Pizza City

I’m all over the area for work. Pizza City has become my spot for lunch when I’m in that area. I’ve always received great friendly service, and have always really enjoyed my food. LOVE the Ernesto salad… it’s the best. I also really like their eggplant rollatini. I’ve had both the regular and brick oven pizza which were both very good. I see an honest effort to serve good quality food, prices are reasonable as well.

Ordered eggplant parmigiana meal with side salad. Salad was rotten. Eggplant tastes like fried pieces of bread. I complained to the business. They offered to give my money back but i had to give back the food which i didnt know until it was too late. I later got a call from a manager yelling at me and acusing me of stealing from them. i told him i took pictures and gave back the untouched rotten salad. he was really out of line. he then called to apologize to me because he hadnt gotten the whole story from his workers. i was sick that day n didnt want to cook. it was awful. i only give two stars because the girl and delivery driver i spoke to were nice and because i got an apology.

just moved back to the area, this pizza place is on all the advertisements. I mostly ordered because they deliver. first time ordered half plain and half pepperoni, got a pepperoni pie. next time ordered a plain. the crust sucks, the sauce sucks, the cheese sucks. I’ll go somewhere else and pick up.

Growing up in Woodland Park (West Paterson), this is easily my favorite pizza place in town. If you’re looking for the cheesy New York City style pizza, this is it!

Sorry Mr G but three strikes and you’re out. Tried your food 5 different times… something
always wrong… this time Sausage & Mozzarella roll – had 5 pieces of meat sliced so
thin it had no flavor… pizza very large but heavily seasoned with garlic powder…
such a shame it looked so appetizing…¾ s of the pie was tossed… with so many
pizza places in town… this cannot compete.

Crispy crust and great flavor! We were trying to figure out what to get for lunch last week, and I had a sudden craving for pizza. So I turned to old faithful ( Unilocal!) to find me a pizza place. Pizza City came up in my search so we figured we’d give it a shot. It’s in a little strip mall on McBride. There’s a «small» parking lot. The restaurant itself isn’t too big, but the pizza slices are huge. Given the size of the slices, my husband and I decided to order 3 slices and share one of them. We ordered a plain cheese slice, an Eggplant Parmigiana slice, and a White slice with Broccoli. I took a bite of hubby’s plain slice to taste. I absolutely loved my Eggplant Parm slice. It was just perfect. The right combination of eggplant, ricotta cheese, mozzarella, and tomato sauce. The white slice with broccoli was super tasty too. I loved how crispy the dough and crust were. That’s my kind of pizza. The only negative for me was that the top of the crust seemed a bit bland, almost like it tasted of raw flour. That’s why it only got 4 stars instead of 5. But I really enjoyed the food none-​the-​less and we will be back for more.

I go there on a pretty regular basis. I’m neither here nor there, as far as quality goes. Good pizza, decent Italian grub. Nothing that makes my eyes roll back as much as a good BEEJ. #ArcherReference
Staff is very courteous, since most of their customers are regulars from the town, especially cops. Regular pizza slices are decently priced for their humongous size. However, their «specialty» slices (while tasty) are a bit on the pricey side, and I’m always taken aback at my total after I’ve ordered and gotten my total.
I definitely give this place loads of cred for being not only customer-​oriented, but COMMUNITY oriented. This restaurant does a lot for the Woodland Park community, and is very generous. I will continue to frequent on the basis of their service, and SOME of their menu items.

Surprisingly good pizza for such a small location.
Slices are very large and prices are extremely reasonable. We have uesd this location to have pizza delivered as well for local functions and have never had an issue.

I feel badly that this review will be negative but lucky for Pizza City their pizzeria is always packed with customers. Tonight my husband ordered two calzones and a order of mussels. Very simple in my opinion. However when he got the food home my calzone was really burnt at the bottom and the mussels we were going to share were God awful! If you are going to have frozen, disgusting mussels just take them off the menu-wouldn’t that be easier? We won’t be returning.

Not impressed with the product. Ordered a margherita pizza and garlic knots to go. The knots were good, but the pizza fell flat. I hate to use this word to describe pizza, but it was downright bland. Adding some spices to the sauce would go a long way.
The staff here was courteous enough, but we saw our to-​go order sit for more than a few minutes before a manager noticed my date get up to ask about it. It did get pretty busy for one cashier to take care of everyone, but with the amount of people working there, I think it could have been a little more efficient. Also, the cleaning agent used to sanitize the tables smells awful, even from across the restaurant. No plans to return. :(

Great pizza, great prices and great people .
Wonderful pizza combinations and now with the gluten free pizza options, it is perfect for the whole family !!!‘mmm

A childhood favorite love the pizza. Huge slices best pasta around. Just in general great food and great service.

Everything I got in my delivery order tasted like it was freezer burnt and reheated. Yuck.
Don’t call pizza city unless you want dry, soggy mozzerella sticks, rice balls or a tasteless Angelo roll.
Hope you’re not hungry for salad or bread, you’ll recieve a pauper’s portion of both with your entrée.
The one glimmer of hopeI have for this place is that their Chicken Saltimbocca was decent.
Meh.

Can’t say I had much else besides the pizza, but it’s DELICIOUS! Huge slices. Absolutely love the pepperoni.

Meh, huge nice sized slices (think quantity not quality).The sandwiches and basically every other item on the menu is nothing to rave about. Lunch specials have extremely small portions for the actual entre, however for $ 7 salad, bread, and main meal how can you complain?

Ugh, just ordered delivery and the pizza was warm and burnt. Prefer hot and evenly cooked. Dissatisfied with the pizza, also wondering why anyone would let a pie go out like that would’ve been better if’d they’d made a new one and let us know it was gonna take longer. Didn’t bother to get a replacement as we were hungry and waiting was not an option.

My coworkers and I go here for their lunch specials. I’m a fan of the Chicken Marsala which comes with a salad, bread and a soda for $ 6.50. Lots of other entrée choices as well.
I also enjoy the personal sized brick oven pizza lunch special or any other of their regular pies. Buffalo Chicken Pizza is another of my favorites.
Overall great place, great food, great staff and great prices!

Gotta love the extra large slices they have! You can also buy the 22″ jumbo pie! It’s a great deal! The only thing is that my husband is embarrsed when he picks up the jumbo pie since the box is extra large! He feels like a gavone! lol!

Went for lunch today and got the lunch special. $ 6.50 for salad, bread, entrée, and a drink is a great deal. It’s even valid on Saturday. We have also had the brick oven pizza, also good. The pizza slices of regular pizza are the biggest around.