Theo’s Pizza and Sandwiches

Ordered room service to AmericInn. Enjoyed their Gyro & onion rings so much we ordered them 2 days in a row. The second day we also added a pizza. Great service & really great food. I came to live gyros & pizza growing up in Chicago. Theo’s gets a thumbs up!

They have some new menu items besides pizza. Love their gyros… They are HUGE! The seating area is a little lackluster, but the food more than makes up for it. Try to sit as far away from the ice machine as possible. :)

The new menu items are the best.

Between the pizza and the restaurant itself I’m having a hard time giving Theo’s more than just two stars. First impressions tells me this place is in dire need of a remodel. The space for customers to eat is dark and uninviting. The counter top where you pay is so high up that it’s almost uncomfortable to do a transaction. The pizza (pepperoni) is just average in my opinion and nothing special to make me keep wanting to eat it. The crust has potential, it’s deep but remains too doughy in the center and you can taste the overused butter used in the dough. It does however have a good crisp on the outside and bottom. The sauce is good but could use a little improvement in its tanginess. Theo’s also has a decent selection of toppings including gyro meat on their Mediterranean or a white alfredo pizza that I haven’t yet tried if I’m desperate enough to go back. Is it better than the major chain pizzas? Just barely. In fact there’s even one I prefer over Theo’s. I really hope this place improves because it does have potential but there’s so much competition that they need to stand out somehow.

Friendly service greeted me when I walked in the door… and the pizza was pleasing as well. Greek style, the dough was fresh and the toppings were plentiful. I would definitely stop in again if i’m in town.

This is a great local pizza place.
Order the Mediterranean pizza with tzeki (sp) on the side.

We were too tired to cook, and pizza was the plan. After looking at our options, we settled on Theo’s since we wanted one locally made, rather than a «big chain gang» type. What a delight! We got the meat lovers version, and it was delicious! It took about 20 minutes from the time I called in. As soon as it arrived at the dinner table, we were enjoying the best pizza in these parts!!! The pizza guy was really nice, the food was great, and we will surely be back. I want to give that Med a try next! YUM!

I’m sure there will be people who may disagree with my love of Theo’s. No, they do not make pizza on a cracker for those that love really thin pizza, but they do their best to accommodate a special request. In my humble opinion, if you want a great pizza for a reasonable price, give Theo’s a try. As Merlin says in the 1981 movie «Excalibur»…“Savor it, and rejoice in it with great gladness,” for you may have found the Excalibur of pizzas.

This is really a hole in the wall, but the pizza was great! Especially the crust!