Paradise Pizza & More

These guys, and gals, are GREAT. If I have ONE complaint it would be. you get TOO much for your money:):).LOL I was watching football one afternoon. Ordered a large cheese pizza and told them I couldn’t find my coupon for a free small pizza with the purchase of any large, they said don’t worry and gave it to me anyways.. So for $ 11.95 I got a large AND a small cheese pizza. NO one on the Cape can top that.
Another time I went in. I am in a wheelchair and asked if I ordered a pizza would they come bring it to my car. and .of course they said yes. The owner was putting together pizza boxes and was playful with his help .They were VERY busy but everyone waiting was very patient because they knew they were going to get great food and that its a small family business. The staff knew some customers by name, askjng how this person and that person was. I sat and had a beer and watched for nearly ½ hour and was so touched. The owner and I talked about the Yankees and Mets from the 70s. Overall, it is such a pleasure to being their customer.
My spinach and sausage calzone came .It was SO HEAVY, I got home and got 3 meals out of it for $ 9.95. I am a HUGE fan of supporting your local business. If I buy ONE pizza/​calzone a month, thats $ 120 in a local business pocket and not Dominos. If just 10 people switch to them that’s $ 1200 for a small business.
1) Dominos will survive without your $ 120 a year
2) Paradise delivers too
3)You get MORE food for your money
4) Its a family business and damn nice people at that!!!
5) they have specialty pizzas that are awesome, different and VERY nicely priced
6) and MOST OF ALL., .their pizza and calzones are MUCH BETTER
Tell them Griz sent you!!!

We ordered paradise pizza after a lazy evening in our hotel. We ordered a Caesar salad, jalapeño poppers, and chicken Parmesan. We received the chicken Parmesan and jalapeño poppers after about 50 minutes. The delivery guy was nice but said he just noticed our salad wasn’t included in the bag. They sent the salad after and it took about 30 more minutes. They offered no discounts or complimentary dessert for their mistake. We paid full price for a meal that took almost an hour to get in the first place and then was not complete and took an additional 30 minutes to receive.

Great Food… Fast delivery… Pizza was very good, Steak and Cheese Sub was loaded with Meat on a large roll. Jalapeño Poppers were awesome.

Best pizza place in the world and Joey is a great guy! I’ve been going here for 25+ years! Highly recommend!

I just discovered Paradise Pizza this year and brought my son three times during our vacation. Awesome pizza, great sauce, and really friendly service. My go-​to pizza place from now on when I visit!

I will say, Paradise Pizza has redeemed themselves this summer. I’ve ordered multiple times this summer and have been pleased every time. Their calzones are HUGE and can easily feed 2 – 3 people with one. I had an onion/​artichoke pizza the other day that was great. I am very happy with the quality of food I have gotten this summer.

Picked up some grub after the beach, but didn’t notice that an item was missing until I got it home. Turns out that I wasn’t charged for the item, but this was the 2^nd time it happened, so… Shame on me.
That being said, I continue to go back because the food is great — just double check the order before you leave.

New Yorkers now living on the Cape and this pizza is phenomenal! Sauce is delicious crust is perfect. If you like a nice thick pizza this is it! They have gluten free options as well. Joey and employees were very personable and friendly on the phone. Can’t wait to try some other things on the menu soon!

It was pretty good. I’d give it 3.5 stars if I could. We are picky pizza eaters from CT. Only tried Paradise once and got a single medium cheese pie. Good portion — perfect for two people to split. Crust was crispy and the temp of the pie was great. Only downside was how greasy it was. Some people like this, but it was a bit of a turn off for us. We still ate the whole thing, for what that’s worth. If you’re just stopping in for a quick slice then it’s fine. The subs actually looked good though I didn’t try them. I don’t want to be hard on the place, but we did have pizza twice while we visited the Cape and another location was much better. Different style though.

We’ve ordered from paradise the last 2 times we’ve been here on the Cape. Coming from NYC, we know good pizza and Paradise piza’s thin crust is fabulous. Thanks for the great meal!

Cape Cod isn’t known for great pizza, but this place could change that. Their standard pie is a little thicker than a typical NY thin crust, but the sauce and cheese mixture is spot on. The crust itself has just the right combination of crispy and chewy. We also tried their «Forget About it» wrap with breaded eggplant, fresh basil, fresh mozzarella, and roasted red peppers. It was amazing! The best Italian restaurants use simple fresh ingredients to maximize flavor. This principle is alive and well at Paradise Pizza. Enjoy!

We wanted to like Paradise Pizza, but we need to keep looking for our pizza place on the Cape.
It’s really close to our house, but we are picky pizza eaters and pleasing us is not easy. Honestly, I would rather make grilled pizza at home than eat something that’s only okay.
We got two pizzas, a pepperoni and a Mediterranean (feta, olives, tomatoes) for a pick up order. To be fair, it was fine, just not good enough for us. Decent dough, cooked well and good helping of toppings. We used a special coupon so I can’t comment on if it’s priced fairly.
It just wasn’t as good as our homemade pizza using store bought dough. If we wanted delivery or take out to the beach, we would consider it again.

Garlic rolls. Little tasty tender knots of goodness dusted with Parmesan cheese and parsley.

Coming from nj, pizza capital of the world, the pizza here is ok. Not nj good but definitely better than I thought it would be.
Delivery was fast and would order again but next time I would ask for the pie to be well done as the pie was a bit undercooked for me (I like it more on the burned side)
Only down side really was the price 19 bucks for a pepperoni pie and 16 oz coke

A group of us staying in Dennis Port ordered a large number of pizzas from Paradise with 2 different toppings, pepperoni and their Key West Vegetable Delight. It took a little longer for the pizzas to be delivered than quoted, but the pizzas remained hot. The crusts were slightly soggy (an allowance I always make for delivery), but the toppings were generous, especially the Key West Vegetable Delight. That was so loaded you couldn’t pick it up; you either had to use a fork and knife or slide the pizza across the plate so an edge was sticking over to eat. The pepperoni pizza was somewhat greasy, but that is not necessarily a bad thing; many people like it that way, including myself. If you don’t like it that way, don’t order it. I’d love to try a fresh out of the oven pizza from them sometime.

Whether you’re on vacation or just a semi-​local like me grabbing lunch or dinner, eat here for delicious, fresh food in a clean and friendly restaurant. Huge menu with tons of choices — pizza, calzones, wraps, salads, the list goes on and on. Joey makes sure the ingredients are fresh, his name is on the sign, so you know the food comes from someone who cares. And he really knows how to make some incredible combinations — just ask for the Forgetaboutit wrap!
I’ve only been here once, but look forward to trying all the menu items. I get the feeling that everything on the menu is delicious.
Ambiance is unique, lots of good sized tables, it’s like a dining room /​living room setting. There are a couple of TVs with different channels on, so sit next to what you want to watch. :-) Can’t say enough positive things about Paradise (aptly named!) and most of all can’t wait to go back and try more items.

Another one of those local gems that have the best italian food around. Quality, quantity, service, and a price which actually makes you expect less. Outstanding spot!

After a few months of frequenting Paradise, I have noticed it has gone very downhill. Our last experience was the final straw for my husband and I. When we called for delivery, we were told we would receive our food in 30 minutes. An hour and 10 minutes later, my husband had to call to remind them of our order. The person on the phone was rude and our order was wrong. The owner has also gotten very grumpy. To go from super friendly at the beginning of the season to just plain rude at the end of the season is quite a switch, especially if you are planning on remaining open year round. I am very sad to see such a promising place go so far downhill. We used to love it, but I doubt we will ever return now.

4 girls at the counter. All writing and rewriting slips and occasionally answering the phone. No greeting, no communication, people with take out orders forced to wait in same line., most inefficient operation I’ve ver experienced. Honestly thought I was on candid camera. I can’t imagine they get any repeat customers.

Continues to serve delicious hot subs. tuna is my to go favorite. the owner is chill, won’t welcome you with open arms but is a kind man… support a local biz on the way to windy West Dennis beach, y’all kiters and windsurfers…