Kacey’s Twin Eatery

Sausage pizza is the best. Great coke shop. Coke in the glass bottle is the best. Seriously best pizza ever

Kasey’s Twin Eatery is a quaint little food spot in Whiteland, IN. We were directed here by a friendly local guy while looking at some antique gas station signs near by.
The place is a small little eatery decorated in Coca Cola memorabilia. The set up is a little weird at first; you order pizza at one counter and all your other food at another counter.
We ordered a large pizza with hamburger and black olives as well as 2 orders of spaghetti for the kids.
The pizza was amazing; a close cousin to a Chicago style pizza with thick thick mozzarella cheese on top. The crust was perfectly browned and the tomato sauce was just right.
The spaghetti was also really good. A mound of buttered spaghetti noodles complimented with a nice robust marinara sauce. Each plate came with a big tossed salad and Italian bread on the side.
This was a great unexpected find while on vacation visiting the area. All my Hoosier friends and family are lucky to have this close by.

Excellent pizza.

I wasn’t too impressed, as I first time customer, but it’s likely I will return for a second impression. I like the interior, although a little dim in the dining area. I wouldn’t call this a typical dinner date spot. I do want this place to stay around, since it’s great business for the Whiteland Community. Here’s a few things I liked:
Pros:
Front counter gave me a large foam cup for just water! Amazing… now I didn’t have to make multiple visits to the refill station.
The amount of bread was generous, although a little too buttery.
Interior décor was decorated well with a Coca-​Cola theme. It wasn’t boring, but had lots of memorabilia to look at.
Cons:
The Lasagna was a little bare without much of a ricotta layer. Cheese layer was spotty… not a full layer.
The salad was as cheap tasting as possible: not tasty shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes, and shredded cheddar cheese. Also came in foam, like the drink.
They are too foam happy. I’d rather see paper cups that can be better recycled. Why can’t they use regular drinking cups that they can wash?
They only accept cash, not credit/​debit.
I would recommend to try yourself to get your own personal opinion. Next time, I will try pizza.

Food is great. Sandwiches are the best. Pizza is great. The Owner Operaters Have great customer service. the coke memorabilia is just icing on the cake. It is a must see.

I don’t know why I waited so long to try this place out! I love mom and pop joints and this place definitely fits the bill. They have a pretty large menu, with pizza, sandwiches, and pasta. Plus, the décor is pretty sweet, it’s a mini Coca Cola museum, the walls are covered with memorabilia.
I generally always get the spaghetti lunch special. For $ 8.04 (after tax) you get a large plate of spaghetti, garlic bread, a salad, and a drink (free refills). You have to place your order at the counter and get refills yourself, but they bring your food out to whatever booth or table you’re at.
Oh another big thing. Cash or check only!

I love this place. The pizzas are great and I love the stromboli sub. We eat here frequently. The staff is always friendly.

Not a fan, I know many people like it but not for me…

5 stars, seriously, 5 stars all around. The pizza here is loaded with a hearty amount of mouth dominating cheese and toppings. The environment is top notch and looks like a mini coca cola museum. Plus, this a ma and pa place in its truest form and the friendly service puts this on display at all times.
Pros:
Incredible Pizza, serious, maybe the best in the area
Friendly People
Museum
Bottle Cap Tic Tac Toe
Glass Bottled Cokes
Friendship
Cons:
They don’t take debit/​credit
Even with the debit card issue, their is a Key Bank ATM directly next to Kacey’s so this should be the least of your worries. The 10,000 lbs of friendship at this place should cover any squabbling inconveniences you might have. Much love

They do not take debit/​credit cards. I have had the lasagna and the pizza and both were way to greasy and rubbery. Not very good in my opinion…

Amazing food. And great prices. 5 stars!

My family and I had dinner here tonight and it was excellent. This is a great place to relax and have dinner with the family. It is very cozy and they have tons of Coca-​Cola stuff everywhere! We’ve been here a few times before and had their pizza, which is good, but tonight we had our favorite the baked lasagna. They have a nice menu to choose from, so I’m sure you’ll find something you like. They have great service here, they are very nice. I’d have to say that it’s a bit of an inconvenience that they don’t take debit or credit cards, but yet they take checks? If you are driving along US 31 and happen to see Kacey’s, give it a try you’ll become a fan!