandwich or ready food in Yonkers. The best. Nobody else comes close. Food is delicious and fresh staff is friendly. A must if you’re visiting the area and a regular stop if you live local.
Jay B.
Place rating: 5 Bronx, NY
Old school deli! So fucking awesome. I got a mona lisa panini. Hot peppers fresh bread, fresh mozzarella fresh cut prosciutto! Amazing. First time here but im coming back for sure!
Chris K.
Place rating: 5 New York, NY
Great rib eye steaks cut or ground to order! Fresh made sausage. great sandwiches. Always smells delicious when you walk in.
Chris C.
Place rating: 5 Bronxville, NY
By far one of the best delis around. Everything is home made and extremely fresh. The guys who work there are the best, super friendly. There heros are huge too. If you like hot peppers, theirs are the ones for you!
Cali A.
Place rating: 5 Atlantic Beach, NY
Deli/market, this is where you will get the best sandwiches and paninis on planet earth! Yes, I said PANINI, grilled-pressed sandwiches! Every ingredients the staff prepares are fresh, all day, every day. High quality deli meats, pork and cheeses, grilled chicken, delicious store made pesto and lots more. Choose hot and cold dishes from macaroni salad to breaded eggplant, or pickup some store made frozen meals and pastas! The entire staff are great people and they will help you build a better sandwich through recommendations! You guys at Mr. Kold Kuts rule!
Peter G.
Place rating: 5 Forest Hills, New York, NY
Mr. Kold Kuts made some phenomenal heros(subs, grinders, etc.). The hot Eggplant Parm and Chicken Parm were chock full of fresh mozzarella. And the bread was perfectly toasted. The cold Italian Special and Mona Lisa were gigantic and chock full of fresh ingredients. The bill for the four was $ 34.00. Four hungry adults could only finish 6 halves. I’m looking forward to going back and trying some other sandwiches.