Cady Cheese Factory

Do you like cheese? If you like cheese at all, you have to have to try cheese from Cady Cheese Factory. Cheese from Cady is like eating a frozen meal or a fresh meal. Ok maybe its not quite that extreme, but I think you get the point. I love cheese. Cheese is so flexible. You can add it endless meals. Our favorite cheese to get at Cady bar none is their colby. Its soo good. We also love the baby swiss, sharp cheddar and everyone loves cheese curds. Everything is fresh and those cheese curds squeek when you chew them. They also carry Parmesan and endless options of jack cheeses. We always get a couple of pounds of their colby, some sharp cheddar, cheese curds and then a few others to try. On our way home we eat a few slices of the colby and some cheese curds. I think their prices are very reasonable compared to cheese costs in the grocery store. The other factor and it really doesn’t matter in our house because we will eat it all, their fresh cheese seems to last longer and stay fresher than store bought cheese. Although when we come home with a bag of cheese for Cady, seems like we make more grilled cheese sandwiches during that time. We really love Cady and the ladies in the shop are always friendly. Cady is a short drive from the metro area but well worth it. There is also a great bison ranch just down the road so you could pick up some cheese and some bison on the same trip. Can’t wait to make our next trip to Cady Cheese.

Cady Cheese has run away with my cheesy heart.
It’s true. My family has been stopping at Cady for years on our many jaunts between Milwaukee and the Twin Cities. We actually schedule our routes to make sure we’ll go through when they’re open.
If you’re under the impression that you’ve had Wisconsin cheese simply because something says it’s from WI on the label or (god forbid!) it’s shaped like the state of WI or a cow, you are wrong. If you are under the impression you’ve had cheese curds, because you ordered some deep fried in a bar once, you are severely wrong. You need to have chees that is wet and squeaky. I know that sounds weird, but it’s not. If it wasn’t made in the last 48 hours, it’s just not the same.
Cady Cheese has cheeses by the cheesy handful. When you walk in there’s a case of pre-​packaged chunks, as well as some ends and pieces. The ends and pieces are a great way to jump in on some wacky flavor. But, if you want the really really good stuff, walk to either side of the counter and wait your turn. When it’s your turn, ask any and every question you like. They will most likely give you a sample of everything you show a mild interest in, but if they don’t, just ask. The only reason they might not is if it’s not something they do fresh cuts of. Once you’ve decided if you’d rather have aged cheddar or baby swiss or Colby made yesterday (my favorite), tell them some weight, they’ll lop off a hunk and wrap it up for you.
Is it the cheapest cheese on the planet? No. Is it the best? Possibly. Don’t forget to get a bag of curds… they will be squeaky and you will love them.
They sell other things in the store, but I go for the cheese. Take the time to stop if you’re driving through, you’re cheesebuds will thank you.

Worth the detour off HWY 94. Amazing cheese, meats, and customer service! My first taste of cheeses curds, best smoked gouda cheese ever!

If I could give Cady 6 stars, I totally would!
We literally get ALL of our cheese from here. Once a month or so we make a little trip to Cady and stock up on Sharp Cheddar, Parmesan, Gorganzola, Baby Swiss and maybe a couple of the random varieties of Jack. The Onion-​Garlic Jack, Cranberry-​Chipotle Jack and BBQ Jack are a few of our favorites. (I know, I sound like a cheese glutton here… but seriously, think about how much cheese you buy for a whole month!)
The cheese is extremely well-​priced for the high quality and variety. If you’re really looking for a bargain, check out the «ends and pieces» bin, which is basically the cheese at the end of a batch that doesn’t come out in the perfect square or circle mold.
Why buy cheese from the grocery store, when this amazing cheese factory is within driving distance?! If you’re coming from the cities, make a day out of it and go down to Sailer’s Meats in Elmwood — it’s a beautiful drive and they have an excellent selection of meat from local farmers.
Support your LOCAL small dairy farmers!

Went in here to try to buy some fresh cheese curds and some lady gave me a look like I was dog shit of the bottom of her shoe.
Clerk: Waddya looking for?
Me: I was looking for fresh cheese curds.
Clerk: (Nasty tone of voice) We’re outta curds!
All the time giving me some dour look. After service like that, I really couldn’t work up interest in some of their other fine items like, Nut and Chocolate Clusters called Cow Flops, Turkey Jerky or T-​Shirts that say Favre Sucks.
The product may be good. But one asshole ruined it for me.